(Poll) Chubb to the Giants, Should We Trade OR Take Saquon, Minkah, or Ward?

[Aztec Hammer]

17 minutes ago, mistakey said:

saquon or ward

This. Flip picks with Broncos for a 2nd before you take either one.

[MWil23]

My dream/too much Madden scenario:

1. CLE: Darnold

2. NYG: Rosen

3. NYJ: Mayfield

4. Browns TRADE with Denver. Dorsey leverages Buffalo and gets Denver to give up WAY too much to move up 1 spot to get Josh Allen (#5, 2019 #1).

5. Browns bluff the Chicago Bears, thinking that we are 100% going to get Barkley. Chicago trades us #8, #40, and a 2019 #2 to get the "best player in the draft".

8. Browns: DENZEL WARD. We get the #1 CB and best man/press man corner in the entire draft.

26. The Browns trade #35 and #64 for the rights to select Guice 

[Mind Character]

2 hours ago, NudeTayne said:

Why would the New York Giants take Chubb when they are moving to a 3-4? Chubb seems like a prototype for 3 defensive end at 6 for 270 lb give or take. I can't see any way they take him, especially with all the trade down offers they are likely receiving if they are indeed not taking a quarterback. That said, what a bizarre NFL world we are living in when the New York Giants don't think they need to draft a quarterback at pick 2 in a very quality passer class. Eli Manning has not looked especially good in at least three seasons and is nearing 40. I just... I just can't.

 

2 hours ago, MWil23 said:

I'm personally of the belief that the NY Giants trading JPP doesn't alter what they do at #2 and guarantee them Chubb. They obviously wanted to dump salary and he wasn't a good fit in the 3-4.

They could still go Rosen/QB at #2 and try to get a solid 3-4 guy in the 2nd (Hubbard for example if you like his fit there).

The thing is... Their new DC James Bettcher plays Nickel 78% of the time with 4 down lineman in a 4-2-1(NCB/NSS)-4 scheme.

So, many on the Giants forum think Bettcher still really wants Bradley Chubb at DE b/c Chubb actually dropped a lot in college to be good enough to handle the rare times he needs to drop.

Doesn't seem ideal for Chubb in a Generic 34 defense, but many aren't so sure with the Giants especially with how Dave Gettleman thinks about DE/DTs.

I still think it would be crazy for them not to take a QB, but to the Giant faithful based on the specificity of the 34scheme to be run....many think Chubb is their guy.

[Kiwibrown]

I would love if Chubb is their guy. 

This class seems like there are a heap of guys with very high upside but not many prospects that don't have big questions. 

Ward underized

Barkley is he a 3 down back

Does Chubb turn corners well enough?

no stand out WR's

[dawgpound1816]

This is my worst nightmare. 

I'm still gonna toot and ride for Chubb until he's gone before the Browns pick at 4. 

What if the Browns take Chubb at #1 and trade up to #2 for Rosen/Darnold?

[LETSGOBROWNIES]

15 minutes ago, dawgpound1816 said:

This is my worst nightmare. 

I'm still gonna toot and ride for Chubb until he's gone before the Browns pick at 4. 

What if the Browns take Chubb at #1 and trade up to #2 for Rosen/Darnold?

If the Giants wanted to trade down, why not take the Jets deal?

[brownie man]

I went with Davenport as long as its with Buffalo 

12. Davenport

22. top corner/ or Maurice Hurst 

 

[duke2056]

any trade down scenario depends on the specific offer.  I would be fine dropping down to any pick in the 1st if the offer is right. 

[Bucketheadsdad]

2 hours ago, MWil23 said:

My dream/too much Madden scenario:

1. CLE: Darnold

2. NYG: Rosen

3. NYJ: Mayfield

4. Browns TRADE with Denver. Dorsey leverages Buffalo and gets Denver to give up WAY too much to move up 1 spot to get Josh Allen (#5, 2019 #1).

5. Browns bluff the Chicago Bears, thinking that we are 100% going to get Barkley. Chicago trades us #8, #40, and a 2019 #2 to get the "best player in the draft".

8. Browns: DENZEL WARD. We get the #1 CB and best man/press man corner in the entire draft.

26. The Browns trade #35 and #64 for the rights to select Guice 

The Bears deal is interesting, but I guess I have to wonder if they are really ready to throw in the towel on Jordan Howard.  Kid is a solid back.  Hell, have them toss in Howard and give us a 3rd instead.