Jump to content

Patriotplayer90

Members
  • Content count

    70
  • Joined

  • Last visited

Community Reputation

12 Prospect
  1. Packers Off-season Mini-Camp/Training Camp Discussion Thread

    I see little difference between having Hundley and some of the better guys that you listed. Unless you have an excellent roster which requires the absolute bare minimum from a QB, you will not win consistently with a backup caliber QB like Fitzpatrick , McCown, etc. Backups are either extremely limited, extremely inconsistent, or both. You keep referring to cap space as if TT actually spent it. He did not. $20M will not turn a crap team with no QB into a winning one. It can add an impact player, sure, or a couple of good ones, but you are playing with fire with Fitz Magic as your QB and it won't matter. Bottom line, teams without good QBs are not good, or inconsistent, at best. Rodgers would solidify the position with the best player in the league and give any team a chance, every single week
  2. Packers Off-season Mini-Camp/Training Camp Discussion Thread

    Your argument makes no sense. Other teams have "Better QBs" and "More Cap space", but still perform just as poorly as Hundley and his cash-strapped roster. Explain....
  3. Packers Off-season Mini-Camp/Training Camp Discussion Thread

    If our record wasn't completely putrid without Rodgers as a starter since 2008, I could give him credit. But our winning percentage has been as bad as other poor teams with no QB, so a very strong argument could be made that he could turn any team into a contender .
  4. Packers Off-season Mini-Camp/Training Camp Discussion Thread

    Which was totally because of a well-rounded roster featuring Gunter as the #1 CB and the 31st ranked passing defense, and not our All World QB scoring 44 TDs.
  5. Packers Off-season Mini-Camp/Training Camp Discussion Thread

    Ted Thompson showed how to nearly ruin an organization in no time with the way he handled the 2015-17 seasons. Rodgers getting injured and exposing the incompetence around him is the only thing giving him another shot at a SB ring.
  6. Do you sell the Hundley stock while it is high?

    Many of the great plays that Rodgers makes are off-script and are executed in incredibly small windows. Every game, he makes plays that other QBs rarely make, if ever. And he can just manipulate the defense in the way only an elite experienced QB can.. All of this, and the highest QB rating ever, yet we still barely reach the playoffs with him at QB. I'm not sure what backup QB could have kept this sinking ship afloat. Don't his backups have more INTs than TDs thrown? If that happens in what is perceived to be a great offense, I'm thinking the QB is the one who actually makes it work, making a 5 star meal out of cafeteria ingredients.
  7. Packers Off-season Mini-Camp/Training Camp Discussion Thread

    How is it a fluke if he did the same thing just two years ago? And had a higher winning percentage?
  8. Packers Off-season Mini-Camp/Training Camp Discussion Thread

    Exactly. And he isn't Gute's guy. The difference is, most backup OL suck. If he's not doing anything disruptive to the rest of the team, he's not likely to go anywhere
  9. Packers Off-season Mini-Camp/Training Camp Discussion Thread

    Murphy didn't exactly get beat by a regular rusher or pass rushing move. That was some next-level Von Miller caliber bend by Harold Landry. You have to applaud a good play by a talented player sometimes.
  10. Packers Off-season Mini-Camp/Training Camp Discussion Thread

    Saying that he could be better would be a valid point, if he didn't have the best QB rating of all time by a pretty good margin. Maybe he knows and sees things that you don't. The last point is just silly. He's sensitive, sure. He's also, by all accounts, a genuine, decent guy. He gives reporters and everyone else the respect to answer questions in a thoughtful and meaningful way. His family sucks, by the way. I lived in Nashville, his brother is a total weasel.
  11. Packers Off-season Mini-Camp/Training Camp Discussion Thread

    Agreed. But you are criticizing Aaron Rodgers on a Green Bay forum. What did you expect?
  12. Packers Off-season Mini-Camp/Training Camp Discussion Thread

    You are basically demanding perfection. He's got a 99 playoff QB rating with very few blemishes, and he even closed out those games well. You are nitpicking and not being realistic in any way. Just like you nitpicked that one stat. The Raiders allowed fewer PPG than us, and Carr had no shortage of talent on offense.
  13. Packers Off-season Mini-Camp/Training Camp Discussion Thread

    You are basically demanding perfection. He's got a 99 playoff QB rating with very few blemishes, and he even closed out those games well. You are nitpicking and not being realistic in any way.
  14. Packers Off-season Mini-Camp/Training Camp Discussion Thread

    Carr won 7 games last year with a more talented team last year. Lol. So he's been carrying poor defenses to the playoffs for years, to the point of breaking his body, won despite poor defensive efforts in the playoffs, yet you throw him under the bus for a few games? He wasn't close to 100 percent in two of those losses, and his receiving group was beyond poor in the other,. He gave them a chance to win in all of them within late game drives, and the defense blew all of them. He's been exceptional otherwise, something you can't say for the defense.
  15. Packers Off-season Mini-Camp/Training Camp Discussion Thread

    Your argument is that this is a 10 win team without Rodgers. Which destroys any of your credibility. We were close to the top of the league in offense in 2013 when he missed half the year , and we won 2 games. And just happened to have a horrific defense sandwiched between 2 seasons of respectable, above average units. You can't compare his impact to that of any other QB. He doesn't have the best QB rating of All Time, which blows away that of his backups, for no reason.
×