Jump to content
Sign in to follow this  
babyatemydingo

2020 Redraft with Rules YAY!

Recommended Posts

So, I wanted to put this in the "Howie Sucks" thread.
But, if you think that, then you can do better.


Rules:
- Make one pick of a player following each of the Eagles picks.
- Howie gets first choice.  So, you can't take the player the Eagles took unless you pick him a round (one pick) earlier than he was drafted by the Eagles.
- There are no trades other than the ones Howie made.
- UDFA's may be taken at any point, regardless of where they signed.  But, I don't want to hear about who you would have signed.  Like him?  Draft him or stop.


You have a distinct advantage as you can look up and down the draft and arrange it by who was and wasn't there.
So, quit complaining about the Howie Rule, you weren't going to take Casey Toohill, anyway.


Here is a template.

21    pick  -  Jalen Reagor        -your pick -  
53    pick  -  Jalen Hurts        -your pick -  
103    pick  -  Davion Taylor        -your pick -  
127    pick  -  K'Von Wallace      -your pick -  
145    pick  -  Jack Driscoll        -your pick -  
168    pick  -  John Hightower    -your pick -  
196    pick  -  Shaun Bradley    -your pick -  
200    pick  -  Quez Watkins        -your pick -  
210    pick  -  Prince Tega Wanogho      -your pick -  
233    pick  -  Casey Toohill        -your pick -  


Here is my draft:


21    pick  -  Jalen Reagor        -my pick -  Brandon Aiyuk  WR
53    pick  -  Jalen Hurts        -my pick -  Kristian Fulton  CB
103    pick  -  Davion Taylor        -my pick -  K'Von Wallace  S
127    pick  -  K'Von Wallace      -my pick -  Shane Lemieux  OG
145    pick  -  Jack Driscoll        -my pick -  Nick Harris  C
168    pick  -  John Hightower    -my pick -  Justin Strnad  LB
196    pick  -  Shaun Bradley    -my pick -  James Proche  WR
200    pick  -  Quez Watkins        -my pick -  Evan Weaver  MLB-DE
210    pick  -  Prince Tega Wanogho      -my pick -  Kenny Willekes  DE
233    pick  -  Casey Toohill        -my pick -  Stephen Sullivan  TE

 

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

21    pick  -  Jalen Reagor                        -my pick -      Jalen Reagor  WR
53    pick  -  Jalen Hurts                           -my pick -      Kristian Fulton  CB
103    pick  -  Davion Taylor                     -my pick -      K'Von Wallace  S
127    pick  -  K'Von Wallace                    -my pick -      James Lynch DT
145    pick  -  Jack Driscoll                       -my pick -      Jack Driscoll  OL
168    pick  -  John Hightower                  -my pick-       John Hightower WR
196    pick  -  Shaun Bradley                     -my pick -      James Proche  WR
200    pick  -  Quez Watkins                      -my pick -      Cassh Maluia  LB
210    pick  -  Prince Tega Wanogho        -my pick -      Kenny Willekes  DE
233    pick  -  Casey Toohill                        -my pick -      Dane Jackson CB

 

Would've gone David Woodward late but there is clearly something wrong with him teams know about.
He's still unsigned.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Posted (edited)

I like this exercise a lot.

Anyways, I spent a decent amount of time thinking about this and here it goes... 

21    pick  -  Jalen Reagor                       -my pick -     Jalen Reagor  WR (I refuse to select anybody over him lol)
53    pick  -  Jalen Hurts                          -my pick -     Kristian Fulton  CB (Wanted to take Ashtyn Davis but couldn't do it... safety has to wait another round)
103    pick  -  Davion Taylor                    -my pick -     Terrell Burgess S (K'Von Wallace can go here too)
127    pick  -  K'Von Wallace                   -my pick -     James Morgan or Jake Fromm QB (Better spot for a back-up. Fromm has higher floor. Morgan is more toolsy.)
145    pick  -  Jack Driscoll                     -my pick -     Nick Harris C (Great movement skills. Develop behind Kelce, so Seumalo doesn' thave to try and snap again..)
168    pick  -  John Hightower                -my pick-      Donovan Peoples-Jones WR (Get some size at WR. Jeffery is gone soon and Hollins is just a special teamer.)
196    pick  -  Shaun Bradley                   -my pick -     Quez Watkins WR (Need more speed. Eagles also were thinking of taking him at 168.)
200    pick  -  Quez Watkins                    -my pick -     Prince Tega Wanogho OT/OG (Still worth the risk a mere 10 picks earlier.)
210    pick  -  Prince Tega Wanogho      -my pick -    Markus Bailey LB (Falling cause of injuries. This is the range to take players like him and Prince.)
233    pick  -  Casey Toohill                     -my pick -    Benito Jones DT (1 tech to develop in a stacked DT room.)

