Jump to content


  • Content count

  • Joined

  • Last visited

Community Reputation

30 Rookie
  1. Aaron Rodgers Appreciation Thread 4.0

    He has a bad/injured OL , injured receiving corp with one legit receiver, a RB who doesn't get the ball,a bad defense, a bad coach, bad kicker, and a bum knee. Packers fans are about as stubborn as they come.
  2. You Are In Control. Who Replaces McCarthy?

    I'm not sold on DeFilippo either, but he did have a hand in an offense which won a SB with a backup QB. How did McCarthy's offense stack up with a backup? Anyway, he doesn't have Rodgers and he has one of the worst OLs in the league. Minnesota's OC from a year ago isn't looking so hot now, nor is Keenum, so that was just a fluke year from all parties involved, not a basis for comparison. There are clearly issues with personnel which were hidden, presumably because the defense was playing at such a high level. Frank Reich is doing a fantastic job in Indy without an All Star supporting cast around Luck, and he has absolutely no play calling duties in Philadelphia. Vrabel coached one of the worst defenses in the league last year, now he has one of the best . Gute will have to do more than simply look at NFL.com stats to determine if a coach can succeed here, just as other GMs shouldn't judge McCarthy solely by his offense's stats with the most talented and improvisational QB and of all time.
  3. You Are In Control. Who Replaces McCarthy?

    McCarthy has Rodgers and looks like a bum, so, no. He'd play to the weaknesses of the offense and the strengths of the defense and make executing a simple play look like performing open heart surgery.
  4. You Are In Control. Who Replaces McCarthy?

    I vote Outpost, because he clearly understand the QB position better than Aaron Rodgers and will be able to teach him how to play properly.
  5. Aaron Rodgers Appreciation Thread 4.0

    He has a coach who actively works to make things more difficult on the entire team.
  6. You Are In Control. Who Replaces McCarthy?

    He's not an offensive coach. Several DCs from that tree have been successful elsewhere. The #1 defense in the league has a former NE defensive coordinator. The best college coach of all time was a DC under Bill B.
  7. Aaron Rodgers Depreciation Thread

    It's almost as if coming off a serious upper body injury and tearing your knee within 3 regular season games could have an effect on the performance of the QB. But no, let's ignore the running game and hang him out to dry with young receivers instead of making things easier on him.
  8. You Are In Control. Who Replaces McCarthy?

    We will have competition with Atlanta who have more talent on both sides of the ball. This move should have been made years ago.
  9. Mike Pettine Defense

    I'm not giving gold stars to a defense giving up 30 PPG
  10. Mike Pettine Defense

    Not for QBs like Beathard and Alex Smith. Other than two stat padders against Brock Osweiller and Josh Allen, this has been a horrible unit and a downgrade from the one the year prior.
  11. You Are In Control. Who Replaces McCarthy?

    This season has presented a perfect opportunity for McCarthy to implement the running game to take the pressure off an injured QB and young receivers, and for the defense to come together under a new coordinator.... and they have failed miserably. Goodbye, McCarthy.
  12. Extend Mike McCarthy?

  13. Aaron Rodgers Depreciation Thread

    No you can't. You look at things like butthurt fans, not with an unbiased, realistic point of view. Either way, his knee is torn. Why are we only running the ball 11 times?
  14. Aaron Rodgers Depreciation Thread

    You have no idea what an open receiver looks like. Our receivers are handcuffed to CBs compared to receivers on teams who don't have horrific offensive coaches.
  15. Week 11 GDT: GB @ Seattle TreeSloths

    How about we give the Qb a FIRST READ for a first down instead of expecting him to survey the entire field in 2 seconds line you geniuses.