Make your own Madden Ratings

ttitansfan4life · August 5, 2017

We've done this before in the past. Just make madden ratings for your rosters for your team. I've always played madden with the mindset of....

95> = Elite

90-94 = Great

85-89 = Good

80-84 = Above Average

75-79 = Average

71-74 = Below Average

70< = Bad/Young players who haven't done much yet(Not counting higher picks). Rookies are obviously different so rare them accordingly....

You don't have to use this but it's what I've always done.

QB: Marcus Mariota(84), Matt Cassell(71), Alex Tanney(64)

RB: Demarco Murray(90), Derrick Henry(83), Khalfani Muhammad(64)

FB: Jalston Fowler(79)

WR: Rishard Matthews(83), Corey Davis(79), Tajae Sharpe(75), Harry Douglas(71)

WR, Eric Decker(83), Taywan Taylor(75), Eric Weems(63)

TE: Delanie Walker(93), Jonnu Smith(72), Phillip Supernaw(69)

LT: Taylor Lewan(91), Dennis Kelly(72)

LG: Quinton Spain(81),

C: Ben Jones(84), Tim Lelito(69)

RG: Josh Kline(74)

RT: Jack Conklin(87)

DE: Jurrell Casey(91), Karl Klug(80)

NT: Sylvester Williams(72),

DT: DaQuan Jones(78), Austin Johnson(75)

OLB: Brian Orakpo(88), Eric Walden(76), Aaron Wallace(68)

ILB: Wesley Woodyard(79), Nate Palmer(66), Darren Bates(64)

ILB: Avery Williamson(80), Jayon Brown(68)

OLB: Derrick Morgan(83), Kevin Dodd(74)

CB: Logan Ryan(84), Adoree Jackson(74), Demontre Hurst(68)

CB: LeShaun Sims(76), Brice McCain(73)

FS: Kevin Byard(79), Kalan Reed(66)

SS: Johnathan Cyprien(80), DaNorris Searcy(74), Bryden Trawick(66)

K: Ryan Succop(84)

P: Brett Kern(84)

Adrenaline_Flux · August 5, 2017

Right now, heading into the season...

QB: Blake Bortles (74), Chad Henne (72), Brandon Allen (69)

RB: Chris Ivory (81), Leonard Fournette (80), T.J. Yeldon (79), Corey Grant (73)

FB: Tommy Bohanon (74), Marquez Williams (68)

WR: Allen Robinson (87), Marqise Lee (83), Allen Hurns (83), Dede Westbrook (69), Rashad Greene (69)

TE: Marcedes Lewis (78), Mychael Rivera (74), Ben Koyack (71)

LT: Cam Robinson (75), Josh Wells (72)

LG: Patrick Omameh (71), Tyler Shatley (69)

C: Brandon Linder (94), Luke Bowanko (74)

RG: A.J. Cann (73), Earl Watford (68)

RT: Jermey Parnell (74), Jeremiah Poutasi (70)

DE: Calais Campbell (95), Yannick Ngakoue (81), Dante Fowler Jr. (76), Dawuane Smoot (72), Lerentee McCray (66)

DT: Malik Jackson (94), Abry Jones (80), Sheldon Day (75), Stefon Charles (73), Michael Bennett (68)

OLB: Telvin Smith (91), Paul Posluszny (87), Audie Cole (70), Blair Brown (67)

MLB: Myles Jack (75), Hayes Pullard III (74)

Free Safety: Tashaun Gipson (80), Peyton Thompson (75)

Strong Safety: Barry Church (80), Jarrod Wilson (72)

Cornerback: A.J. Bouye (91), Jalen Ramsey (89), Aaron Colvin (80), Josh Johnson (75), Jalen Myrick (66), Tyler Patmon (64)

K: Jason Myers (76)

P: Brad Nortman (78)

LS: Carson Tinker (100, RIP baybay), Matt Overton (40, classic Madden)

bucsfan333 · August 6, 2017

Offense (82.1 AVG)

