Settle something (poll included)

[jdzimme3]

Trying to settle a difference of opinion on the quality of a trade offer.  The league is a 12 team, 3 keeper league, standard scoring, auction league.  Keepers are kept free and clear so it doesn’t matter how much they were drafted for.  Here is the trade offer:

Team 1 Receives -

·         Julio Jones

·         Leonard Fournette

·         TJ Yeldon

·         OJ Howard

for

Team 2 Receives -

·         Zeke Elliott

·         Devin Funchess

From a keeper perspective, Zeke would almost surely be kept by either team.  A healthy Fournette and Julio Jones are also likely keepers for either team (probably just 1 of the two for team 2).  For this season, all the players in the trade are likely to start for the team obtaining them (excluding 1 of the jax rbs).  Both teams in the trade have competitive teams for this year. 

Thanks!

[MightyMouse07]

WR1, RB1, and a TE1 for a RB1 and WR3

 

Team one clearly wins this trade. Now I don't know the roster for Team 2, so maybe they can give up this amount of talent and still end up a better team. 

[TheDILinator]

I agree with Mighty Mouse.  Easy win for Team 1.  Fournette/Yeldon count as single RB, as he mentioned above, and a very productive one at that.  And Howard is breaking out in a big way this season.  However, the caveat is knowing the roster of Team 2, as MM mentioned.  It's possible he's so loaded, that upgrading from the Jax RB combo to Elliot is really all that matters.  In that case, Win/Win!