Jump to content
Sign in to follow this  
Titans_Matt

NFL All-Time Teams

Recommended Posts

I've always been extremely fond football history, so at the beginning of quarantine a friend asked me to do hypothetical all time teams with hypothetical "Madden ratings" attached to each player. I figured might as well share this on here as well, since I figured some people might enjoy it, and generate some discussion. It was a pretty big undertaking with a lot of research involved. I adjusted the hypothetical ratings to their competition so everyone wasn't just gifted 99s, and no duplicate players, one team per player. I reviewed a few times, so hopefully there aren't any mistakes.Any other questions, just ask, please enjoy!

 

AFC 

AFC South

 

TITANS

QB-Warren Moon (92 OVR)

QB-Steve McNair (90 OVR)

RB-Earl Campbell (98 OVR)

RB-Eddie George (90 OVR)

RB-Chris Johnson (88 OVR)

RB-Derrick Henry (86 OVR)

FB- Mike Rozier (87 OVR)

WR-Charley Hennigan (85 OVR)

WR-Derrick Mason (83 OVR)

WR-Drew Hill (78 OVR)

WR-Billy White Shoes Johnson (75 OVR, returning 98 OVR)

TE-Frank Wycheck (90 OVR)

TE-Delanie Walker (88 OVR)

OT- Taylor Lewan (85 OVR)

OT-Brad Hopkins (85 OVR)

OG-Bruce Matthews (99 OVR)

OG-Mike Munchak (96 OVR)

C-Carl Mauck (78 OVR)

DE-Elvin Bethea (93 OVR)

DE-Jevon Kearse (90 OVR)

DT-Ray Childress (89 OVR)

DT-Curley Culp (86 OVR)

DL-Jurrell Casey (86 OVR)

LB-Robert Brazile (92 OVR)

LB-Keith Bulluck (88 OVR)

LB-George Webster (86 OVR)

LB-Al Smith (83 OVR)

CB-Samari Rolle (85 OVR)

CB-Cris Dishman (85 OVR)

CB-Courtland Finnegan (79 OVR)

CB-Logan Ryan (76 OVR)

FS-Kevin Byard (84 OVR)

SS- Jim Norton (90 OVR)

K-Al Del Greco (89 OVR)

P-Brett Kern (92 OVR)

 

COLTS

QB-Peyton Manning (99 OVR)

QB-Johnny Unitas (99 OVR)

FB-Alan Ameche (91 OVR)

RB-Lenny Moore (93 OVR)

RB- Edgerrin James (88 OVR)

WR-Raymond Berry (98 OVR)

WR-Marvin Harrison (97 OVR)

WR-Reggie Wayne (90 OVR)

WR-T.Y. Hilton (82 OVR)

TE-John Mackey (97 OVR)

TE-Dallas Clark (94 OVR)

OT- Bob Vogel (90 OVR)

OT-Tarik Glenn (82 OVR)

OG-Jim Parker (98 OVR)

OG- Chris Hinton (90 OVR)

C-Jeff Saturday (97 OVR)

DE-Gino Marchetti (97 OVR)

DE-Dwight Freeney (93 OVR)

DT- Art Donovan (88 OVR)

DT-Gene Lipscom (87 OVR)

DL-Robert Mathis (90 OVR)

LB-Mike Curtis (88 OVR)

LB-Darius Leonard (83 OVR)

LB- Don Shinnick (80 OVR)

LB- Bill Pellington (76 OVR)

CB-Bobby Boyd (88 OVR)

CB- Lenny Lyles (78 OVR)

CB- Bruce Laird (78 OVR)

CB-Vontae Davis (75 OVR)

FS-Rick Volk (87 OVR)

SS-Bob Sanders (90 OVR)

K-Adam Vinatieri (99 OVR)

P-Pat McAfee (90 OVR)

 

JAGUARS

QB-Mark Brunell (84 OVR)

RB-Fred Taylor (89 OVR)

RB-Maurice Jones-Drew (89 OVR)

FB-Greg Jones (80 OVR)

WR-Jimmy Smith (85 OVR)

WR-Keenan McCardell (80 OVR)

WR-Allen Robinson (75 OVR)

TE-Marcedes Lewis (79 OVR)

TE-Kyle Brady (76 OVR)

LT-Tony Boselli (92 OVR)

LT-Maurice Williams (74 OVR)

LG- Vince Manuwai (72 OVR)

LB- Chris Naeole (72 OVR)

C-Brad Meester (79 OVR)

DE- Tony Brackens (80 OVR)

DE- Yannick Ngakoue (79 OVR)

DT-John Henderson (86 OVR)

DT-Marcus Stroud (86 OVR)

LB-Kevin Hardy (82 OVR)

LB-Mike Peterson (80 OVR)

LB- Paul Posluszny (80 OVR)

LB-Telvin Smith (77 OVR)

CB-Jalen Ramsey (85 OVR)

CB-Rashean Mathis (85 OVR)

CB-AJ Bouye (78 OVR)

FS- Chris Hudson (70 OVR)

SS-Donovin Darius (76 OVR)

K-Josh Scobee (84 OVR)

P-Bryan Barker (85 OVR)

 

TEXANS

QB-Deshaun Watson (85 OVR)

QB-Matt Schaub (69 OVR)

FB- Lawrence Vickers (74 OVR)

RB-Arian Foster (84 OVR)

RB-Domanick Williams (66 OVR)

WR-DeAndre Hopkins (96 OVR)

WR-Andre Johnson (96 OVR)

WR-Will Fuller V (77 OVR)

TE-Owen Daniels (78 OVR)

OT-Duane Brown (83 OVR)

OT- Eric Winston (76 OVR)

OG- Chester Pitts (70 OVR)

OG- Zach Fulton (68 OVR)

C-Chris Myers (80 OVR)

DE-JJ Watt (98 OVR)

DE-Mario Williams (89 OVR)

DT- Amobi Okoye (68 OVR)

DT-DJ Reader (65 OVR)

LB-Jadeveon Clowney (87 OVR)

LB-Demeco Ryans (86 OVR)

LB-Brian Cushing (84 OVR)

LB-Whitney Mercilus (84 OVR)

CB-Johnathan Joseph (84 OVR)

CB-Kareem Jackson (78 OVR)

CB-Dunta Robinson (74 OVR)

FS- Bernard Pollard (78 OVR)

SS-DJ Swearinger (70 OVR)

K-Kris Brown (87 OVR)

P-Trevor Daniel (80 OVR)

 

AFC EAST

 

JETS

QB-Joe Namath (88 OVR)

RB-Curtis Martin (94 OVR)

RB-Freeman McNeil (83 OVR)

FB-Matt Snell (88 OVR)

WR-Don Maynard (92 OVR)

WR Al Toon (85 OVR)

WR-Laveranues Coles (78 OVR)

WR-Wayne Chrebet (76 OVR)

TE-Rich Caster (82 OVR)

OT- Winston Hill (90 OVR)

OT-Marvin Powell (90 OVR)

OG- Dave Herman (88 OVR)

OG- Randy Rasmussen (82 OVR)

C-Kevin Mawae (99 OVR)