QB: Jameis Winston (82) | Ryan Fitzpatrick (75) | Ryan Griffin (66)

RB: Doug Martin (81) | Jacquizz Rodgers (80) | Charles Sims (78) | Jeremy McNichols (71) | Peyton Barber (69)

FB: Austin Johnson (68)

TE: Cameron Brate (82) | OJ Howard (80) | Luke Stocker (74) | Antony Auclair (69)

LT: Donovan Smith (74) | Leonard Wester (69)

LG: Kevin Pamphile (78) | Evan Smith (75)

C: Ali Marpet (88) | Joe Hawley (75)

RG: JR Sweezy (77)

RT: Demar Dotson (80) | Caleb Benenoch (68)

Defense (82.6 AVG)

LE: William Gholston (78) | Jacquies Smith (73) | Ryan Russell (67)

DT: Gerald McCoy (94) | Chris Baker (84) | Clinton McDonald (77) | Stevie Tu'ikolovatu (65)

RE: Robert Ayers (85) | Noah Spence (78) | George Johnson (72)

LOLB: Devante Bond (72) | Kendell Beckwith (70)

MLB: Kwon Alexander (85) | Richie Brown (61)

ROLB: Lavonte David (87) | Adarius Glanton (64)

FS: Kieth Tandy (79) | Justin Evans (71)

SS: Chris Conte (77) | JJ Wilcox (75)

K: Nick Folk (76) | Roberto Aguayo (70)

P: Bryan Anger (95)

Johnny Nix · August 6, 2017

Bengals- I'll just do projected 53 or close to it

QB- Dalton- 87, McCarron- 78

RB- Bernard- 82, Hill- 79, Mixon- 78, Peerman- 70

WR- Green- 97, Lafell- 81, Boyd- 78, Ross- 78, Core- 75, Malone- 72, Erickson- 72

TE- Eifert- 90, Hewitt-77, Kroft- 76, Uzomah- 75

OT- Ogbeuhi- 72, Fisher- 71, Winston- 70

OG- Boling- 85, Smith- 78, Hopkins- 75, Westerman-75

C- Bodine- 77, Johnson- 75

DE- Dunlap- 88, Johnson- 78, Willis- 74, Clarke- 73

DT- Atkins- 95, Billings- 76, Hardison-75, Sims-75, Glasgow- 72

LB- Burfict-92, Minter- 86, Rey- 80, Vigil-79, Lawson- 77, Evans- 70

CB- Jones- 87, Kirkpatrick- 85, Dennard- 78, Jackson III- 77, Shaw- 77

S- Iloka- 88, Williams- 81, Fejedelem- 75, Smith- 75

K- Elliot- 74

P- Huber- 85

48 1/2ers · August 7, 2017

95> = Elite

90-94 = Great

85-89 = Good

80-84 = Above Average

75-79 = Average

71-74 = Below Average

QB- Brian Hoyer (77) CJ Beathard (69) Matt Barkley (70)

RB- Hyde (83) Juszcyk (96) Hightower (75) Joe Williams (74) Breida (69)

WR- Garcon (88) Goodwin (81) Kerley (76) Taylor (73) Robinson (71)

TE- George Kittle (74) Vance McDonald (75) Logan Paulsen (73)

OL- Joe Staley (92) Trent Brown (79) Jeremy Zuttah (79) Daniel Kilgore (73) Josh Garnett (73) Zane Beadles (73)

DL- DeForest Buckner (87) Arik Armstead (80) Solomon Thomas (81) Earl Mitchell (77) Elvis Dumervil (78) Aaron Lynch (77) Quinton Dial (76)

LB- Navorro Bowman (93) Reuben Foster (83) Ahmad Brooks (80) Malcom Smith (77) Ray Ray Armstrong (74)

CB- Rashard Robinson (85) Dontae Johnson (75) K'waun Williams (74) Ahkello Witherspoon (74) Keith Reaser (74)

