Daniel

If being a borderline top 10 QB for your career gets you a HOF spot, then we should just change the name to Hall of the Good and Kinda Good QBs.

That was mostly in jest. It gets brought up every year. I just wondered if people think Miami is the special case that would lose to a college team, or at least, people who don't think that regularly, since the consensus seems to be that the Dolphins are special, bad special, but special nonetheless.

So....could they beat Alabama?

OK, let me break down for you why it's a bad idea (and why two firsts would be an absolutely horrifyingly awful idea). Let's say the Bears call us up, and say, hey, Kevin Byard is the best free safety in the league, right? We will give you a first round draft pick and Eddie Jackson for him, and also, we'll pick up the tab on his guaranteed money. You would take that in a heartbeat, wouldn't you? After all, not only would the downgrade from Byard to Jackson be a really small one, but it would save a ton of cap money that could go elsewhere and give us an additional draft pick. We'd be fleecing them. We're the Bears in the Ramsey trade scenario. We already have a fantastic set of DBs, potentially the best in the NFL. Yeah, Ramsey would make it better, but the impact is tiny. The cost on the other hand, is huge, because we still have to pay him. For the same price as having Ramsey, we could resign Logan Ryan, sign a high end kicker, and spend a first round draft pick on a pass rusher, a DL, a RB, or a QB. Now which of those yields a bigger impact? Trading a first for Ramsey would be insane.

Pfft, screw that. Prime rib or gtfo, if we're talking about steaks.

Dudes were overreacting to that weird *** training camp entrance. Dude is a baller, from the Nashville area, and grew up a Titans fan. I don't know how anyone wouldn't want him on the team. Still, I sure would not give up an early draft pick for him.

I mean, ideally your QB rarely has to make reads and the No. 1 on the play is open. Seeing one read all the time (if the ball isn't being forced into too tight windows and way too much coverage) probably just indicates that his hot read got open. Which I imagine happens a lot when it's one of the best receivers in the league.

Because that would motivate OLs to do this constantly just to draw DL guys off for penalties. They'd face no risk themselves, so why not do it all the time and pick up a ton of offside/neutral zone penalties?

As much as I'd like to see it happen, I really don't want the Titans to give up anything close to the capital it would take.

And the right tackle. And the right DB.

If we're in the playoffs, I'm wondering why letting Marcus go is the route we pick. And why either signing Carr or Tannehill are the only options we get to choose between. I mean, I guess if those are our only options, I'd much rather keep a draft pick than spend a first on the upgrade from Tannehill to Carr.

You're allowed to be wrong, but a defensive player that isn't a pass rusher that you also have to pay like a top free agent is pretty clearly not worth anything close to that. You're essentially giving up two firsts to sign him in free agency.

As ridiculous as that is.

No way is Ramsey worth two firsts. Not even close.

Minkah has years left on his rookie contract. Jalen doesn't, which makes a big, big difference. That said, I agree with yall that they almost certainly wouldn't trade him to a division rival.