DE- Mark Gastineau (91 OVR)

DE- Shaun Ellis (80 OVR)

DT-Joe Klecko (88 OVR)

DT-Damon Harrison Sr (76 OVR)

DL-Muhammad Wilkerson (82 OVR)

DL-Leonard Williams (76 OVR)

LB-Larry Grantham (88 OVR)

LB- Mo Lewis (84 OVR)

LB-David Harris (79 OVR)

CB-Darrelle Revis (97 OVR)

CB-Aaron Glenn (87 OVR)

CB-James Hasty (80 OVR)

FS-Victor Green (73 OVR)

SS-Jamal Adams (84 OVR)

K-Pat Leahy (81 OVR)

P-Curley Johnson (88 OVR)

 

PATRIOTS

QB-Tom Brady (99 OVR)

RB-Kevin Faulk (80 OVR)

RB-James White (79 OVR)

FB- Sam Cunningham (84 OVR)

WR-Wes Welker (90 OVR)

WR- Stanley Morgan (86 OVR)

WR-Irving Fryar (86 OVR)

WR-Julian Edelman (84 OVR)

TE-Rob Gronkowski (99 OVR)

TE-Ben Coates (85 OVR)

OT-Ben Armstrong (87 OVR)

OT- Tom Neville (78 OVR)

OG-John Hannah (99 OVR)

OG-Logan Mankins (92 OVR)

C-David Andrews (73 OVR)

DE-Richard Seymour (91 OVR)

DE-Julius Adams (76 OVR)

DT-Vince Wilfork (88 OVR)

DT-Houston Antwine (88 OVR)

LB- Andre Tippett (92 OVR)

LB- Tedy Bruschi (86 OVR)

LB- Dont'a Hightower (84 OVR)

LB-Mike Vrabel (84 OVR)

LB-Jerod Mayo (84 OVR)

LB-Willie McGinest (84 OVR)

CB-Mike Haynes (98 OVR)

CB-Ty Law (92 OVR)

CB-Stephon Gilmore (91 OVR)

CB-Asante Samuel (90 OVR)

FS-Devin McCourty (87 OVR)

SS-Lawyer Milloy (88 OVR)

K-Stephen Gostkowski (90 OVR)

P- Rich Camarillo (90 OVR)

 

BILLS

QB-Jim Kelly (90 OVR)

RB-OJ Simpson (98 OVR)

RB-Thurman Thomas (94 OVR)

FB- Cookie Gilchrist (97 OVR)

WR-Andre Reed (92 OVR)

WR-Eric Moulds (86 OVR)

WR-Elbert Dubenion (83 OVR)

WR-Lee Evans (72 OVR)

TE- Ernie Warlick (86 OVR)

OT-Will Wolford (84 OVR)

OT-Stew Barber (80 OVR)

OG-Billy Shaw (98 OVR)

OG- Joe DeLamielleure (97 OVR)

C-Kent Hull (90 OVR)

DE-Bruce Smith (99 OVR)

DE- Ron McDole (80 OVR)

DE- Jerry Hughes (76 OVR)

DT-Fred Smerlas (89 OVR)

DT- Tom Sestak (86 OVR)

DT- Kyle Williams (84 OVR)

DT-Pat Williams (82 OVR)

LB-Cornelius Bennett (89 OVR)

LB- Darryl Talley (84 OVR)

LB-Takeo Spikes (84 OVR)

LB- Mike Stratton (84 OVR)

CB- Butch Byrd (88 OVR)

CB-Robert James (83 OVR)

CB- Tre'Davious White (82 OVR)

CB-Nate Clements (79 OVR)

FS-George Saimes (87 OVR)

SS-Henry Jones (78 OVR)

K- Steve Christie (81 OVR)

P-Brian Moorman (92 OVR)

 

DOLPHINS

QB-Dan Marino (98 OVR)

QB-Bob Griese (89 OVR)

RB-Ricky Williams (86 OVR)

RB-Mercury Morris (83 OVR)

FB-Larry Csonka (99 OVR)

WR-Mark Clayton (89 OVR)

WR-Mark Duper (84 OVR)

WR-Chris Chambers (79 OVR)

WR-Nat Moore (75 OVR)

TE-Keith Jackson (89 OVR)

OT- Richmond Webb (92 OVR)

OT- Jake Long (86 OVR)

OG-Larry Little (97 OVR)

OG-Jim Langer (91 OVR)

C-Dwight Stephenson (97 OVR)

DE-Jason Taylor (95 OVR)

DE-Bill Stanfill (86 OVR)

DE-Cameron Wake (85 OVR)

DT-Bob Baumhower (90 OVR)

DT-Manny Fernandez (83 OVR)

LB-Zach Thomas (94 OVR)

LB- Nick Buoniconti (93 OVR)

LB- John Offerdahl (87 OVR)

LB-Bryan Cox (83 OVR)

CB-Patrick Surtain (88 OVR)

CB-Sam Madison (86 OVR)

CB-Xavien Howard (80 OVR)

FS-Jake Scott (90 OVR)

SS-**** Anderson (87 OVR)

K-Olindo Mare (86 OVR)

P-Reggie Roby (89 OVR)

 

AFC NORTH

 

 

BENGALS

QB-Boomer Esiason (86 OVR)

QB-Ken Anderson (85 OVR)

RB-Corey Dillon (90 OVR)

FB-Pete Johnson (85 OVR)

WR-Chad Johnson (92 OVR)

WR-A.J. Green (92 OVR)

WR-Cris Collinsworth (83 OVR)

WR-T.J. Houshmandzadeh (79 OVR)

TE-Bob Tumpy (82 OVR)

OT-Anthony Munoz (99 OVR)

OT-Andrew Whitworth (90 OVR)

OT-Willie Anderson (90 OVR)

OG-Max Montoya (87 OVR)

OG- Bruce Reimers (80 OVR)

C-Bob Johnson (78 OVR)

DE-Coy Bacon (87 OVR)

DE-Carlos Dunlap (82 OVR)

DT-Geno Atkins (89 OVR)

DT-Tim Krumrie (82 OVR)

LB- Vontaze Burfict (78 OVR)

LB-Jim Leclair (78 OVR)

LB-Reggie Williams (72 OVR)

LB-James Francis (69 OVR)

CB-Ken Riley (90 OVR)

CB-Lemar Parrish (90 OVR)

CB-Leon Hall (77 OVR)

FS-Reggie Nelson (78 OVR)

SS-David Fulcher (83 OVR)

K- Shayne Graham (85 OVR)

P-Lee Johnson (76 OVR)

 

STEELERS

QB-Ben Roethlisberger (90 OVR)

QB-Terry Bradshaw (89 OVR)

RB-Franco Harris (93 OVR)

RB-Jerome Bettis (93 OVR)

FB-John Henry Johnson (87 OVR)

WR-Antonio Brown (95 OVR)

WR-John Stallworth (92 OVR)

WR-Hines Ward (92 OVR)

WR-Lynn Swann (89 OVR)

TE- Elbie Nickel (82 OVR)

TE-Heath Miller (80 OVR)

OT-Jon Kolb (83 OVR)

OT- Alejandro Villanueva (80 OVR)