S- Jimmie Ward (82) Eric Reid (78) Jaquiski Tartt (75) Lorenzo Jerome (71) Adrian Colbert (68)

ST- Gould (79) Pinion (78) Nelson (90)

Whoever I left off I probably have <71

Forge · August 7, 2017

10 minutes ago, 48 1/2ers said:

95> = Elite

90-94 = Great

85-89 = Good

80-84 = Above Average

75-79 = Average

71-74 = Below Average

QB- Brian Hoyer (77) CJ Beathard (69) Matt Barkley (70)

RB- Hyde (83) Juszcyk (96) Hightower (75) Joe Williams (74) Breida (69)

WR- Garcon (88) Goodwin (81) Kerley (76) Taylor (73) Robinson (71)

TE- George Kittle (74) Vance McDonald (75) Logan Paulsen (73)

OL- Joe Staley (92) Trent Brown (79) Jeremy Zuttah (79) Daniel Kilgore (73) Josh Garnett (73) Zane Beadles (73)

DL- DeForest Buckner (87) Arik Armstead (80) Solomon Thomas (81) Earl Mitchell (77) Elvis Dumervil (78) Aaron Lynch (77) Quinton Dial (76)

LB- Navorro Bowman (93) Reuben Foster (83) Ahmad Brooks (80) Malcom Smith (77) Ray Ray Armstrong (74)

CB- Rashard Robinson (85) Dontae Johnson (75) K'waun Williams (74) Ahkello Witherspoon (74) Keith Reaser (74)

S- Jimmie Ward (82) Eric Reid (78) Jaquiski Tartt (75) Lorenzo Jerome (71) Adrian Colbert (68)

ST- Gould (79) Pinion (78) Nelson (90)

Whoever I left off I probably have <71

Largely okay with most of these, but you're quite a bit higher on these guys as a whole. But I think it depends on what the scale encompasses. Brian Hoyer, is not an "average" starting quarterback if you were to throw out the rankings - he'd have to fall somewhere (if you want to do it as tier groupings) between what, 13-17 or so? I don't see that happening. But if the ranking number is against all quarterbacks in the league, sure, he's above average. So It depends on which way your grading.

There's no way that Goodwin can be an 81. He cannot be considered "above average". I know that as a fanbase we love what we are hearing from camp, but the guy's career high in receptions for a season is 29, he had a total of 3 the prior 2 years before that. He hasn't shown a whole ton at this level at this point in time. Staley and Bowman is a reputation scoring to me - Bowman is not the same as he was pre-injury and Staley is coming off a very substandard season for him where he was probably an average left tackle. You could easily make an argument he's not a top ten left tackle any more.

Robinson is an interesting one. I think that he's good, but the sample size is pretty small. Still, given that there is a bit of a sample size there, and the fact that nearly all the damage against him was done in 2 games last year and he was very, very good in all of the others, I probably am going to be right around this grade as well. Also interesting that you have Johnson with a higher grade than WIlliams. I'd actually have Williams with a much better grade than him. I'd probably be in the 77-78 range for him, and in the 69-70 range for Johnson.

I'd probably have Armstead higher than you . He doesn't have much in the way of bulk stats, and the sample size is limited again, but on an efficiency basis, he's been scary good, so I'd be willing to put him as a good.

Kiwibrown · August 7, 2017

95> = Elite

90-94 = Great

85-89 = Good

80-84 = Above Average

75-79 = Average

71-74 = Below Average

QB Osweiler 75, Kessler 75, Kizer 75

RB Crowell 85, Johnson 80, Dayes 72

FB Vitale 80

WR Britt 81, Coleman 79, Louis 71, Higgins, 69, Payton 68.

TE Njoku 77, DeValve 74, Telfer 76 (run blocking TE)

Ot Thomas 95, Johnson 66, Coleman 79, Erving 75

OG Bitonio 85, Zeitler, 91, Greco 80,

C Tretter 84.

