FF's Greatest Jaguars of All Time - #4

[pwny]

1. Fred Taylor
2. Tony Boselli
3. Jimmy Smith

[pwny]

@Adrenaline_Flux @Bad meets Evil @.Buzz @Chops013 @corry @DuvalsKing @Duuuuuvaal @iPwn @Its A Sabotage @JaguarCrazy2832 @Jaguarfan @JaguarsFan28329 @Jags @Jags_Longhorns @jagsfan18 @JagsFan92 @JagsFanInNY @JaxJags11 @KhanYouDigIt @LinderFournette @MightyRx @MJD4MVP5455 @MoJo122-b-21 @RussianJag @sammymvpknight @skaterbirdhouse @SpanishJaguar @Speedyg @TMNinjaBortles @Tugboat @VLoo @4thDownHailMary  @DuvalsKing @zappa13004

[pwny]

I think this one is going to be a runaway.

[JaguarCrazy2832]

The guy I'm retroactively named after

[Tugboat]

I feel like there's a triumvirate of guys that basically just belong lumped together here as a unit basically.  Can see the argument for Brunell, but i kinda arbitrarily went with Keenan instead.

 

Swing factor is still how weird it is to watch southpaw QBs.

[pwny]

I know it's draft day, but don't forget to vote

[JaguarCrazy2832]

22 hours ago, pwny said:

I think this one is going to be a runaway.

Who did you think would run away with this?

[pwny]

2 minutes ago, JaguarCrazy2832 said:

Who did you think would run away with this?

At first, thought it would be Brunell. Thought a little more and switched to MJD after I posted, and then thought it could be close between the two.

Did not expect Keenan to be getting votes over MJD at all.

[JaguarCrazy2832]

Just now, pwny said:

At first, thought it would be Brunell. Thought a little more and switched to MJD after I posted, and then thought it could be close between the two.

Did not expect Keenan to be getting votes over MJD at all.

Keenan played on better teams, its why I expect him and Mark to beat out MJD

[pwny]

2 minutes ago, JaguarCrazy2832 said:

Keenan played on better teams, its why I expect him and Mark to beat out MJD

I mean sure, but

6,393 yards, 30 TDs (equal to 6,993 adjusted net yards)

10,944 yards, 79 TDs (equal to 12,524 adjusted net yards)

MJD was almost twice as productive as a Jaguar as Keenan was. Even adjusting for era and factoring in the level of play on the teams they played for, I just don't see an argument for Keenan.

 

I'm not even sure Keenan would be in my top 3 remaining players at this point.

[JaguarCrazy2832]

Just now, pwny said:

I mean sure, but

6,393 yards, 30 TDs (equal to 6,993 adjusted net yards)

10,944 yards, 79 TDs (equal to 12,524 adjusted net yards)

MJD was almost twice as productive as a Jaguar as Keenan was. Even adjusting for era and factoring in the level of play on the teams they played for, I just don't see an argument for Keenan.

 

I'm not even sure Keenan would be in my top 3 remaining players at this point.

Keenan is definitely Top-3 for me for remaining. You're not wrong about MJD at all, the awesome thing about him is you knew he was getting the ball. We had nothing else and he just got it done.

[pwny]

1 minute ago, JaguarCrazy2832 said:

Keenan is definitely Top-3 for me for remaining. You're not wrong about MJD at all, the awesome thing about him is you knew he was getting the ball. We had nothing else and he just got it done.

For me, it's probably

4. MJD
5. Brunell
6. Brackens
7. Keenan

[.Buzz]

I went Keenan. Forgot to post that earlier.