OG-Alan Faneca (97 OVR)

OG-Dermontti Dawson (97 OVR)

C-Mike Webster (99 OVR)

DE-LC Greenwood (92 OVR)

DE-Dwight White (80 OVR)

DT-Joe Greene (99 OVR)

DT- Ernie Stautner (96 OVR)

DT-Casey Hampton (86 OVR)

LB- Jack Ham (99 OVR)

LB-Jack Lambert (98 OVR)

LB-James Harrison (91 OVR)

LB-Joey Porter (88 OVR)

CB-Rod Woodson (99 OVR)

CB-Mel Blount (99 OVR)

CB-Jack Butler (91 OVR)

FS-Donnie Shell (90 OVR)

SS-Troy Polamalu (97 OVR)

K-Gary Anderson (95 OVR)

P-Bobby Walden (90 OVR)

 

BROWNS

QB-Otto Graham (98 OVR)

RB-Jim Brown (99 OVR)

RB-LeRoy Kelly (93 OVR)

FB-Marion Motley (99 OVR)

WR-Paul Warfield (95 OVR)

WR- Mac Speedie (89 OVR)

WR-Dante Lavelli (85 OVR)

WR-Eric Metcalf (82 OVR)

WR-Josh Cribbs (74 OVR, returning 96 OVR)

TE-Ozzie Newsome (97 OVR)

OT-Joe Thomas (99 OVR)

OT- Mike McCormack (97 OVR)

OG- Gene Hickerson (93 OVR)

OG- **** Schafrath (90 OVR)

C-Frank Gatski (89 OVR)

DE-Len Ford (90 OVR)

DE-Michael Dean Perry (88 OVR)

DT-Bob Gain (89 OVR)

DT-Bill Willis (86 OVR)

DL- Myles Garrett (82 OVR)

LB-Clay Mathews Jr (86 OVR)

LB-Walt Michaels (85 OVR)

LB-Chip Banks (85 OVR)

LB-Joe Schobert (77 OVR)

CB- Frank Minnifield (86 OVR)

CBHanford Dixon (82 OVR)

CB- Warren Lahr (82 OVR)

CB-Joe Haden (81 OVR)

FS- Thom Darden (85 OVR)

SS-TJ Ward (77 OVR)

K-Lou Groza (99 OVR)

P- Horace Gillom (84 OVR)

 

RAVENS

QB-Lamar Jackson (89 OVR)

QB-Joe Flacco (78 OVR)

RB-Jamal Lewis (86 OVR)

RB-Ray Rice (83 OVR)

FB-Sam Gash (84 OVR)

WR- Michael Jackson (78 OVR)

WR-Qadry Ismail (77 OVR)

WR-Torrey Smith (73 OVR)

TE-Todd Heap (82 OVR)

TE-Mark Andrews (79 OVR)

OT-Jonathan Ogden (99 OVR)

OT-Ronnie Stanley (80 OVR)

OG-Marshal Yanda (96 OVR)

OG-Wally Williams (78 OVR)

C-Mike Flynn (76 OVR)

DE- Michael McCrary (82 OVR)

DE-Rob Burnett (83 OVR)

DT-Haloti Ngata (88 OVR)

DT-Sam Adams (84 OVR)

DL- Tony Siragusa (84 OVR)

LB-Ray Lewis (99 OVR)

LB-Terrell Suggs (91 OVR)

LB-CJ Mosley (87 OVR)

LB-Peter Boulware (86 OVR)

LB- Adalius Thomas (83 OVR)

CB-Chris Mcalister (85 OVR)

CB- Duane Starks (78 OVR)

CB-Jimmy Smith (77 OVR)

FS-Ed Reed (99 OVR)

SS-Dawan Landry (78 OVR)

K-Justin Tucker (98 OVR)

P-Sam Koch (88 OVR)

 

AFC WEST

 

RAIDERS

QB-Ken Stabler (88 OVR)

QB-Rich Gannon (87 OVR)

RB-Marcus Allen (93 OVR)

RB-Bo Jackson (85 OVR)

FB-Mark van Eeghhen (81 OVR)

WR-Tim Brown (96 OVR)

WR-Fred Bilentnikoff (88 OVR)

WR-Cliff Branch (87 OVR)

WR-Art Powell (87 OVR)

TE-Dave Casper (94 OVR)

TE- Todd Christensen (94 OVR)

OT-Art Shell (99 OVR) 

OT- Lincoln Kennedy (84 OVR)

OG- Gene Upshaw (99 OVR)

OG- Steve Wisniewski (92 OVR)

C-Jim Otto (98 OVR)

DE- Howie Long (93 OVR)

DE- Ben Davidson (84 OVR)

DT-Chester McGlockton (86 OVR)

DT Otis Sistrunk (81 OVR)

LB-Ted Hendricks (96 OVR)

LB-Khalil Mack (92 OVR)

LB-Rod Martin (84 OVR)

LB- Bill Romanowski (83 OVR)

LB-Matt Millen (80 OVR)

CB-Charles Woodson (99 OVR)

CB-Willie Brown (99 OVR)

CB-Lester Hayes (93 OVR)

CB-Nnamdi Asomugha (89 OVR)

FS-Jack Tatum (88 OVR)

SS-George Atkinson (84 OVR) 

K-Geogre Blanda (96 OVR)

P-Ray Guy (99 OVR)

 

CHARGERS

QB-Dan Fouts (93 OVR)

QB-Phillip Rivers (90 OVR)

RB-LaDainian Tomlinson (98 OVR)

RB-Paul Lowe (85 OVR)

RB-Darren Sproles (84 OVR)

FB-Lorenzo Neal (96 OVR)

WR-Lance Alworth (97 OVR)

WR-John Jefferson (88 OVR)

WR-Charlie Joiner (85 OVR)

WR-Keenan Allen (83 OVR)

TE-Kellen Winslow Sr (99 OVR)

TE-Antonio Gates (99 OVR)

OT-Ron Mix (95 OVR)

OT-Rush Washington (88 OVR)

OG-Walt Sweeney (90 OVR)

OG-Doug Wilkerson (86 OVR) 

C-Nick Hardwick (80 OVR)

DE-Leslie O'Neal (92 OVR)

DE-Fred Dean (91 OVR)

DT- Gary Big Hands Johnson (86 OVR)

DT- Louie Kelcher (85 OVR)

DL-Joey Bosa (85 OVR)

DL-Melvin Ingram (83 OVR)

LB-Junior Seau (99 OVR)

LB-Shawne Merriman (86 OVR)

LB-Woodrow Lowe (84 OVR)

LB-Billy Ray Smith (75 OVR)

CB- Gill Byrd (85 OVR)

CB- Antonio Cromartie (85 OVR)

CB-Speedy Duncan (84 OVR)

CB-Casey Hayward Jr (82 OVR)

FS-Eric Weddle (92 OVR)

SS-Rodney Harrison (91 OVR)

K-Johhn Carney (84 OVR)

P-Darren Bennett (92 OVR)

 

CHIEFS

QB-Patrick Mahomes (93 OVR)

QB-Len Dawson (90 OVR)

