FF's Greatest Jaguars of All Time - #1

[pwny]

Let's do this!

 

I pulled a list off Bleacher Report to come up with this group. It should be more than sufficient for #1-4 or so, but I want other people's suggestions on who to add going forward.

[pwny]

This is a two horse race, but it will be interesting to see where our group lands. The media has a consensus pick for this one, but the younger fans seem to have more appreciation for the other.

[Glen]

A.J. Epenesa 

[JaguarCrazy2832]

You didn’t vote?

[pwny]

1 minute ago, JaguarCrazy2832 said:

You didn’t vote?

YOu diDn’T VoTE?

[JaguarCrazy2832]

I did just dunno why you didn’t 

[pwny]

Just now, JaguarCrazy2832 said:

I did just dunno why you didn’t 

When I’ve done these before, I’ve held my vote solely to be the tiebreaker, and otherwise let everyone else decide placement.

[LinderFournette]

Gotta put the boss man at 1

[.Buzz]

Freddy T for me. But him and Big Bo are 1a/1b.

 

[Tugboat]

5 hours ago, pwny said:

This is a two horse race, but it will be interesting to see where our group lands. The media has a consensus pick for this one, but the younger fans seem to have more appreciation for the other.

It's an interesting dynamic between the two choices.  Can't help but wonder if i'd been the age i am now, back then...i might've landed more in the Boselli camp.  But my heart belongs to Freddy here, and as much as my head knows it's close and a fair argument either way...it's not even close for me.  As long as we're voting as fans...Sentimental value always has to weigh into these things imo.  After all...that's what we watch sports for - the passion, emotion, experiences, and memories, right?

That's where Fred just runs away with it for me.  Just conjures up too many fond memories and warm feelings that remind me why i got stuck being a fan of this dumbass team in the first place.

[LinderFournette]

5 hours ago, Tugboat said:

It's an interesting dynamic between the two choices.  Can't help but wonder if i'd been the age i am now, back then...i might've landed more in the Boselli camp.  But my heart belongs to Freddy here, and as much as my head knows it's close and a fair argument either way...it's not even close for me.  As long as we're voting as fans...Sentimental value always has to weigh into these things imo.  After all...that's what we watch sports for - the passion, emotion, experiences, and memories, right?

That's where Fred just runs away with it for me.  Just conjures up too many fond memories and warm feelings that remind me why i got stuck being a fan of this dumbass team in the first place.

I have the fawn memory of Boselli actually dominating guys like Michael McCrary and bruce Smith

[Tugboat]

21 minutes ago, LinderFournette said:

I have the fawn memory of Boselli actually dominating guys like Michael McCrary and bruce Smith

Are you, or are you not making a Bambi joke about me right now?

[KhanYouDigIt]

Fred Taylor for me.

The Jags are pushing for the wrong guy to get into the HOF.

Edited April 18, 2020 by KhanYouDigIt

[.Buzz]

4 minutes ago, KhanYouDigIt said:

Fred Taylor for me.

The Jags are pushing for the wrong guy to get into the HOF.

They both deserve it fwiw.

[Glen]

I met Fred Taylor once.

Lied right to his face.

10/10 solid guy