Jump to content

2024 NFL Draft Discussion

MacReady

By MacReady
in Green Bay Packers

 Share

Recommended Posts

ThatJerkDave

ThatJerkDave

Posted
Posted
49 minutes ago, OneTwoSixFive said:

Something I did years ago (but got taken over by another poster more recently) was the post-draft mock. I'd never seen it done before I did it (though it may have been).

Basically, your 'big board' is the actual draft. You may take any player still on the board when you pick. You may not make any trade the Packers did not make...........BUT...........you can refuse one they did make, and stay with the original picks.

You have a big advantage in knowing where all the players went, but you have a tiny fraction of the resources the Packers themselves can bring to bear on any prospect - and they also have multiple very talented evaluators to sort through the prospects. Make your choices, file them away and see if in a couple of years you did better, the same, or worse than the Packers choices. Obviously, the post draft mock should be made as soon as possible after the draft, so you have no extra information on players.

That is always a fun exercise.  My 2022 one was funny because I was all about Christian Watson, Romeo Doubs and Zach Tom, but I would have taken them all earlier than we actually got them.  

Link to comment
Share on other sites
R T

R T

Posted
Posted (edited)
2 hours ago, ThatJerkDave said:

I just released some finless brown...

They say they are good for spear fishing. I've never done it but have heard a stick in the brown is an unforgettable experience. 

Edited by R T
  • Like 1
Link to comment
Share on other sites
Packerraymond

Packerraymond

Posted
Posted

My final top 64: 

1 Marvin Harrison Jr. WR 6-4 205 Ohio State
2 Malik Nabers WR 6-0 200 LSU
3 Caleb Williams QB 6-1 215 USC
4 Jayden Daniels QB 6-4 210 LSU
5 Joe Alt OL 6-7 322 Notre Dame
6 Rome Odunze WR 6-3 215 Washington
7 Taliese Fuaga OL 6-6 334 Oregon State
8 Drake Maye QB 6-4 230 North Carolina
9 Quinyon Mitchell DB 6-0 196 Toledo
10 Brock Bowers TE 6-4 240 Georgia
11 Dallas Turner EDGE 6-4 252 Alabama
12 Cooper DeJean DB 6-1 207 Iowa
13 Terrion Arnold DB 6-0 196 Alabama
14 Graham Barton OL 6-5 314 Duke
15 Laiatu Latu EDGE 6-5 265 UCLA
16 Olumuyiwa Fashanu OL 6-6 317 Penn State
17 Amarius Mims OL 6-7 340 Georgia
18 Troy Fautanu OL 6-4 317 Washington
19 Byron Murphy II DL 6-1 308 Texas
20 Jared Verse EDGE 6-4 260 Florida State
21 JC Latham OL 6-6 360 Alabama
22 Jer'Zhan Newton DL 6-2 295 Illinois
23 Nate Wiggins DB 6-2 185 Clemson
24 Darius Robinson DL 6-5 296 Missouri
25 Tyler Guyton OL 6-7 328 Oklahoma
26 Chop Robinson EDGE 6-3 254 Penn State
27 Brian Thomas Jr. WR 6-4 205 LSU
28 Adonai Mitchell WR 6-4 196 Texas
29 Kool-Aid McKinstry DB 6-1 195 Alabama
30 Keon Coleman WR 6-4 215 Florida State
31 T.J. Tampa DB 6-2 200 Iowa St.
32 Jackson Powers-Johnson OL 6-3 320 Oregon
33 Marshawn Kneeland EDGE 6-3 275 W. Michigan
34 Braden Fiske DL 6-5 297 Florida State
35 J.J. McCarthy QB 6-3 202 Michigan
36 Ennis Rakestraw Jr. DB 6-0 188 Missouri
37 Jordan Morgan OL 6-5 325 Arizona
38 Edgerrin Cooper LB 6-3 230 Texas A&M
39 Kingsley Suamataia OL 6-6 325 BYU
40 Ladd McConkey WR 6-0 185 Georgia
41 Payton Wilson LB 6-4 238 NC State
42 Javon Bullard DB 5-11 195 Georgia
43 Michael Penix Jr. QB 6-3 213 Washington
44 Chris Braswell EDGE 6-3 255 Alabama
45 Ja'Tavion Sanders TE 6-4 243 Texas
46 Kris Jenkins DL 6-3 305 Michigan
47 Xavier Worthy WR 6-1 172 Texas
48 Xavier Legette WR 6-3 227 South Carolina
49 Max Melton DB 6-0 190 Rutgers
50 Junior Colson LB 6-3 247 Michigan
51 Bo Nix QB 6-2 217 Oregon
52 Dadrion Taylor-Demerson DB 5-11 195 Texas Tech
53 Roman Wilson WR 6-0 192 Michigan
55 Jaden Hicks DB 6-3 212 Washington St.
54 Patrick Paul OL 6-7 315 Houston
56 Zach Frazier OL 6-3 310 West Virginia
57 Jonathon Brooks RB 6-0 207 Texas
58 Ruke Orhorhoro DL 6-4 290 Clemson
59 Christian Haynes OL 6-2 313 UConn
60 Tyler Nubin DB 6-2 210 Minnesota
61 Ricky Pearsall WR 6-1 190 Florida
62 Trey Benson RB 6-1 223 Florida State
63 Malachi Corley WR 5-11 210 W. Kentucky
64 Michael Hall Jr. DL 6-2 280 Ohio State
  • Like 4
Link to comment
Share on other sites
NFLGURU

