Jump to content


Veteran Members
  • Content count

  • Joined

  • Last visited

Community Reputation

19 Prospect
  1. Looking to the future draft.. (yes already)

    I agree on the need for an OL, the first things we should look for in this draft is a franchise QB, If none is there then we need to get a tackle, preferable a LT to finally upgrade this OL.
  2. Looking to the future draft.. (yes already)

    You are ignoring the comment by not acknowledging where in the draft they were picked and what rounds. That draft had rookies that produced and played roles in at least one Super Bowl winning team. If another team signs Kevin Boss to more money that in no way meant he was not a good player for the Giants. What matters to me is how this players played while a Giant. Kevin Boss played good enough to make Jeremey Shockey a Pro-Bowl and All-Pro player expandable. A major injury is what made Steve Smith a shell of himself but he was still a good player for the Giants and Steve Smith did make a Pro-Bowl. Production is expected from the players drafted in the first first three rounds. When you get great production from the rounds drafted after, that is special. Gettleman is most likely going to have a Top 5 draft pick, and it is not going to be surprise to anyone that his first two draft picks are going to be great, it would be a great disappointment if they were not. As for Sam Darnold, he plays on a bad team with a defensive head coach and his all of his skilled position players are the very meaning of JAG. Till the Giants get a franchise QB, the future of the Jets is a lot brighter than ours.
  3. Tom Brady still has a decent offensive line he can play behind. Eli (and most QB's) can't function behind this one. If you want to start Tanney fine, but there is no need to start Lauletta in there before he is ready. Why are you in a rush to take the Texans approach and turn Lauletta into David Carr, instead of taking the Kansas City approach with Patrick Mahomes?
  4. Why would they not be favored? They have beaten some good teams we have not. They have a legitimate run game, we just lost the leagues best run stopping Nose Guard. They have a good defensive line that can rush the passer our offensive line sucks pretty badly.
  5. Looking to the future draft.. (yes already)

    Are you ignoring the main point I was making on purpose, or are simply not old enough to remember the 2007 Giants? If the latter then I can see where you are coming from with your comments.
  6. Giants trade Eli Apple to Saints

    Nor does it mean that it is the case. Plus with him being traded I think word would have got out by now if he was traded because he was being a problem again. To me it feels like Gettleman wants to purge the Giants as much as possible of every draft pick that Reese had made.
  7. Giants trade Eli Apple to Saints

    Key word is last season. If this trade was done last season that would have made sense. He was given a fresh start this season, I have not heard anything about him being a problem in the locker room this season.
  8. Giants trade Eli Apple to Saints

    This trade to me seem pretty much one sided in the Saints favor. The Saints are getting a decent #2 QB that is still on his rookie contract. Giants still have to take on 2.3 million in dead money next year from Eli. The secondary is already a weakness for the Giants and now they just traded their #2 CB? Another genius Gettleman move.
  9. Eli Apple traded to New Orleans Saints

    Is a 4th and 7th the best we could do? I am thinking a decent #2 corner should be able to get us at least a 3rd round pick.
  10. Looking to the future draft.. (yes already)

    A little early to be going for it.
  11. Looking to the future draft.. (yes already)

    We already saw how he gauges the QB. If it was easy to get a franchise QB then many NFL teams would not have struggled in getting one. Will the Giants have the #1 QB fall in their laps once again. Who knows, they should have taken the franchise QB this year when he was there for them. If you are going to base everything off of their first draft then compare Reese first draft in 2007 to Gettleman current draft, looked where they picked and say who did the better job.
  12. Looking to the future draft.. (yes already)

    Let me change that to I don't have complete faith in Gettleman to find our next QB as if he is some draft guru that others seem to believe he is.
  13. Looking to the future draft.. (yes already)

    Looking at his last couple of draft, I don't believe Engram, Tomlinson, Eli Apple or Sterling Shepard are bust. And your making my point for me, yes most GM should have a different if not better draft if they are picking at 2 instead of 9. Yes Gettleman got us some talented players from this draft , most GM's would have gotten us some talented player given where we picked. Odds are they are going to have a top 5 draft picks next year, so yes he is going to get us more talented players next year just like most any GM would picking in that position. Do I trust him to find our next QB, no. If he had an eye for a QB he would have taken Sam Darnold.
  14. Week 7 MNF: New York Giants @ Atlanta Falcons

    I agree on the first part that Odell can't make headlines on the field because of the o-line and the QB. But I agree totally with Mara that Odell should not be making headlines off the field. Odell should be a leader not a distraction, I don't believe a person can be both and be productive.
  15. Looking to the future draft.. (yes already)

    Who says Cleveland got it right? If you believe picking with the 9th pick in the draft is just as good as picking with the 2nd pick in the draft then there is nothing more that needs to be said on this.