DE Garrett 85, Ogbah 84, Nassib, 73, Holmes 70

DT Shelton 85, Bryant 79, Brantley 73, Ogunjobi, 73

LB Collins, 91, Kirksey 86, Schobert 70,.

CB Haden 84, Taylor 83, BBC, 78, McCourtey 77

FS Ed Reynolds 72, Kindred, 71

SS Peppers 79, NJ Jets safety 72.

K gonzalez 72

P colquet 79.

LS Huglet 78

Returner Alford 88 (as a returner)

The rest 69 and below.

48 1/2ers · August 7, 2017

36 minutes ago, Forge said:

Largely okay with most of these, but you're quite a bit higher on these guys as a whole. But I think it depends on what the scale encompasses. Brian Hoyer, is not an "average" starting quarterback if you were to throw out the rankings - he'd have to fall somewhere (if you want to do it as tier groupings) between what, 13-17 or so? I don't see that happening. But if the ranking number is against all quarterbacks in the league, sure, he's above average. So It depends on which way your grading.

There's no way that Goodwin can be an 81. He cannot be considered "above average". I know that as a fanbase we love what we are hearing from camp, but the guy's career high in receptions for a season is 29, he had a total of 3 the prior 2 years before that. He hasn't shown a whole ton at this level at this point in time. Staley and Bowman is a reputation scoring to me - Bowman is not the same as he was pre-injury and Staley is coming off a very substandard season for him where he was probably an average left tackle. You could easily make an argument he's not a top ten left tackle any more.

Robinson is an interesting one. I think that he's good, but the sample size is pretty small. Still, given that there is a bit of a sample size there, and the fact that nearly all the damage against him was done in 2 games last year and he was very, very good in all of the others, I probably am going to be right around this grade as well. Also interesting that you have Johnson with a higher grade than WIlliams. I'd actually have Williams with a much better grade than him. I'd probably be in the 77-78 range for him, and in the 69-70 range for Johnson.

I'd probably have Armstead higher than you . He doesn't have much in the way of bulk stats, and the sample size is limited again, but on an efficiency basis, he's been scary good, so I'd be willing to put him as a good.

For the most part I'm grading them based off of how I would rank them among their own positions.

So Hoyer compared to the rest of the QB's in the league is about average. Goodwin I am a little high on but he was a good player last year for the Bills, as a receiver he's one thing but as an overall weapon it puts him higher, he's our #2 receiver pretty clearly right now and that puts him ahead of Kerley who I feel good about his grade. Bowman fully recovered from injury is an Elite player. I need to see with my own eyes that he's slowed down before i acknowledge that he's still not a top 5 ILB in this game. Staley is pretty much the same, only he doesnt have the injury history and I saw him play less than elite but he's still likely the best lineman in the division. Robinson by a lot of measures had a great season last year. His inexperience is why he isnt higher but he's on is way towards being a go to #1 corner, and I bet most people will rank a good #2 corner higher than I ranked Robinson. With Williams I'll admit I havent seen play much so idono I'm going off of what i've mostly read or barely seen, so you could be right there with how he's graded compared to others.

43M · August 7, 2017

When I used to edit ratings in Madden, this was what I went by.....

*Note - Got lazy and decided just to do starters and a few other key players.

Ratings

97-99= Elite

91-96 = Great

85-90 = Good

79-84 = Above Average

71-78 = Average

65-70 = Below Average

60-64 - Fringe Guys/Training Camp Bodies/Emergency Signings

59 and Lower - Find a new profession

QB

Ben Roethlisberger - 91

Landry Jones - 68

Josh Hobbs - ??? (65)

RB

LeVeon Bell - 97

James Conner - ??? (71)

Fitz Touissant - 69

WR

Antonio Brown - 97

Martavis Bryant - 83 (90 at the top of his game, which I dont think he will be at)

Eli Rogers - 76

Juju Smith Schuster - ??? (72)

