1 Year Peak: Who's the 3rd best WR of all time behind Rice/Moss

[mdonnelly21]

1 Year Peak: Who's the 3rd best WR of all time behind Rice/Moss

[Forge]

I mean, it kind of has to be cooper kupp if you don't put him in the first or second if you're just talking one year

[Hunter2_1]

Megatron unanimously right now..

Edited May 16, 2022 by Hunter2_1

[JonStark]

If we're just talking one year, it's Kupp. His regular season + postseason is probably the best from a WR we've ever seen. 

Out of the options there, it's probably Calvin. 

[Pugger]

45 minutes ago, JonStark said:

If we're just talking one year, it's Kupp. His regular season + postseason is probably the best from a WR we've ever seen. 

Out of the options there, it's probably Calvin. 

Kupp is great but one great year does not make a player the 3rd best of all time.

[BradfordSteeler]

1 hour ago, Pugger said:

Kupp is great but one great year does not make a player the 3rd best of all time.

The question literally asks for 1 year peak.

[JonStark]

1 hour ago, Pugger said:

Kupp is great but one great year does not make a player the 3rd best of all time.

 

On 5/14/2022 at 11:27 PM, mdonnelly21 said:

1 Year Peak

 

[Jameson_Neat]

Fitzgerald '08

[Soggust]

Kupp over Moss imo

[Pugger]

4 hours ago, BradfordSteeler said:

The question literally asks for 1 year peak.

My bad.

[Soko]

Think it’s Megatron here, but Kupp would possibly be right after. 

[AngusMcFife]

The post makes the assumption that Jerry Rice and Randy Moss had the single best WR seasons of all time, and now we have to figure out the 3rd best. 

Is that accurate? I'm not sure. 

I get that Rice should be rated #1 WR, and Moss is probably #2 although that's debatable. But I'm not sure either one has had a season that stands above the rest. Moss's 2007 was incredible with 23 TDs but even then I don't think he was quite as dynamic as he was in 1998, 2000, and 2003 when he had much worse QBs. 

Weird and confusing question. 

[AngusMcFife]

You can't overlook Don Hutson's 1942 campaign. 

[Titans_Matt]

1 hour ago, AngusMcFife said:

You can't overlook Don Hutson's 1942 campaign. 

I definitely voted Other because of this

[AFlaccoSeagulls]

So here's my thought process...

"Oh it's gotta be Calvin Johnson."

reads the thread about Cooper Kupp

"Well, Cooper Kupp outproduced Calvin with the same exact QB throwing him the ball and just shattered numerous receiving records"

So yeah, I'm going to go Kupp here since it's just a 1-year peak.