NFLGURU

Posted
Posted (edited)
2 hours ago, Leader said:

Justis Mosqueda -   We asked you who you think the Packers will take out of their realistic options at #25.

The first two results:
1. Cooper DeJean
2. Graham Barton

If they stick and pick I'm going with Kool Aid, and thats just a guess.  Pretty solid player and if they dont pick him at 25, they might come up for late 1st/early 2nd for him.   I think Barton and DeJean will be gone.

My Brian Thomas Jr draft crush is still on but its seems pretty unlikely.🤞

Edited by NFLGURU
Link to comment
Share on other sites
vegas492

vegas492

Posted
Posted
40 minutes ago, Packerraymond said:

My final top 64: 

 

1 Marvin Harrison Jr. WR 6-4 205 Ohio State
2 Malik Nabers WR 6-0 200 LSU
3 Caleb Williams QB 6-1 215 USC
4 Jayden Daniels QB 6-4 210 LSU
5 Joe Alt OL 6-7 322 Notre Dame
6 Rome Odunze WR 6-3 215 Washington
7 Taliese Fuaga OL 6-6 334 Oregon State
8 Drake Maye QB 6-4 230 North Carolina
9 Quinyon Mitchell DB 6-0 196 Toledo
10 Brock Bowers TE 6-4 240 Georgia
11 Dallas Turner EDGE 6-4 252 Alabama
12 Cooper DeJean DB 6-1 207 Iowa
13 Terrion Arnold DB 6-0 196 Alabama
14 Graham Barton OL 6-5 314 Duke
15 Laiatu Latu EDGE 6-5 265 UCLA
16 Olumuyiwa Fashanu OL 6-6 317 Penn State
17 Amarius Mims OL 6-7 340 Georgia
18 Troy Fautanu OL 6-4 317 Washington
19 Byron Murphy II DL 6-1 308 Texas
20 Jared Verse EDGE 6-4 260 Florida State
21 JC Latham OL 6-6 360 Alabama
22 Jer'Zhan Newton DL 6-2 295 Illinois
23 Nate Wiggins DB 6-2 185 Clemson
24 Darius Robinson DL 6-5 296 Missouri
25 Tyler Guyton OL 6-7 328 Oklahoma
26 Chop Robinson EDGE 6-3 254 Penn State
27 Brian Thomas Jr. WR 6-4 205 LSU
28 Adonai Mitchell WR 6-4 196 Texas
29 Kool-Aid McKinstry DB 6-1 195 Alabama
30 Keon Coleman WR 6-4 215 Florida State
31 T.J. Tampa DB 6-2 200 Iowa St.
32 Jackson Powers-Johnson OL 6-3 320 Oregon
33 Marshawn Kneeland EDGE 6-3 275 W. Michigan
34 Braden Fiske DL 6-5 297 Florida State
35 J.J. McCarthy QB 6-3 202 Michigan
36 Ennis Rakestraw Jr. DB 6-0 188 Missouri
37 Jordan Morgan OL 6-5 325 Arizona
38 Edgerrin Cooper LB 6-3 230 Texas A&M
39 Kingsley Suamataia OL 6-6 325 BYU
40 Ladd McConkey WR 6-0 185 Georgia
41 Payton Wilson LB 6-4 238 NC State
42 Javon Bullard DB 5-11 195 Georgia
43 Michael Penix Jr. QB 6-3 213 Washington
44 Chris Braswell EDGE 6-3 255 Alabama
45 Ja'Tavion Sanders TE 6-4 243 Texas
46 Kris Jenkins DL 6-3 305 Michigan
47 Xavier Worthy WR 6-1 172 Texas
48 Xavier Legette WR 6-3 227 South Carolina
49 Max Melton DB 6-0 190 Rutgers
50 Junior Colson LB 6-3 247 Michigan
51 Bo Nix QB 6-2 217 Oregon
52 Dadrion Taylor-Demerson DB 5-11 195 Texas Tech
53 Roman Wilson WR 6-0 192 Michigan
55 Jaden Hicks DB 6-3 212 Washington St.
54 Patrick Paul OL 6-7 315 Houston
56 Zach Frazier OL 6-3 310 West Virginia
57 Jonathon Brooks RB 6-0 207 Texas
58 Ruke Orhorhoro DL 6-4 290 Clemson
59 Christian Haynes OL 6-2 313 UConn
60 Tyler Nubin DB 6-2 210 Minnesota
61 Ricky Pearsall WR 6-1 190 Florida
62 Trey Benson RB 6-1 223 Florida State
63 Malachi Corley WR 5-11 210 W. Kentucky
64 Michael Hall Jr. DL 6-2 280 Ohio State