RB-Priest Holmes (88 OVR)

RB-Jamaal Charles (87 OVR)

RB-Larry Johnson (84 OVR)

FB- Christian Okoye (96 OVR)

FB-Tony Richardson (94 OVR)

WR-Tyreek Hill (89 OVR)

WR-Otis Taylor (86 OVR)

WR- Carlos Carson (80 OVR)

WR-Dwayne Bowe (78 OVR)

WR-Dante Hall (70 OVR, returning 99 OVR)

TE-Tony Gonzalez (99 OVR)

TE-Travis Kelce (92 OVR)

OT-Jim Tyrer (93 OVR)

OT-Mitchell Schwartz (88 OVR)

OG-Will Shields (98 OVR)

OG-Ed Budde (89 OVR)

C-Jack Rudnay (87 OVR)

DE-Jared Allen (92 OVR)

DE- Neil Smith (92 OVR)

DT-Buck Buchanan (98 OVR)

DT-Jerry Mays (90 OVR)

DL-Justin Houston (86 OVR)

DL-Art Still (85 OVR)

DL-Chris Jones (81 OVR)

LB-Bobby Bell (99 OVR)

LB-Willie Lanier (98 OVR)

LB-Derrick Thomas (98 OVR)

LB-Tamba Hali (88 OVR)

LB-Derrick Johnson (87 OVR)

CB-Emmitt Thomas (93 OVR)

CB- Albert Lewis (86 OVR)

CB-Dale Carter (85 OVR)

CB-Kevin Ross (82 OVR)

FS-Johnny Robinson (92 OVR)

SS-Deron Cherry (90 OVR)

DB-Eric Berry (89 OVR)

K-Jan Stenerud (98 OVR)

P-Dustin Colquitt (86 OVR)

 

BRONCOS

QB-John Elway (96 OVR)

RB-Terrell Davis (92 OVR)

RB-Floyd Little (91 OVR)

FB- Howard Griffith (81 OVR)

WR-Rod Smith (86 OVR)

WR-Demaryius Thomas (84 OVR)

WR-Ed McCaffrey (82 OVR)

WR-Lionel Taylor (82 OVR)

TE-Shannon Sharpe (97 OVR)

OT-Ryan Clady (85 OVR)

OT- Matt Lepsis (77 OVR)

OG-Mark Schlereth (84 OVR)

OG-Keith Bishop (83 OVR)

C- Tom Nalen (91 OVR)

DE-Elvis Dumervil (89 OVR)

DE-Rich Tombstone Jackson (85 OVR)

DT-Trevor Pryce (87 OVR)

DT-Paul Smith (84 OVR)

DL-Rulon Jones (81 OVR)

LB-Von Miller (96 OVR)

LB-Randy Gradishar (92 OVR)

LB-Karl Mecklenburg (88 OVR)

LB-Al Wilson (85 OVR)

LB-Tom Jackson (85 OVR)

CB-Champ Bailey (98 OVR)

CB- Louis Wright (90 OVR)

CB-Chris Harris Jr (87 OVR)

CB-Aqib Talib (87 OVR)

FS-Steve Atwater (92 OVR)

SS-Dennis Smith (89 OVR)

K-Jason Elam (93 OVR)

P-Tom Rouben (82 OVR)

 

 

NFC 

NFC SOUTH

 

BUCANEERS

QB-Brad Johnson (81 OVR)

RB-Warrick Dunn (84 OVR)

RB-James Wilder (83 OVR)

FB-Mike Alstott (98 OVR)

WR-Mike Evans (89 OVR)

WR-Keyshawn Johnson (86 OVR)

WR-Vincent Jackson (83 OVR)

WR-Mark Carrier (78 OVR)

TE-Jimmie Giles (86 OVR)

OT-Paul Gruber (82 OVR)

0T- Donald Penn (87 OVR)

OG-Ali Marpet (78 OVR)

OG-Randy Grimes (77 OVR)

C-Tony Mayberry (84 OVR)

DE- Lee Roy Selmon (95 OVR)

DE-Simeon Rice (90 OVR) 

DT-Warren Sapp (97 OVR)

DT-Gerald McCoy (90 OVR)

LB-Derrick Brooks (99 OVR)

LB-Hardy Nickerson (88 OVR)

LB-Lavonte David (84 OVR)

LB- Shelton Quarles (80 OVR)

CB-Ronde Barber (92 OVR)

CB-Donnie Abraham (81 OVR)

CB-Brian Kelly (81 OVR)

FS-Cedric Brown (78 OVR)

SS-John Lynch (94 OVR)

K-Martin Gramatica (83 OVR)

P-Josh Bidwell (80 OVR)

 

Falcons

QB-Michael Vick (89 OVR)

QB-Matt Ryan (88 OVR)

RB-Gerald Riggs (87 OVR)

RB-Jamal Anderson (84 OVR)

FB- William Andrews (87 OVR)

WR-Julio Jones (96 OVR)

WR- Andre Rison (90 OVR)

WR-Roody White (85 OVR)

WR-Terrance Mathis (80 OVR)

TE-Alge Crumpler (85 OVR)

OT-Mike Kenn (89 OVR)

OT- George Kunz (89 OVR)

OG- Bill Fralic (88 OVR)

OG- R. C. Thielemann (84 OVR)

C-Alex Mack (89 OVR)

DE-John Abraham (90 OVR)

DE-Claude Humphrey (90 OVR)

DT-Grady Jarrett (80 OVR)

DT-Jonathan Babineaux (77 OVR)

LB-Jessie Tuggle (90 OVR)

LB- Tommy Nobis (90 OVR)

LB- Keith Brooking (87 OVR)

LB-Deion Jones (80 OVR)

CB-Deion Sanders (99 OVR)

CB- Ray Buchanan (82 OVR)

CB-Desmond Trufant (80 OVR)

FS-Eugene Robinson (86 OVR)

SS-Scott Case (80 OVR)

K-Matt Bryant (85 OVR)

P- Dan Stryzinski (78 OVR)

 

SAINTS

QB-Drew Brees (98 OVR)

RB-Alvin Kamara (84 OVR)

RB-Deuce McAllister (84 OVR)

RB-Reggie Bush (83 OVR)

RB-Mark Ingram (83 OVR)

FB- Craig Ironhead Heyward (88 OVR)

WR-Michael Thomas (92 OVR)

WR-Joe Horn (85 OVR)

WR-Marques Colston (82 OVR)

WR-Eric Martin (80 OVR)

TE-Jimmy Graham (90 OVR)

OT-Willie Roaf (98 OVR)

OT- Terron Armstead (85 OVR)

OG-Jahri Evans (91 OVR)

OG-Carl Nicks (83 OVR)

C-Jake Kupp (81 OVR)

DE-Cameron Jordan (87 OVR)

DE-Joe Johnson (82 OVR)

DT-La'Roi Glover (92 OVR)

DT-Jim Wilks (79 OVR)

DL-Will Smith (81 OVR)

LB-Rickey Jackson (95 OVR)

LB-Pat Swilling (94 OVR) 

LB-Sam Mills (90 OVR)

LB- Vaughan Johnson (84 OVR)