I'm sure if I sat here I'd keep tweaking it, but I like this a lot.

Edited by TheRealMcCoy

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

21    pick  -  Jalen Reagor        -your pick -  Jalen Reagor WR (If I cant trade up for Lamb Howie got it right)


53    pick  -  Jalen Hurts        -your pick -  Jeremy Chinn S


103    pick  -  Davion Taylor        -your pick -  Akeem Davis Gaither LB


127    pick  -  K'Von Wallace      -your pick -  Troy Dye LB

145    pick  -  Jack Driscoll        -your pick -  Bryce Hall CB


168    pick  -  John Hightower    -your pick -  Darnell Mooney WR

196    pick  -  Shaun Bradley    -your pick -  James Proche WR


200    pick  -  Quez Watkins        -your pick -  Jake Hanson C 

210    pick  -  Prince Tega Wanogho      -your pick Prince Tega Wanogho T

 

233  pick- Casey Toohill DE -your pick Nate Stanley QB 

 

 

really just replace Hurts with Fulton and I’d rather have ADG or Dye over Taylor and I liked the rest 

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

1. WR Jalen Reagor
2. CB Kristian Fulton
3. S K'Von Wallace
4. LB Troy Dye
4. C Tyler Biadazs
5. WR Isaiah Hodgins
6. OT Prince Tega Wanogho
6. S Geno Stone
7. LB David Woodward

BAMD, I know this isn't what you were going for in this thread, but I just wanted to get down on paper so to speak what I would have done.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
On 5/7/2020 at 12:57 AM, Kiltman said:

21    pick  -  Jalen Reagor                        -my pick -      Jalen Reagor  WR
53    pick  -  Jalen Hurts                           -my pick -      Kristian Fulton  CB
103    pick  -  Davion Taylor                     -my pick -      K'Von Wallace  S
127    pick  -  K'Von Wallace                    -my pick -      James Lynch DT
145    pick  -  Jack Driscoll                       -my pick -      Jack Driscoll  OL
168    pick  -  John Hightower                  -my pick-       John Hightower WR
196    pick  -  Shaun Bradley                     -my pick -      James Proche  WR
200    pick  -  Quez Watkins                      -my pick -      Cassh Maluia  LB
210    pick  -  Prince Tega Wanogho        -my pick -      Kenny Willekes  DE
233    pick  -  Casey Toohill                        -my pick -      Dane Jackson CB

 

Would've gone David Woodward late but there is clearly something wrong with him teams know about.
He's still unsigned.

You took Driscoll and Hightower in the same spots as the Eagles.
You need to move them up or move them out.

Note:  I decided to allow Reagor at 1 across the board.
He may actually have been your choice.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
16 hours ago, TheRealMcCoy said:

I like this exercise a lot.

Anyways, I spent a decent amount of time thinking about this and here it goes... 

21    pick  -  Jalen Reagor                       -my pick -     Jalen Reagor  WR (I refuse to select anybody over him lol)
53    pick  -  Jalen Hurts                          -my pick -     Kristian Fulton  CB (Wanted to take Ashtyn Davis but couldn't do it... safety has to wait another round)
103    pick  -  Davion Taylor                    -my pick -     Terrell Burgess S (K'Von Wallace can go here too)
127    pick  -  K'Von Wallace                   -my pick -     James Morgan or Jake Fromm QB (Better spot for a back-up. Fromm has higher floor. Morgan is more toolsy.)
145    pick  -  Jack Driscoll                     -my pick -     Nick Harris C (Great movement skills. Develop behind Kelce, so Seumalo doesn' thave to try and snap again..)
168    pick  -  John Hightower                -my pick-      Donovan Peoples-Jones WR (Get some size at WR. Jeffery is gone soon and Hollins is just a special teamer.)
196    pick  -  Shaun Bradley                   -my pick -     Quez Watkins WR (Need more speed. Eagles also were thinking of taking him at 168.)
200    pick  -  Quez Watkins                    -my pick -     Prince Tega Wanogho OT/OG (Still worth the risk a mere 10 picks earlier.)
210    pick  -  Prince Tega Wanogho      -my pick -    Markus Bailey LB (Falling cause of injuries. This is the range to take players like him and Prince.)
233    pick  -  Casey Toohill                     -my pick -    Benito Jones DT (1 tech to develop in a stacked DT room.)