That's like the highest I've seen Darius Robinson.  I applaud it.  He belongs up there, if not even higher.  

  • Like 1
Link to comment
Share on other sites
Packerraymond

Packerraymond

Posted
Posted
25 minutes ago, vegas492 said:

That's like the highest I've seen Darius Robinson.  I applaud it.  He belongs up there, if not even higher.  

He's definitely one of "my guys." People keep knocking him for his lack of athletic ability for the edge....but he's not an edge to me, he's a base 5-tech with interior rush package ability. 

  • Like 2
Link to comment
Share on other sites
skibrett15

skibrett15

Posted
Posted
2 minutes ago, Packerraymond said:

He's definitely one of "my guys." People keep knocking him for his lack of athletic ability for the edge....but he's not an edge to me, he's a base 5-tech with interior rush package ability. 

I think teams agree with you on DeJean.  Guessing he goes 15-20 once the 3rd/4th qb go.

Link to comment
Share on other sites
Brit Pack

Brit Pack

Posted
Posted
1 hour ago, Packerraymond said:

My final top 64: 

 

1 Marvin Harrison Jr. WR 6-4 205 Ohio State
2 Malik Nabers WR 6-0 200 LSU
3 Caleb Williams QB 6-1 215 USC
4 Jayden Daniels QB 6-4 210 LSU
5 Joe Alt OL 6-7 322 Notre Dame
6 Rome Odunze WR 6-3 215 Washington
7 Taliese Fuaga OL 6-6 334 Oregon State
8 Drake Maye QB 6-4 230 North Carolina
9 Quinyon Mitchell DB 6-0 196 Toledo
10 Brock Bowers TE 6-4 240 Georgia
11 Dallas Turner EDGE 6-4 252 Alabama
12 Cooper DeJean DB 6-1 207 Iowa
13 Terrion Arnold DB 6-0 196 Alabama
14 Graham Barton OL 6-5 314 Duke
15 Laiatu Latu EDGE 6-5 265 UCLA
16 Olumuyiwa Fashanu OL 6-6 317 Penn State
17 Amarius Mims OL 6-7 340 Georgia
18 Troy Fautanu OL 6-4 317 Washington
19 Byron Murphy II DL 6-1 308 Texas
20 Jared Verse EDGE 6-4 260 Florida State
21 JC Latham OL 6-6 360 Alabama
22 Jer'Zhan Newton DL 6-2 295 Illinois
23 Nate Wiggins DB 6-2 185 Clemson
24 Darius Robinson DL 6-5 296 Missouri
25 Tyler Guyton OL 6-7 328 Oklahoma
26 Chop Robinson EDGE 6-3 254 Penn State
27 Brian Thomas Jr. WR 6-4 205 LSU
28 Adonai Mitchell WR 6-4 196 Texas
29 Kool-Aid McKinstry DB 6-1 195 Alabama
30 Keon Coleman WR 6-4 215 Florida State
31 T.J. Tampa DB 6-2 200 Iowa St.
32 Jackson Powers-Johnson OL 6-3 320 Oregon
33 Marshawn Kneeland EDGE 6-3 275 W. Michigan
34 Braden Fiske DL 6-5 297 Florida State
35 J.J. McCarthy QB 6-3 202 Michigan
36 Ennis Rakestraw Jr. DB 6-0 188 Missouri
37 Jordan Morgan OL 6-5 325 Arizona