CB-Marshon Lattimore (84 OVR)

CB-Dave Wayymer (80 OVR)

CB- Dave Whitsell (79)

CB-Tracy Porter (76 OVR)

FS-Sammy Knight (82 OVR)

SS-Roman Harper (81 OVR)

K-Morten Anderson (99 OVR)

P- Tommy Barnhardt (80 OVR)

 

PANTHERS

QB-Cam Newton (88 OVR)

RB-Christian McCaffrey (89 OVR)

RB-Stephen Davis (84 OVR)

RB-Deangelo Williams (80 OVR)

FB-Brad Hoover (78 OVR)

WR-Steve Smith (95 OVR)

WR-Muhsin Muhhammad (84 OVR)

WR- Kelvin Benjamin (75 OVR)

Kelvin Benjamin (81 OVR)

TE-Greg Olsen (89 OVR)

TE-Wesley Walls (89 OVR)

OT-Jordan Gross (84 OVR)

OT-Todd Steussie (82 OVR)

OG- Trai Turner (85 OVR)

OG- Andrew Norwell (82 OVR)

C-Ryan Kalil (88 OVR)

DE-Julius Peppers (96 OVR)

DE- Mike Rucker (81 OVR)

DT-Kris Jenkins (88 OVR)

DT-Kawann Short (84 OVR) 

LB-Luke Kuechly (96 OVR)

LB-Jon Beason (85 OVR)

LB-Thomas Davis Sr (85 OVR)

LB-Dan Morgan (82 OVR)

CB-Josh Norman (82 OVR)

CB-Chris Gamble (78 OVR) 

CB-Captain Munnerlyn (75 OVR)

FS- Mike Minter (78 OVR)

SS-Deon Grant (76 OVR)

K-John Kasey (90 OVR)

P- Todd Sauerbrun (84 OVR)

 

 

NFC EAST

 

COWBOYS

QB-Roger Staubach (98 OVR)

QB-Troy Aikman (90 OVR)

RB-Emmitt Smith (97 OVR)

RB-Tony Dorsett (93 OVR)

RB-Ezekiel Elliott (90 OVR)

FB-Don Perkins (94 OVR)

WR-Michael Irvin (94 OVR)

WR- Bullet Bob Hayes (92 OVR, 99 speed)

WR- Drew Pearson (89 OVR)

WR-Dez Bryant (87 OVR)

TE-Jason Witten (97 OVR)

TE- Jay Novacek (88 OVR)

OT- Tyron Smith (95 OVR)

OT- Rayfield Wright (93 OVR)

OG-Larry Allen (99 OVR)

OG-Zack Martin (94 OVR)

C- Mark Stepnoski (93 OVR)

DE- Harvey Martin (91 OVR)

DE- Ed Too Tall Jones (88 OVR)

DT-Bob Lilly (99 OVR)

DT-Randy White (98 OVR)

LB-DeMarcus Ware (96 OVR)

LB- Chuck Howley (90 OVR)

LB-Lee Roy Jordan (89 OVR)

LB-Sean Lee (83 OVR)

CB-Mel Renfro (96 OVR)

CB-Everson Walls (89 OVR)

CB (original position safety)- Charlie Waters (82 OVR)

FS-Cliff Harris (92 OVR)

SS-Darren Woodson (89 OVR)

K-Dan Bailey (86 OVR)

P-Mike Saxton (76 OVR)

 

GIANTS

QB- Y. A. Tittle (93 OVR)

QB-Eli Manning (88 OVR)

QB-Phil Simms (88 OVR)

RB-Jim Thorpe (94 OVR)

RB-Frank Gifford (94 OVR)

RB-Tiki Barber (85 OVR)

RB-Saquon Barkley (83 OVR)

FB-Alex Webster (83 OVR)

WR-Odell Beckham Jr (90 OVR)

WR- Del Shofner (89 OVR)

WR-Homer Jones (84 OVR)

WR-Plaxico Burress (83 OVR)

WR-Amani Toomer (80 OVR)

WR-Jeremy Shockey (88 OVR)

TE- Mark Bavaro (85 OVR)

OT-Rosey Brown (96 OVR)

OT- Jumbo Ellitott (80 OVR)

OG-Jack Stroud (85 OVR)

OG-Darrell Dess (83 OVR)

C-Mel Hein (98 OVR)

DE-Michael Strahan (96 OVR)

DE- Andy Robustelli (94 OVR)

DT- Arnie Weinmeister (87 OVR)

DT-Rosey Grier (84 OVR)

DL-Justin Tuck (83 OVR)

DL-Osi Umenyiora (82 OVR)

LB-Lawrence Taylor (99 OVR)

LB-Harry Carson (94 OVR)

LB-Sam Huff (92 OVR)

LB- Jessie Armstead (88 OVR)

LB-Carl Banks (81 OVR)

CB- Erich Barnes (88 OVR)

CB-Mark Haynes (85 OVR)

CB-Carl Spider Lockhart (83 OVR)

CB-Janoris Jenkins (79 OVR)

FS-Emlen Tunnell (98 OVR)

SS-Jimmy Patton (90 OVR)

DB-Antrel Rolle (84 OVR)

K-Matt Bahr (82 OVR)

P-Sean Landeta (97 OVR)

 

EAGLES

QB-Randall Cunningham (91 OVR)

QB-Donovan McNabb (90 OVR)

RB-Steve Van Buren (91 OVR)

RB-LeSean McCoy (87 OVR)

RB-Brian Westbrook (85 OVR)

FB- Keith Byars (84 OVR)

WR-Pete Pihos (90 OVR)

WR- Harold Carmichael (87 OVR)

WR- Tommy McDonald (86 OVR)

WR-Desean Jackson (86 OVR, returning 97 OVR)

TE-Keith Jackson (89 OVR)

TE-Zach Ertz (88 OVR)

OT-Bob Brown (94 OVR)

OT-Jason Peters (94 OVR)

OG-Brandon Brooks (85 OVR)

OG-Shawn Andrews (85 OVR)

C-Jason Kelce (89 OVR)

DE-Reggie White (99 OVR)

DE- Clyde Simmons (86 OVR)

DT-Fletcher Cox (92 OVR)

DT- Jerome Brown (86 OVR)

DL-Trent Cole (83 OVR)

DL-Brandon Graham (81 OVR)

LB-Chuck Bednarik (98 OVR)

LB-Maxie Baughan (92 OVR)

LB-Jeremiah Trotter (86 OVR)

LB-Seth Joyner (86 OVR)

LB-Bill Bergey (85 OVR)

CB-Troy Vincent (88 OVR)

CB-Eric Allen (88 OVR)

CB-Lito Sheppard (83 OVR)

FS-Brian Dawkins (98 OVR)

SS-Malcolm Jenkins (85 OVR)

K-David Akers (96 OVR)

P-Donnie Jones (90 OVR)

 

REDSKINS

QB-Sammy Baugh (97 OVR)

QB-Joe Theismann (86 OVR)

RB-Larry Brown (88 OVR)

RB-Clinton Portis (84 OVR)

FB-John Riggins (99 OVR)

WR- Charley Taylor (93 OVR)

