QB Club Rankings (Top QB's this decade)

[D-rell]

The formula used to determined wins is based on "real" Adjusted Net Yards per Attempt (rANY/A) and a Player Volume Factor (VF).

(rANY/A) weights in yards:

TD = 20 yards

1stD = 8 yards

Fum = -35 yards

Int = -45 yards

*note: QB's receive 60% of credit/blame for all passing plays

VF

1.00 = every 38 drop-backs

Win Conversions based on Pythagorean expectation and some of the following info:

avg. QB adjusted YPG = 205

avg. rANY/A = 4.79

etc.

*playoff stats included

*All decade measurement duration Sept. 9th, 2010 - Oct. 16th, 2017

*min of 500 Pass Attempts

*Final Rankings determined by combination of player's rank in wins shares column (volume) and Wins Per column (efficiency)

 

Top QB's this decade

Rk     Name 1     Aaron Rodgers 2     Tom Brady 3     Drew Brees 4     Cam Newton 5     Matt Ryan 6     Peyton Manning 7     Russell Wilson 8     Ben Roethlisberger 9     Philip Rivers 10     Matthew Stafford 11     Andrew Luck 12     Alex Smith 13     Tony Romo 14     Eli Manning 15     Carson Palmer 16     Colin Kaepernick 17     Michael Vick 18     Kirk Cousins 19     Andy Dalton 20     Robert Griffin 21     Joe Flacco 22     Dak Prescott 23     Josh Freeman 24     Ryan Fitzpatrick 25     Jameis Winston 26     Matt Schaub 27     Ryan Tannehill 28     Jay Cutler 29     Tyrod Taylor 30     Marcus Mariota 31     Kyle Orton 32     Blake Bortles 33     Nick Foles 34     Derek Carr 35     Sam Bradford 36     Teddy Bridgewater 37     Brian Hoyer 38     Geno Smith 39     Josh McCown 40     Matt Hasselbeck 41     Donovan McNabb 42     Jake Locker 43     Mark Sanchez 44     Matt Cassel 45     Chad Henne 46     Case Keenum 47     Jason Campbell 48     Carson Wentz 49     Brandon Weeden 50     Christian Ponder 51     Kevin Kolb 52     Trevor Siemian 53     Colt McCoy 54     Shaun Hill 55     Rex Grossman 56     EJ Manuel 57     Mike Glennon 58     Blaine Gabbert 59     Matt Moore 60     Brock Osweiler 61     John Skelton 62     Jared Goff 63     Tarvaris Jackson 64     Seneca Wallace 65     Derek Anderson
My exel file containing decade totals for each player listed: https://docs.google.com/spreadsheets/d/e/2PACX-1vQ5sqR5qGelms0O3k9j3kSrglcL4etpFcZIlCtF3fufhBRnjGJ6iR6RJTLTIoEoHcOOp7qqiXMF-Z04/pubhtml