Emilio Pagán is the only MLB reliever with an ERA+ below 100 and negative Win Probability Added every season since 2020.

2020: 94 ERA+, -1.0 WPA
2021: 81 ERA+, -0.6 WPA
2022: 89 ERA+, -1.0 WPA
2023: 79 ERA+, -0.3 WPA

His combined -2.9 WPA since 2020 is dead last for relievers.

— Aaron Gleeman (@AaronGleeman) May 18, 2023