WR-Art Monk (90 OVR)

WR-Bobby Mitchell (88 OVR)

WR-Gary Clark (87 OVR) 

WR-Santana Moss (82 OVR)

TE-Jerry Smith (85 OVR)

TE-Chris Cooley (83 OVR)

OT-Trent Williams (90 OVR)

OT- Jim Lachey (89 OVR)

OG-Russ Grimm (90 OVR)

OG-Joe Jacoby (90 OVR)

C- Len Hauss (87 OVR)

DE-Charles Mann (88 OVR)

DE-Dexter Manley (87 OVR)

DT-Dave Butz (86 OVR)

DT- Diron Talbert (80 OVR)

LB-Chris Hanburger (91 OVR)

LB-London Fletcher (87 OVR)

LB-LaVar Arrington (85 OVR)

LB-Ryan Kerrigan (85 OVR)

LB-Ken Harvey (85 OVR)

CB-Darrell Green (98 OVR)

CB-DeAngelo Hall (87 OVR)

CB-Pat Fischer (86 OVR)

FS-Ken Houston (99 OVR)

SS-Sean Taylor (87 OVR)

K-Mark Moseley (87 OVR)

P-Tress Way (80 OVR)

 

NFC EAST

 

VIKINGS

QB-Fran Tarkenton (95 OVR)

QB-Daunte Culpepper (87 OVR)

RB-Adrian Peterson (97 OVR)

RB-Robert Smith (83 OVR)

FB-Chuck Foreman (96 OVR)

WR-Randy Moss (99 OVR)

WR-Cris Carter (96 OVR)

WR-Adam Thielen (84 OVR)

WR-Ahmad Rashad (83 OVR)

WR-Stefon Diggs (78 OVR)

TE-Steve Jordan (85 OVR)

OT- Ron Yary (97 OVR)

OT- Gary Zimmerman (93 OVR)

OG-Randall McDaniel (99 OVR)

OG-Ed White (86 OVR)

C-Mick Tingelhoff (90 OVR)

DE-Carl Eller (94 OVR)

DE- Chris Doleman (93 OVR)

DT-Alan Page (99 OVR)

DT-John Randle (96 OVR)

DL-Kevin Williams (90 OVR)

DL-Jim Marshall (85 OVR)

DL-Everson Griffen (83 OVR)

LB-Matt Blair (85 OVR)

LB- Jeff Siemon (84 OVR)

LB-Anthony Barr (84 OVR)

LB-Chad Greenway (82 OVR)

LB-Scott Studwell (82 OVR)

CB-Antoine Winfield (95 OVR)

CB-Bobby Bryant (84 OVR)

CB-Xavier Rhodes (84 OVR)

CB-Nate Wright (77 OVR)

FS-Paul Krause (98 OVR)

SS-Harrison Smith (89 OVR)

SS-Joey Browner (89 OVR)

K-Fred Cox (86 OVR)

P- Mitch Berger (91 OVR)

 

PACKERS

 QB-Aaron Rodgers (97 OVR)

QB-Brett Favre (97 OVR)

Bart Starr (90 OVR)

RB- Paul Hornung (90 OVR)

RB-Ahman Green (87 OVR)

FB-Jim Taylor (98 OVR)

WR-Don Hutson (99 OVR)

WR-James Lofton (94 OVR)

WR-Sterling Sharpe (92 OVR)

WR-Davante Adams (86 OVR)

WR-Jordy Nelson (84 OVR)

WR-Donald Driver (84 OVR)

TE-Paul Coffman (83 OVR)

OT-Forrest Gregg (99 OVR)

OT- Cal Hubbard (90 OVR)

OG- Mike Michalske (93 OVR)

OG-Jerry Kramer (92 OVR)

C-Jim Ringo (97 OVR)

DE-Willie Davis (91 OVR)

DE-Kabeer Gbaja-Biamila (82 OVR)

DT-Henry Jordan (93 OVR)

DT-Mike Daniels (83 OVR)

LB-Ray Nitschke (98 OVR)

LB-Clay Mathews (88 OVR)

LB-Dave Robinson (87 OVR)

LB-Fred Carr (84 OVR)

CB-Herb Adderley (95 OVR) 

CB-Bobby Dillon (87 OVR)

CB-Al Harris (84 OVR)

FS- Willie Wood (95 OVR)

SS-Darren Sharper (92 OVR)

SS-LeRoy Butler (92 OVR)

K-Mason Crosby (84 OVR)

P-Max McGee (92 OVR)

 

BEARS

QB-Sid Luckman (89 OVR)

QB-Jim McMahon (81 OVR)

RB-Walter Payton (99 OVR)

RB-Gale Sayers (96 OVR)

FB-Bronko Nagurski (99 OVR)

WR-Brandon Marshall (90 OVR)

WR- Harlon Hill (87 OVR)

WR-Alshon Jeffery (82 OVR)

WR-Willie Gault (80 OVR, 99 speed)

WR-Devin Hester (72 OVR, returning 99 OVR)

TE-Mike Ditka (93 OVR)

OT-Joe Stydahar (90 OVR)

OT-Ed Healey (88 OVR)

OG-Stan Jones (90 OVR)

OG-Dan Fortmann (90 OVR)

C-Olin Kreutz (91 OVR)

C-Jay Helgenberg (91 OVR)

DE-Doug Atkins (97 OVR)

DE-Richard Dent (94 OVR)

DT-Dan Hampton (92 OVR)

DT-George Musso (87 OVR)

DL-Steve McMichael (85 OVR)

DL-William The Refrigerator Perry (80 OVR)

LB-**** Butkus (99 OVR)

LB-Mike Singletary (98 OVR)

LB-Brian Urlacher (96 OVR)

LB-Bill George (93 OVR)

LB-Lance Briggs (88 OVR)

CB-Charles Tillman (84 OVR)

CB-Kyle Fuller (83 OVR)

CB-Roosevelt Taylor (83 OVR)

FS-Dave Duerson (85 OVR)

SS-Gary Fencik (85 OVR)

K-Robbie Gould (87 OVR)

P-George Gulyanics (80 OVR)

 

LIONS

QB-Bobby Layne (91 OVR)

QB-Matthew Stafford (84 OVR)

RB-Barry Sanders (99 OVR)

RB-Billy Sims (87 OVR)

FB-Cory Schlesinger (88 OVR)

WR-Calvin Johnson (96 OVR)

WR-Herman Moore (89 OVR)

WR-Gail Cogdil (84 OVR)

WR-Kenny Golladay (81 OVR)

WR-Golden Tate III (80 OVR)

TE-Charlie Sanders (92 OVR)

OT- Lou Creekmur (93 OVR)

OT-Lomas Brown (90 OVR)

OG-Kevin Glover (86 OVR)

OG-Harley Sewell (85 OVR)

C-Ed Flanagan (85 OVR)

DE- Robert Porcher (85 OVR)

DE-Al Baker (83 OVR)

DT-Ndamukong Suh (91 OVR)

DT-Alex Karras (90 OVR)

DL- Doug English (83 OVR)

DL-Ezekiel Ansah (80 OVR)

LB-Joe Schmidt (97 OVR)

