Jump to content

The Siege of Gotham Mafia - Mafia Wins!!!


Recommended Posts

1 minute ago, MD4L said:

Why did I vote Darth, then?

To further give the impression that you have legit evidence. Had you refused to vote darth (I could be wrong but I believe a lot of people were more than willing to vote darth) it would be a direct indication of your alignment. 

Link to comment
Share on other sites

1 minute ago, theuntouchable said:

To further give the impression that you have legit evidence. Had you refused to vote darth (I could be wrong but I believe a lot of people were more than willing to vote darth) it would be a direct indication of your alignment. 

Not even close. There's a simple fact that justifies being town.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

5 minutes ago, Slappy Mc said:

The wording of my role message indicates a more traditional investigator role.

902303-john-blake-and-jim-gordon-with-ba

That would be me, Commissioner Jim Gordon.

Night 1 - no investigation (sorry about that guys, I got caught up on weekend stuff)
Night 2 - OleXmad - came back as town
Night 3 - Darth Pees - came back as mafia (as you all know)
Night 4 - MookieMonster - came back as town

Okay, why Mookie? If MD4L was correct with his census, then we had 9 possibilities. Three are dead (mission, Darth (mafia), bucs). I could clear OleXmad. Rags claimed Batman.

That left us with four options: domepatrol91 (claimed to be a granny with a stun gun, was worried I'd get hit), MD4L, Malfin, and Mookie.

Since I now know that Mookie is town, there's four possibilities:

  1. MD4L told the truth and is town. Then it is either dome or Malfin. But both of them have played very town-like, and their explanations makes sense for why there were no mafia kills in night 1 and night 3.
  2. MD4L is lying and is town. Why??
  3. MD4L is lying and is other.
  4. MD4L told the truth and is mafia.
Link to comment
Share on other sites

Archived

This topic is now archived and is closed to further replies.




×
×
  • Create New...