Sammie Coates - 72 - 79 (Depending which Coates shows up)

Justin Hunter - 72

TE

Jesse James - 75

Xavier Grimble - 70

OLine

Allejandro Villanueva - 83

Marcus Gilbert - 87

David DeCastro - 90

Ramon Foster - 80

Maurkice Pouncey - 91

DE

Stephon Tuitt - 84

Cam Heyward - 92

DT

Javon Hargrave - ??? (76)

OLB

Bud Dupree - 78

James Harrison - 81

TJ Watt - ??? (76)

ILB

Ryan Shazier - 84

Vince Williams - 74-79 (Hard to say to be honest)

CB

Artie Burns - ??? (79)

William Gay - 74

Ross Cockrell - 71

Cam Sutton - ??? (67)

S

Sean Davis - ??? (77)

Mike Mitchell - 76

Robert Golden - 74

K

Chris Boswell - 86

P

For some reason, I forget who our punter is right now, and too tired to look it up.

daineraider · August 7, 2017

Raiders

QB: Carr-88, Manuel 72

RB: Lynch-86, Washington 80, Richard 79

FB: Olawale-90

WR: Cooper-89, Crabtree 84, Patterson 79, Roberts 74

TE: Cook-84, Walford 75, Smith 74

LT: Penn-88

LG: Osemele-95

C: Hudson-91

RG: Jackson-87

RT: Newhouse-73

DE: Mack-97, Edwards 84, Autry 77, Ward 68

DT: Ellis-74, Vanderdoes 70, Latham 69

LB: Irvin-90, James 73, Jenkins 72, Cowser 69

CB: Amerson-86, Smith 82, Conley 79, Carrie 77

S: Nelson-84, Joseph 84, Melifonwu 76

K: Seabass-86

P: The King-91

BleedTheClock · August 7, 2017

Cleveland Browns

QB: Cody Kessler (80)---Deshone Kizer (74)---Brock Osweiler (71)---Kevin Hogan (67)

RB: Isaiah Crowell (85)---Duke Johnson (82)---Matt Dayes (67)

FB: Dan Vitale (72)

WR: Josh Gordon (78)---Kenny Britt (76)---Corey Coleman (76)---Ricardo Louis (68)---Rashad Higgins (67)---Jordan Payton (64)

TE: David Njoku (78)---Seth DeValve (73)---Randall Telfer (71)

LT: Joe Thomas (94)---Roderick Johnson (73)

LG: Joel Bitonio (90)---Spencer Drango (70)

C: JC Tretter (82)---(Austin Reiter (72)

RG: Kevin Zeitler (90)---John Greco (77)

RT: Shon Coleman (71)---Cameron Erving (68)

LE: Emmanuel Ogbah (83)---Carl Nassib (78)

DT: Danny Shelton (84)---Desmond Bryant (80)---Caleb Brantley (77)---Larry Ogunjobi (72)

RE: Myles Garrett (84)---Nate Orchard (70)

LOLB: Jamie Collins (88)---Joe Schobert (71)

MLB: Tank Carder (71)---Domonique Alexander (69)

ROLB: Christian Kirksey (88)---James Burgess (68)

CB: Joe Haden (81)---Jason McCourty (78)---Jamar Taylor (76)---Briean Boddy-Calhoun (75)---Howard Wilson (69)---Channing Stribling (66)

FS: Jabrill Peppers (78)---Derrick Kindred (67)

SS: Calvin Pryor (76)---Ibraheim Campbell (66)

K: Zane Gonzales (73)

P: Britton Colquitt (77)

Superstar Development Players:

(Joe Thomas, Joel Bitonio, Myles Garrett)

Quick Development Traits:

(Isaiah Crowell, David Njoku, Kevin Zeitler, Emmanuel Ogbah, Jamie Collins, Christian Kirksey, Jabrill Peppers)

cddolphin · August 7, 2017

Work on your formatting people yeesh..

