You get them at their peak for an entire career: Who are you taking. Trent Williams or Aaron Donald

[El Ramster]

34 minutes ago, Soko said:

Jalen Ramsey. 

Watt basically missed the entire season in 2/3 of Clowney’s PB seasons.

You talk about name recognition. 
@seminoles1 that’s the king right there. Jalen’s first 2 years he was good in LA. I won’t hate or be a homer. He was really good. After that not so much.. I mean either way, In 10 years all you can say Donald had was Jalen Ramsey and he won 3DPOY that should tell you something.. 

[seminoles1]

1 hour ago, El Ramster said:

Like I said. Is Watt a first ballot Hof? We don’t know yet. He’s still playing. A super bowl

would help him. Shame because the guy was a menace. He was an unstoppable force. A force multiplier. A true monster and an impact machine.. At this point he’s turning into frank Gore. Just trying to keep it pushing while the tires are flat, the rim is broken and the axel has 2 miles left. 

You know he retired at the end of the 2022 season, right?

[Danger]

I can't call Aaron Donald the GOAT simply because of the length of his career. Had he just played like 4-5 more seasons, at a relatively similar level, yeah I can absolutely put that into consideration.

[El Ramster]

36 minutes ago, seminoles1 said:

You know he retired at the end of the 2022 season, right?

He came out and said he would like to play again. He wasn’t healthy. He said it on the Mcafee show, he would even suit up for a playoff game for Houston. 

[Soko]

2 hours ago, El Ramster said:

Like I said. Is Watt a first ballot Hof? We don’t know yet.

If we don’t know about Watt, then we don’t know about Donald, either. You can’t have it both ways.

Watt retired before Donald did, he’s not “still playing”.

[seminoles1]

1 hour ago, El Ramster said:

He came out and said he would like to play again. He wasn’t healthy. He said it on the Mcafee show, he would even suit up for a playoff game for Houston. 

He said he would come back if the Texans absolutely needed it, not that he'd like to play again. If you read or listened to both that and his follow-up interview about it, you'd know he's happy in retirement and is not considering any kind of comeback.

To say he's still playing and hanging on like Frank Gore like you did is, once again, completely false.