LB-Chris Spielman (88 OVR)

LB- Alex Wojciechowicz (86 OVR)

LB-Wayne Walker (84 OVR)

CB-Night Train Lane (99 OVR)

CB-Lem Barney (94 OVR)

CB-**** LeBeau (88 OVR)

CB-Darius Slay Jr (85 OVR)

CB-Dre Bly (83 OVR)

FS- Yale Lary (95 OVR)

SS-Jack Christiansen (94 OVR)

K-Jason Hanson (91 OVR)

P-Sam Martin (78 OVR)

 

NFC WEST

 

RAMS

QB-Kurt Warner (93 OVR)

QB-Norm Van Brocklin (93 OVR)

RB-Eric Dickerson (98 OVR)

RB-Marshall Faulk (97 OVR)

RB-Todd Gurley (88 OVR)

RB-Steven Jackson (85 OVR)

FB-Dan Towler (93 OVR)

WR-Torry Holt (94 OVR)

WR-Issac Bruce (94 OVR)

WR- Elroy Crazy Legs Hirsch (90 OVR)

WR-Henry Ellard (85 OVR)

TE-Tom Fears (85 OVR)

OT-Orlando Pace (98 OVR)

OT-Jackie Slater (96 OVR)

OG-Tom Mack (94 OVR)

OG-Dennis Harrah (87 OVR)

C-Doug Smith (87 OVR)

DE-Deacon Jones (99 OVR)

DE-Jack Youngblood (94 OVR)

DT-Merlin Olsen (99 OVR)

DT-Aaron Donald (97 OVR)

DL-Robert Quinn (81 OVR)

LB-Kevin Greene (94 OVR)

LB- Les Richter (90 OVR)

LB-Isiah Robertson (87 OVR)

LB-Jack Hacksaw Reynolds (83 OVR)

CB-Ed Meador (88 OVR)

CB-LeRoy Irvin (86 OVR)

CB-Todd Lyghht (80 OVR)

FS-Nolan Cromwell (89 OVR)

SS-Jerry Gray (86 OVR)

K-Jeff Wilkins (85 OVR)

P-Dale Hatcher (86 OVR)

 

SEAHAWKS

QB-Russell Wilson (90 OVR)

QB-Matt Hasselbeck (84 OVR)

QB-Marshawn Lynch (92 OVR)

RB-Shaun Alexander (90 OVR)

RB-Curt Warner (87 OVR)

FB-Mack Strong (95 OVR)

WR-Steve Largent (97 OVR)

WR-Joey Galloway (82 OVR)

WR-Brian Blades (82 OVR

WR-Doug Baldwin (82 OVR)

WR-Tyler Lockett (80 OVR)

TE-Mike Tice (75 OVR)

OT-Walter Jones (98 OVR)

OT-Howard Ballard (83 OVR)

OG-Steve Hutchinson (96 OVR)

OG-Bryan Millard (78 OVR)

C-Robbie Tobeck (80 OVR) 

DE-Michael Sinclair (85 OVR)

DE-Jacob Green (84 OVR)

DT-Cortez Kennedy (93 OVR)

DT-Joe Nash (82 OVR)

DL- Michael Bennett (83 OVR)

LB-Bobby Wagner (94 OVR)

LB-Lofa Tatupu (85 OVR)

LB-Chad Brown (84 OVR)

LB-Rufus Porter (83 OVR)

LB-KJ Wright (81 OVR)

CB-Richard Sherman (95 OVR)

CB-Dave Brown (84 OVR)

CB-Marcus Trufant (82 OVR)

CB-Shawn Springs (82 OVR)

FS-Earl Thomas III (93 OVR)

SS-Kenny Easley (94 OVR)

DB-Kam Chancellor (88 OVR)

K-Norm Johnson (88 OVR)

P- Rick Tuten (84 OVR)

 

CARDINALS

QB-Carson Palmer (85 OVR)

QB-Jim Hart (84 OVR)

RB-Ollie Matson (91 OVR)

RB-Ottis Anderson (84 OVR)

FB-Ernie Nevers (93 OVR)

FB-Larry Centers (89 OVR)

WR-Larry Fitzgerald (97 OVR)

WR-Anquan Boldin (85 OVR)

WR-Mel Gray (85 OVR)

WR-Roy Green (83 OVR)

TE-Jackie Smith (89 OVR)

OT-Dan Dierdorf (95 OVR)

OT-Ernie McMillan (84 OVR)

OG-Ken Gray (88 OVR)

OG-Conrad Dobler (84 OVR)

C-Tom Banks (85 OVR)

DE-Calais Campbell (89 OVR)

DE-Leo Sugar (82 OVR)

DT-Darnell Dockett (85 OVR)

DT-Eric Swann (83 OVR)

LB-Chandler Jones (89 OVR)

LB-Ken Gray (87 OVR)

LB-Karlos Dansby (84 OVR)

LB-Dale Meinert (83 OVR)

CB-Aeneas Williams (95 OVR)

CB-Patrick Peterson (95 OVR)

CB-Roger Wehrli (91 OVR)

FS-Larry Wilson (96 OVR)

SS-Tyrann Mathieu, DB (89 OVR)

DB-Tim McDonald (89 OVR)

DB-Adrian Wilson (87 OVR)

DB-Pat Tillman (83 OVR)

K-Jim Bakken (94 OVR)

P-Ben Graham (87 OVR)

 

49ERS

 QB-Joe Montana (99 OVR)

QB-Steve Young (96 OVR)

RB-Frank Gore (92 OVR)

RB-Roger Craig (91 OVR)

RB- Hugh McElhenny (91 OVR)

FB-Joe Perry (93 OVR)

WR-Jerry Rice (99 OVR)

WR-Terrell Owens (98 OVR)

WR- Billy Wilson (86 OVR)

WR-Dwight Clark (84 OVR)

TE-George Kittle (87 OVR)

TE-Brent Jones (87 OVR)

TE-Vernon Davis (85 OVR)

OT-Joe Staley (92 OVR) 

OT- Bob St Clair (92 OVR)

OG- Guy McIntyre (87 OVR)

OG- Randy Cross (87 OVR)

C-Forrest Blue (86 OVR)

DE-Justin Smith (88 OVR)

DE- Cedrick Hardman (83 OVR)

DT-Leo Nomellini (95 OVR)

DT-Bryant Young (87 OVR)

DL- Michael Carter (85 OVR)

LB-Patrick Willis (96 OVR)

LB-Charles Haley (95 OVR)

LB-Dave Wilcox (92 OVR)

LB-NaVorro Bowman (87 OVR)

LB-Ken Norton Jr (86 OVR)

CB-Jimmy Johnson (90 OVR)

CB-Eric Wright (84 OVR)

CB-Eric Davis (84 OVR)

FS-Ronnie Lott (99 OVR)

SS-Merton Hanks (86 OVR)

K-Ray Werschhing (83 OVR)

P-Andy Lee (92 OVR)

  • Like 3

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

...aaaand Bob Sanders is already injured.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I can't do this all at once, but at a very quick glance, the Colts, and really the rest of the AFC South aside from the Titans, seem to have a lot of players that I feel like should be a tick or two higher. Not everyone, but a handful.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Here's what I had in that thread about all-time franchise team (I followed the template of the OP, looks like you're adding more players, but it's a general reference point)...