QB: Jay Cutler 80, Matt Moore 73 (would've put Tannehill at 85)
RB: Jay Ajayi 87, Kenyan Drake 81
WR: Jarvis Landry 88, DeVante Parker 86, Kenny Stills 81
TE: Julius Thomas 76, Anthony Fasano 76
OL: Laremy Tunsil 90, Kraig Urbik 69, Mike Pouncey 85, Jermon Bushrod 71, Ju'Wuan James 79
average (11 personnel): 81.09

DE: Cameron Wake 91, Andre Branch 80
DT: Ndamukong Suh 95, Jordan Phillips 78
LB: Lawrence Timmons 79, Raekwon McMillan 79, Kiko Alonso 81
CB: Byron Maxwell 83, Xavien Howard 81, Tony Lippett 80
FS: Nate Allen 77
SS: Reshad Jones 94
average (4-3 nickel base): 83.55

Kiwibrown · August 7, 2017

17 hours ago, daineraider said:

Raiders

QB: Carr-88,

Feel free to give Carr another 3-5 points.

Between, Carr and Rodgers and then the likes of Tebow, QB release time needs to become a stat.

People who wind mill the football are much worse than those who have a quick release.

cddolphin · August 8, 2017

13 hours ago, Kiwibrown said:

People who wind mill the football are much worse than those who have a quick release.

One of the biggest reasons I don't think Bortles or Wentz will be succesful NFL QBs.

D82 · August 8, 2017

RATINGS

97-99= Elite

91-96 = Great

85-90 = Good

79-84 = Above Average

71-78 = Average

65-70 = Below Average

60-64 - Fringe Guys/Training Camp Bodies/Emergency Signings

59 and Lower - Find a new profession

QB
Dak Prescott (87)
Kellen Moore (76)
Luke McCown (68)
Cooper Rush (60)

RB
Ezekiel Elliott (91)
Darren McFadden (80)
Alfred Morris (79)
Rod Smith (70)
Ronnie Hillman (64)

FB
Keith Smith (71)

WR
Dez Bryant (95)
Terrence Williams (86)
Cole Beasley (84)
Brice Butler (75)
Ryan Switzer (68)* - low mainly due to being a rookie...think he'll end up being at least a good player)

TE
Jason Witten (88)
James Hanna (75)
Geoff Swaim (72)
Rico Gathers (69)

OT
Tyron Smith (99)
La'el Collins (80)
Byron Bell (68)

OG
Zack Martin (99)
Chaz Green (76)
Jonathan Cooper (75)

C
Travis Frederick (97)
Joe Looney (72)

DE
DeMarcus Lawrence (81)
David Irving (80)
Benson Mayowa (76)
Taco Charlton (74)
Charles Tapper (71)

DT
Maliek Collins (84)
Tyrone Crawford (79)
Stephen Paea (77)
Cedric Thornton (76)

OLB
Sean Lee (90)
Kyle Wilber (76)
Damien Wilson (68)

MLB
Anthony Hitchens (78)
Jaylon Smith (74)
Mark Nzeocha (69)

CB
Orlando Scandrick (86)
Anthony Brown (80)
Nolan Carroll (77)
Chidobe Awuzie (74)
Jourdan Lewis (68)

S
Byron Jones (87)
Jeff Heath (76)
Kavon Frazier (67)
Xavier Woods (65)

K
Dan Bailey (98)

P
Chris Jones (86)

Make your own Madden Ratings

Recommended Posts

Link to comment

Share on other sites

Link to comment

Share on other sites

Link to comment

Share on other sites

Link to comment

Share on other sites

Link to comment

Share on other sites

Link to comment

Share on other sites

Link to comment

Share on other sites

Link to comment

Share on other sites

Link to comment

Share on other sites

Link to comment

Share on other sites

Link to comment

Share on other sites

Link to comment

Share on other sites

Link to comment

Share on other sites

Link to comment

Share on other sites

Link to comment

Share on other sites

Archived