Jump to content

mdonnelly21

Veteran Members
  • Content Count

    1,208
  • Joined

  • Last visited

Community Reputation

32 Rookie

Recent Profile Visitors

The recent visitors block is disabled and is not being shown to other users.

  1. A Rod fell out IMO #1. RW #2. Patrick Maholmes #3. Henry Although I'm pulling for a RB in Henry this season
  2. I think you nailed it. Generally White WR's obv as athletic either. A lot of the more athletic WR's who are black end up getting overrated because of the highlight reel. I'm trying to be objective about it. No he isn't top 3 but I don't think it's good enough to just say he's top 10 either. But I'd at least be fine with top 10 otherwise he does get underrated.
  3. Oh yeah? Julio Hopkins Thomas Odell Evans Adams I would put Adam right behind those guys and it's close
  4. 2017: 91 for 1,276, 4 TD's 2018: 113 for 1,373, 9 TD's And continues to work this year... I don't feel like Adam Thielan doesn't get enough credit and IMO is comfortably a borderline top 5 WR in the league
  5. It's going by Grade 100 doesn't exist. It's perfect Nothing under a 55 since we are going by grades
  6. Which pairing would you take and why? T.O and Calvin Johnson or Randy Moss/Marvin Harrison?
  7. 55 is the worst WR of all time. Rice and Moss tied for the best WR of all time with a 99. 1. Jerry Rice 99 2. Randy Moss 99 3. T.O - 98 4. Calvin Johnson 98 5. Sterling Sharpe 97 6. Larry Fitzgerald 97 7. Marvin Harrison 97 8. Antonio Brown 97 9. Michael Irving 96 10. Cris Carter 96 11. Andre Johnson 96 12. Lance Alworth 96 13. Tory Holt 96 14. Steve Largent 95 15. Isaac Bruce 95 16. James Lofton 95 17. Reggie Wayne 95 18. Art Monk 95 19. Fred Biletnikoff 94 20. Raymond Berry 94 21. Steve Smith 94 22. Andre Reed 94 23. Julio Jones 94 24. Charlie Joiner 93 25. Charley Taylor 93 H/M - Paul Warfied, Jimmy Smith, Anquan Boldin
  8. Your rankings for Moss/T.O and Calvin is are lit and very close to mine. I think AB has a case for like a 96 though he was legit for like 5 years straight
  9. Peak RANDY is a 99/100. I'd probably give both Megatron and T.O a 98 1. Hopkins 95 2. Julio 95 3. Thomas 95 4. Hill 94 5. Adams 93 If you're feeling like it go ahead and do your top 10
  10. For what its worth I'm not surprised by the results. Michael Thomas is probably less far ahead of Hopkins/Julio then Hopkins and Julio are ahead of Hill. It just shows me that those 3 are in a tier of their own and Hill is just on the outside.
  11. The point of doing this was because those are generally the top 4 WRs Michael Thomas being regarded as the BEST Wideout Then Hopkins/Julio being 2A & 2B and Hill comfortably #4. So I wanted to see how the #1 & #4 would far against #2 & #3.
×
×
  • Create New...