Jump to content

The GOAT at each position/role


RaidersAreOne

Recommended Posts

Will only do from the time I started watching (2004).

 

QB: Tom Brady

HB: Adrian Peterson

WR: Terrell Owens

TE: Rob Gronkowski

T: Trent Williams

G: Alan Faneca

C; Jason Kelce

 

DE: JJ Watt

DT: Aaron Donald

ILB: Patrick Willis 

OLB: James Harrison

CB: Darrelle Revis

FS: Ed Reed

SS: Troy Polamalu

K: Justin Tucker

P: Sam Koch

 

 

Link to comment
Share on other sites

  • GM
  • HC  - Bill Belichick
  • OC -
  • DC -

 

  • QB - Tom Brady
  • RB - Earl Campbell
  • FB - Jim Brown
  • WR - Randy Moss
  • TE - Rob Gronkowski
  • T -  Larry Allen
  • G - Steve Hutchinson
  • C - Mick Tingelhoff

 

  • DE - Reggie White
  • DT - Alan Page
  • MLB - Brian Urlacher
  • OLB - Lawrence Taylor
  • CB - Deion Sanders
  • S -  Ed Reed

 

  • K - Anyone but Gary Anderson
  • P - Ray Guy
  • KR - Devin Hester
  • PR -
Link to comment
Share on other sites

  • GM - George Halas
  • HC - Bill Belichick
  • OC - Bill Walsh
  • DC - Bill Belichick

 

  • QB - Tom Brady
  • RB - Barry Sanders
  • FB - Jim Brown
  • WR - Jerry Rice
  • TE - Rob Gronkowski
  • T - Anthony Munoz
  • G - John Hannah
  • C - Jim Otto

 

  • DE - Bruce Smith
  • DT - Bob Lilly
  • MLB - **** Butkus
  • OLB - Lawrence Taylor
  • CB - Deion Sanders 
  • S - Ronnie Lott

 

  • K - Adam Vinatieri
  • P - Ray Guy
  • KR - Devin Hester
  • PR - Devin Hester
Link to comment
Share on other sites

On 10/4/2021 at 3:28 AM, Awsi Dooger said:

General Manager -- Ozzie Newsome

Head Coach -- Vince Lombardi

Offensive Coordinator -- Howard Schnellenberger

Defensive Coordinator -- Bill Belichick

 

Quarterback -- Tom Brady

Running Back -- Jim Brown

Halfback -- Gale Sayers

Wide Receiver -- Jerry Rice

Wide Receiver -- Randy Moss

Tight End -- Kellen Winslow

Tight End -- Rob Gronkowski

Tackle -- Anthony Munoz

Tackle -- Jonathan Ogden

Guard -- John Hannah

Guard -- Bruce Matthews

Center -- Dwight Stephenson (easily the widest gap between #1 and #2 at any position, IMO)

 

Defensive End -- Reggie White

Defensive End -- Deacon Jones

Defensive Tackle -- Mean Joe Green

Defensive Tackle -- Warren Sapp

Middle Linebacker -- **** Butkus

Outside Linebacker -- Lawrence Taylor

Linebacker -- Ray Lewis

Strong Safety -- Ronnie Lott

Free Safety -- Ed Reed

Free Safety -- Kenny Easley (no chance I can pick between Easley and Reed; Easley considered far superior to Lott throughout college)

Cornerback -- Deion Sanders

Cornerback -- Darrelle Revis

 

Kicker -- Justin Tucker

Punter -- Shane Lechler

Kick Returner -- Gale Sayers

Punt Returner -- Devin Hester

 

Solid list TBH.

Only changes I'd make are:

Replace Jim Brown with Barry Sanders

Keep Reed and drop Easley

Replace Randy Moss with T.O.

Moss just wasn't consistent enough for me. Amazing player, but taken out of a game way too often. Very hard to shut T.O. down in his prime. 

Link to comment
Share on other sites

On 10/4/2021 at 5:10 AM, Nabbs4u said:
  • GM Bill Polian
  • HC Bill Belichick
  • OC Bill Walsh
  • DC Bill Belichick 

 

  • QB Tom Brady
  • RB Barry Sanders
  • FB Jim Brown
  • WR Jerry Rice
  • TE Rob Gronkowski
  • T Anthony Munoz 
  • G Bruce Mathews
  • C Mike Webster

 

  • DE Reggie White
  • DT Mean Joe Green
  • MLB Junior Seau
  • OLB Lawrence Taylor
  • CB Deion Sanders
  • S Ed Reed

 

  • K Justin Tucker
  • P Ray Guy
  • KR Gale Sayers
  • PR Devin Hester

This is pretty much the exact same as the list I would make. Only changes would be Jim Otto at C, Ray Lewis at MLB, Night Train Lane at CB, and Ronnie Lott at S. Solid list.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

  • 4 weeks later...
  • GM: Bobby Beathard
  • HC: Belichick
  • OC: Brian Bilick
  • DC: Wade Phillips

 

  • QB: P. Manning
  • RB: Barry Sanders
  • FB: Jim Brown
  • Blocking FB: Lorenzo Neal
  • Physical WR: Moss
  • Technical WR: Rice 
  • TE: Gronk
  • T: Joe Thomas
  • G: Larry Allen
  • C : Mike Webster

 

  • DE: Reggie White
  • DT: Aaron Donald
  • MLB: Ray Lewis
  • EDGE/Pass Rushing OLB: LT
  • Coverage/Off-Ball OLB: Derrick Brooks
  • CB: Deion Sanders
  • Ball-Hawking Safety: Ed Reed
  • Hard-Hitting Safety: Ronnie Lott 

 

  • K: Justin Tucker
  • P: Ray Guy
  • KR: Devin Hester
  • PR: Dante Hall
Link to comment
Share on other sites

  • QB P.Manning
  • RB W.Payton
  • FB L.Czonka
  • WR J.Rice
  • TE R.Gronkowski
  • T W.Jones
  • G R.Grimm
  • C K.Mawae

 

  • DE B.Smith
  • DT A.Page
  • MLB J.Lambert
  • OLB D.Brooks / L.Taylor
  • CB D.Revis
  • S B.Sanders

 

  • K J.Tucker
  • P S.Lechler
  • KR D.Hester
  • PR D.Hester

 

And just to specify this is best player not best career

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

×   Pasted as rich text.   Paste as plain text instead

  Only 75 emoji are allowed.

×   Your link has been automatically embedded.   Display as a link instead

×   Your previous content has been restored.   Clear editor

×   You cannot paste images directly. Upload or insert images from URL.

×
×
  • Create New...