NFL Forums

GG @rackcs and @MikeT14

Prolly a close-ish start when I think about MVP cases. Mahomes is obv way too high but if I start devaluing the record, Burrow gets a bit out of line. Since I'm a biased Chiefs fan, I'll leave it here for now, but over the course of the season I think these oddities will self-correct. 1. Jayden Daniels 2. Baker Mayfield 3. Lamar Jackson 4. Josh Allen 5. Sam Darnold 6. C.J. Stroud 7. Joe Burrow 8. Justin Fields 9. Geno Smith 10. Dak Prescott 11. Patrick Mahomes II 12. Kyler Murray 13. Kirk Cousins 14. Derek Carr 15. Daniel Jones 16. Trevor Lawrence 17. Brock Purdy 18. Caleb Williams 19. Aaron Rodgers 20. Bo Nix 21. Gardner Minshew II 22. Matthew Stafford 23. Jacoby Brissett 24. Deshaun Watson

Aight homies don't get mad at me for starting yet another QB ranking thread, but last year I threw together a lil web app in order to help me rank QBs. Well, I realized earlier this week that it was week 5, which means we are starting to have enough data to bring it back. Therefore, I slapped on a minty fresh coat of paint, cleaned up some small stuff, and reconnected the APIs to the 2024 endpoints to get it back up and running. It's better on desktop, but it should still be theoretically usable on mobile. Note: This is not for money. There is no advertising. This is not an attempt to spam. I probably can't even handle heavy traffic tbh. But I think it's a fun little tool that I think people might find interesting. Delete the thread if you want, but don't delete me from your heart. Maybe people will like it. Maybe it will be a dead thread in a few days, but if anyone finds it dope then it was worth it, imo. 2024 QB Ranker (click here ^^) WTF IS THIS CRAP?: I feel like people often pick and choose their criteria to fit the argument they are trying to make. When it comes to Josh Allen it's "Look at the TDs" but when we look at Jameis we only think of the turnovers. That makes sense, but the question I have is - Are we weighting them equally for all players, regardless of what that weight is? So, I built a simple tool to customize an algorithm to help define a static criterion and observe how it affects players across the league. HOW IT WORKS: You define what's important to you and it takes the stats, equalizes the stats compared to the field, weights them according to your criteria, and then ranks the players. You can expand certain categories to split the weight of run vs pass etc. Recent games are weighted 5 4 3 2 1 ratio with most recent being heaviest weight. Support stats are changeable and are an attempt to penalize for having Great weapons, coaching, etc. There is also a boost for having a lot of responsibility in the offense. These combine into a support metric. And you can turn any of them off individually or collectively by simply setting the weight to 0. Finally, you can drag and drop players individually to reorder if you are a weak human who can't live with your decisions. CHECK THIS OUT (only important part) This button on the bottom right will COPY THE LIST in a formatted way to your clipboard to paste onto the forums (i resized all the images to be super small kb wise don't worry). e.g. (but the whole list) -> 1. Jayden Daniels 2. Baker Mayfield 3. Lamar Jackson 4. Sam Darnold 5. C.J. Stroud BUT SOGGUST: "You gave [insert team] a [insert grade] for [insert Support Stat]??? Do you even watch football?" No. Not really. I spent about 10 mins total assigning rankings based upon personal biases and the research of asking my cat. That's why there is the ability to modify the stats by hovering over them. Quit ya whinin "My quarterback isn't on the list!!" 5 games minimum. When they play 5 games, they will make the list.

I think the exact opposite, but I see why someone would hold that opinion.

Throwing to puddings, and guarded by turnstiles. What could go wrong.

I want to know how Judon’s doing

I think Geno is a good QB though. I do not believe darnold is good

Pour one out for SBXISBXVSBXVIII

We already lost to Sam Darnold this season. If we lose to Geno Smith too than we deserve to miss the playoffs.

Yeah yeah. Same the same about minshew and your bald headed crip coach. He’ll be 30 by next year with a monster deal. Guys start declining when they hit 30.