Jump to content
Sign in to follow this  
y2lamanaki

49ers Select Dante Pettis, WR, Washington#44 Overall

Recommended Posts

1 hour ago, NinerNation21 said:

So this might stir the pot a bit, but I was just listening to Matt Maiocco's podcast and he had Pettis on as his guest. This is complete paraphrasing, but Maiocco asked if he knew where he was going to be selected and Pettis said that 49ers really liked him and contacted his agent on day 2 and asked if they thought Pettis would still be available at 74. Pettis was kind of difficult to follow during his answer, but essentially, he thought he was going to go in the third and there were other teams interested in him at the top of the 3rd. As we all know, we then traded up to 44 to take him, 30 picks higher than where they wanted to take him. 

This is only my guess, but hearing that there were multiple teams ready to take him at the top of 3rd makes me think they all got into a bidding war and were trying to jump each other with the 49ers winning it by trading in front of someone who was about to take him in the middle of the second.

A bidding war early in the second for a guy seen as a 3rd rounder doesn't make much sense, especially when there were several other really good WRs available. If  his comments are meant to suggest that every team that wanted a WR wanted him I find that hard to believe. There are a whole bunch of mocks and big boards, by guys I think know what they are talking about, that had other WRs rated ahead of him, or had virtually the same rating on him as on other guys.  We  might have thought he was the best WR out there but no one can be sure, or even close to sure, that he will turn out better than Kirk or Miller or Washington or even Chark, or that he would not have still been there at 59. Mayock had every one of those guys rated ahead of Pettis. Jeremiah had both Chark and Kirk in his top 50, but not Pettis so I can't tell how he rated Pettis. PFF had Washinton, Miller and even Gallop ahead of Pettis - and maybe more I could only find their top 6.  You get the point. We gave up a pretty darn good pick, 74, to get our choice of WRs and used that choice to take a guy that was not rated as high as several others by a bunch of pretty good analysts. If we waited we might still have gotten him at 59, or maybe we'd have had to "settle" for one of those other guys and he turns out better anyway. In either case we'd still have been able to take anothger good player at 74,  I like Pettis; I hated the trade up.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
7 minutes ago, big9erfan said:

A bidding war early in the second for a guy seen as a 3rd rounder doesn't make much sense, especially when there were several other really good WRs available. If  his comments are meant to suggest that every team that wanted a WR wanted him I find that hard to believe. There are a whole bunch of mocks and big boards, by guys I think know what they are talking about, that had other WRs rated ahead of him, or had virtually the same rating on him as on other guys.  We  might have thought he was the best WR out there but no one can be sure, or even close to sure, that he will turn out better than Kirk or Miller or Washington or even Chark, or that he would not have still been there at 59. Mayock had every one of those guys rated ahead of Pettis. Jeremiah had both Chark and Kirk in his top 50, but not Pettis so I can't tell how he rated Pettis. PFF had Washinton, Miller and even Gallop ahead of Pettis - and maybe more I could only find their top 6.  You get the point. We gave up a pretty darn good pick, 74, to get our choice of WRs and used that choice to take a guy that was not rated as high as several others by a bunch of pretty good analysts. If we waited we might still have gotten him at 59, or maybe we'd have had to "settle" for one of those other guys and he turns out better anyway. In either case we'd still have been able to take anothger good player at 74,  I like Pettis; I hated the trade up.

All of those guys may have had him ranked in a specific spot, but he's saying his agent was fielding calls from teams on where he might be drafted and he said he was told by several teams that they were targeting him in the late second early third round. I can only speculate that there were several teams wanting him in that range, but the niners felt he was too good of a fit to let him go to another team and traded up.

I listen to all of the talking heads and value their opinions, but once the draft happens and I see where guys were picked, or hear from them, specifically, on where their agents are telling them they could go based off of what teams are telling them, I value that over what an analyst thought would happen.  

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
52 minutes ago, NinerNation21 said:

All of those guys may have had him ranked in a specific spot, but he's saying his agent was fielding calls from teams on where he might be drafted and he said he was told by several teams that they were targeting him in the late second early third round. I can only speculate that there were several teams wanting him in that range, but the niners felt he was too good of a fit to let him go to another team and traded up.

I listen to all of the talking heads and value their opinions, but once the draft happens and I see where guys were picked, or hear from them, specifically, on where their agents are telling them they could go based off of what teams are telling them, I value that over what an analyst thought would happen.  

Again though..most analysts thought he would go in the late second, early third from what I can tell. So I don't know why it even matters...I mean, there's no difference from what the agent and player were saying they were hearing to what most of the talking heads were talking about from the start? I'm just confused on why suddenly everything is different when there is really no difference? 

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
Sign in to follow this  



×