QB: Aaron Rodgers
RB: Ahman Green
RB: Paul Hornung
WR: Don Hutson
WR: Sterling Sharpe
TE: Paul Coffman
LT: Chad Clifton
LG: Gale Gillingham
C: Jim Ringo
RG:  Jerry Kramer
RT: Forrest Gregg

DE: Reggie White
DT:  Henry Jordan
DT: Gilbert Brown
DE: Willie Davis
LB: Clay Matthews
LB: Ray Nitschke
LB: Dave Robinson
CB: Herb Adderley
FS: Willie Wood
SS: LeRoy Butler
CB: Charles Woodson

K: Mason Crosby
P:  ...Craig Hentrich?

HC: Vince Lombardi

Honorable Mentions: QB Bart Starr, Brett Favre, HB Tony Canadeo, FB Clarke Hinkle, Jim Taylor, G Fuzzy Thurston, Mike Michalske, C Frank Winters, WR James Lofton, Donald Driver, Jordy Nelson, DE KGB, S Bobby Dillon, Nick Collins

*****************************************************************************************************

I think I will respond to your picks in bullet point form...

-First things first, get that rapist scumbag the F off my team. Not even taking into account all the raping, that dude is SUCH AN OVERRATED safety. He was not a strong safety, he was a free safety. And even though he had good ball skills, he blew *** in coverage. Absolute choker. Seemed to be on the wrong end of every major choke job of the GB defense during his tenure, from TO on the Niners in the playoffs, to 4th and 26 against the Eagles...also in the playoffs. Screw that guy. And moreso, you have better options at safety with Bobby Dillon to Nick Collins. I'd give it to Nick Collins since at least I got to see him play, more my era.

-Rodgers should be a tick higher, Favre a tick lower, Starr maybe a couple higher.

-Paul Hornung was one of the absolute best players of his era. Crank him up a couple points. Ahman Green is waaay forgotten and underrated. His peak was ridiculous. 90-92.

-Sharpe is too low, should be maybe 94-95. Also criminally underrated, since his career was cut short. The numbers he would've put up with Favre, oh man.

-Jordy Nelson as always is underrated. He's better than Davante Adams. Should be 88-90 at least.

-No Reggie White at DE? Are you high? Should be in place of KGB. KGB was really good at what he did, but was basically a one trick pony.

 -Chad Clifton should be a tackle.

-Might be a tad premature to put Mike Daniels there

-Herb Adderley was an absolute badass and should be like 97

-How do you not put Chuck Woodson at corner? Put him over Harris, low-to-mid 90s

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
9 minutes ago, DannyB said:

Here's what I had in that thread about all-time franchise team (I followed the template of the OP, looks like you're adding more players, but it's a general reference point)...

QB: Aaron Rodgers
RB: Ahman Green
RB: Paul Hornung
WR: Don Hutson
WR: Sterling Sharpe
TE: Paul Coffman
LT: Chad Clifton
LG: Gale Gillingham
C: Jim Ringo
RG:  Jerry Kramer
RT: Forrest Gregg

DE: Reggie White
DT:  Henry Jordan
DT: Gilbert Brown
DE: Willie Davis
LB: Clay Matthews
LB: Ray Nitschke
LB: Dave Robinson
CB: Herb Adderley
FS: Willie Wood
SS: LeRoy Butler
CB: Charles Woodson

K: Mason Crosby
P:  ...Craig Hentrich?

HC: Vince Lombardi

Honorable Mentions: QB Bart Starr, Brett Favre, HB Tony Canadeo, FB Clarke Hinkle, Jim Taylor, G Fuzzy Thurston, Mike Michalske, C Frank Winters, WR James Lofton, Donald Driver, Jordy Nelson, DE KGB, S Bobby Dillon, Nick Collins

*****************************************************************************************************

I think I will respond to your picks in bullet point form...

-First things first, get that rapist scumbag the F off my team. Not even taking into account all the raping, that dude is SUCH AN OVERRATED safety. He was not a strong safety, he was a free safety. And even though he had good ball skills, he blew *** in coverage. Absolute choker. Seemed to be on the wrong end of every major choke job of the GB defense during his tenure, from TO on the Niners in the playoffs, to 4th and 26 against the Eagles...also in the playoffs. Screw that guy. And moreso, you have better options at safety with Bobby Dillon to Nick Collins. I'd give it to Nick Collins since at least I got to see him play, more my era.

-Rodgers should be a tick higher, Favre a tick lower, Starr maybe a couple higher.

-Paul Hornung was one of the absolute best players of his era. Crank him up a couple points. Ahman Green is waaay forgotten and underrated. His peak was ridiculous. 90-92.

-Sharpe is too low, should be maybe 94-95. Also criminally underrated, since his career was cut short. The numbers he would've put up with Favre, oh man.

-Jordy Nelson as always is underrated. He's better than Davante Adams. Should be 88-90 at least.

-No Reggie White at DE? Are you high? Should be in place of KGB. KGB was really good at what he did, but was basically a one trick pony.

 -Chad Clifton should be a tackle.

-Might be a tad premature to put Mike Daniels there

-Herb Adderley was an absolute badass and should be like 97

-How do you not put Chuck Woodson at corner? Put him over Harris, low-to-mid 90s

One team per player, Reggie White played more years with the Eagles, Woodson played more years with the Raiders 

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
18 minutes ago, Titans_Matt said:

One team per player, Reggie White played more years with the Eagles, Woodson played more years with the Raiders 

no me gusta

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Note: no reason JJ Watt shouldn't be a straight 99. He's one of the best football players of all-time. And he annoys the crap out of me, but it is what it is.

  • Like 1

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

No Moss for Pats?

Otherwise it looks spot on. Kudos for recognising Haynes and Tippett as the best in their positions

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
4 minutes ago, Hunter2_1 said:

No Moss for Pats?

Otherwise it looks spot on. Kudos for recognising Haynes and Tippett as the best in their positions

Nope. His rule is one player can only be on one franchise: the one he was on the longest.

Buncha steamin' loads of bullcrap, I tell ya hwhut...

King Of The Hill No GIF - Find & Share on GIPHY

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
8 hours ago, Titans_Matt said:

One team per player, Reggie White played more years with the Eagles, Woodson played more years with the Raiders 

Oh I thought it was they belonged to the team that drafted them. 

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Posted (edited)

Leon Searcy should be the RT for the Jags. Easily the second best OL we’ve ever had. I’d also add Gary Walker and/or Malik Jackson to the DL list.

No way I’m putting Chris Hudson on my all time team. Carnell Lake, Tashaun Gipson, or Deon Grant should all be options for FS.

Edited by Chops013

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

×   Pasted as rich text.   Paste as plain text instead

  Only 75 emoji are allowed.

×   Your link has been automatically embedded.   Display as a link instead

×   Your previous content has been restored.   Clear editor

×   You cannot paste images directly. Upload or insert images from URL.

Sign in to follow this  

×
×
  • Create New...