I'm sure if I sat here I'd keep tweaking it, but I like this a lot.

Sorry, pick a QB, Morgan or Fromm?

 

 

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
16 hours ago, EaglesPeteC said:

21    pick  -  Jalen Reagor        -your pick -  Jalen Reagor WR (If I cant trade up for Lamb Howie got it right)


53    pick  -  Jalen Hurts        -your pick -  Jeremy Chinn S


103    pick  -  Davion Taylor        -your pick -  Akeem Davis Gaither LB


127    pick  -  K'Von Wallace      -your pick -  Troy Dye LB

145    pick  -  Jack Driscoll        -your pick -  Bryce Hall CB


168    pick  -  John Hightower    -your pick -  Darnell Mooney WR

196    pick  -  Shaun Bradley    -your pick -  James Proche WR


200    pick  -  Quez Watkins        -your pick -  Jake Hanson C 

210    pick  -  Prince Tega Wanogho      -your pick Prince Tega Wanogho T

 

233  pick- Casey Toohill DE -your pick Nate Stanley QB 

 

 

really just replace Hurts with Fulton and I’d rather have ADG or Dye over Taylor and I liked the rest 

You need to move Prince up or out.
You have him in the same spot as the Eagles.
Not allowed, Howie said so.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
16 hours ago, Danger said:

1. WR Jalen Reagor
2. CB Kristian Fulton
3. S K'Von Wallace
4. LB Troy Dye
4. C Tyler Biadazs
5. WR Isaiah Hodgins
6. OT Prince Tega Wanogho
6. S Geno Stone
7. LB David Woodward

BAMD, I know this isn't what you were going for in this thread, but I just wanted to get down on paper so to speak what I would have done.

No, this is spot on.
I made a post adjustment to allow Reagor.
He couldn't be taken elsewhere and was available.
There was enough chatter about him to say he was a viable pick there.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
6 hours ago, babyatemydingo said:

You need to move Prince up or out.
You have him in the same spot as the Eagles.
Not allowed, Howie said so.

I’ll do what I want. You’re not my dad! 

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Posted (edited)

21    pick  -  Jalen Reagor                        -my pick -      Kenneth Murray LB
53    pick  -  Jalen Hurts                           -my pick -      Ashtyn Davis S 
103    pick  -  Davion Taylor                     -my pick -      Troy Pride CB
127    pick  -  K'Von Wallace                    -my pick -      Antonio Gandy-Golden WR
145    pick  -  Jack Driscoll                       -my pick -      Joe Reed WR/Ret
168    pick  -  John Hightower                  -my pick-       Darnell Mooney WR 
196    pick  -  Shaun Bradley                     -my pick -      Jake Hanson iOL
200    pick  -  Quez Watkins                      -my pick -      Prince Tega Wanogho OT
210    pick  -  Prince Tega Wanogho        -my pick -     Cole McDonald QB
233    pick  -  Casey Toohill                        -my pick -     Tyrie Cleveland WR

 

I'll PM my address...

Edited by nlesthought

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
11 hours ago, babyatemydingo said:

Sorry, pick a QB, Morgan or Fromm?

I guess Morgan cause Eagles seem to like more arm strength than Fromm has.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
11 hours ago, babyatemydingo said:

Winner gets a toy Yoda.

Baby Yoda?

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
13 hours ago, babyatemydingo said:

You took Driscoll and Hightower in the same spots as the Eagles.
You need to move them up or move them out.

Note:  I decided to allow Reagor at 1 across the board.
He may actually have been your choice.

Please everyone take this as an example of how much I read of posts.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
Sign in to follow this  



×