38 Edgerrin Cooper LB 6-3 230 Texas A&M
39 Kingsley Suamataia OL 6-6 325 BYU
40 Ladd McConkey WR 6-0 185 Georgia
41 Payton Wilson LB 6-4 238 NC State
42 Javon Bullard DB 5-11 195 Georgia
43 Michael Penix Jr. QB 6-3 213 Washington
44 Chris Braswell EDGE 6-3 255 Alabama
45 Ja'Tavion Sanders TE 6-4 243 Texas
46 Kris Jenkins DL 6-3 305 Michigan
47 Xavier Worthy WR 6-1 172 Texas
48 Xavier Legette WR 6-3 227 South Carolina
49 Max Melton DB 6-0 190 Rutgers
50 Junior Colson LB 6-3 247 Michigan
51 Bo Nix QB 6-2 217 Oregon
52 Dadrion Taylor-Demerson DB 5-11 195 Texas Tech
53 Roman Wilson WR 6-0 192 Michigan
55 Jaden Hicks DB 6-3 212 Washington St.
54 Patrick Paul OL 6-7 315 Houston
56 Zach Frazier OL 6-3 310 West Virginia
57 Jonathon Brooks RB 6-0 207 Texas
58 Ruke Orhorhoro DL 6-4 290 Clemson
59 Christian Haynes OL 6-2 313 UConn
60 Tyler Nubin DB 6-2 210 Minnesota
61 Ricky Pearsall WR 6-1 190 Florida
62 Trey Benson RB 6-1 223 Florida State
63 Malachi Corley WR 5-11 210 W. Kentucky
64 Michael Hall Jr. DL 6-2 280 Ohio State

Interesting you have DTD your third rated Safety. And you got Cooper, Wilson and Colson all quite closely rated. 

Link to comment
Share on other sites
Packerraymond

Packerraymond

Posted
Posted

Another prediction I have after getting through this class and peeking at next year, Gute won't take a RB earlier than 5/6/7 this year. We saw it last year with Gute passing on taking an OL after three straight years of 3x OL picks (and most likely again this year), last year was a weak OL class, this year is great. He waited to pick from a position of strength.

We may be looking at an abnormally strong RB class in 2025, Ollie Gordon OK State, Omarion Hampton UNC, Quinshon Judkins OSU, Treyveon Henderson OSU, Jaydn Ott Cal, Donovan Edwards Michigan, Tahj Brooks Texas Tech, Devin Neal Kansas, Damien Martinez (transfer portal), Ashton Jeanty Boise State all are established runners still in college, I'd put Gordon, Hampton, Judkins, Henderson as RB1 this year. Maybe Donovan Edwards too, it'd be close. Etienne could blow up at Georgia, CJ Baxter is the lone guy at Texas now, Tawee Walker will get lots of run for the Badgers, and there's always 2-3 that come out of nowhere.

Don't chase a poor class Gute, just let Jacobs and Dillon handle it, pick from a spot of value next year. 

Link to comment
Share on other sites
Guest
This topic is now closed to further replies.
 Share
Go to topic listing


×
×
  • Create New...