Jump to content

Which NFL season would field the best all-star team?


Jotun_Fan

Recommended Posts

Let's say you could pick any NFL season from past to 2019, which season would you think would have the best all-star team?  For instance if you say 2000, it would have to be players who only played in that season, and they would have to reasonably have their form from that season.  So if you said 1998 you'd be stuck with rookie Peyton and not prime Peyton.  

One vote I have is for 1994, the team:
RB Barry Sanders
RB Emmitt Smith
QB Steve Young
QB Dan Marino
WR Jerry Rice
WR Michael Irvin
WR Cris Carter
WR Tim Brown
TE Ben Coates
TE Shannon Sharpe
OT Willie Roaf
OT Richmond Webb
OG Randall McDaniel
OG Bruce Matthews
OG Nate Newton
C Dermontti Dawson

DE Bruce Smith
DE Charles Haley
DE Reggie White
DE Neil Smith
DT John Randle
DT Cortez Kennedy
MLB Ken Norton
MLB Hardy Nickerson
OLB Junior Seau
OLB Derrick Thomas
OLB Greg Lloyd
OLB Kevin Greene
CB Deion Sanders
CB Rod Woodson
CB Aeneas Williams
S Darren Woodson
S LeRoy Butler
S Merton Hanks
S Carnell Lake

 

  • Like 1
Link to comment
Share on other sites

  • 3 weeks later...

I like 98

QB S. Young, R. Cunningham

RB T. Davis, M. Faulk, B. Sanders, J. Anderson

WR R. Moss, C. Carter, J. Rice, T. Owens, A. Freeman, O.J. McDuffie, and R. Smith

TE S. Sharpe, F. Wycheck

OT J. Ogden, L. Allen, W. Roaf, T. Boselli

OG B. Mathews, W. Shields, R. McDaniel, R. Brown

C J. Christy, T. Nalen

DEFENSE

DE R. White, M. Strahan, C. Doleman, M. Sinclair

DT J. Randle, W. Sapp, L. Lett, L. Glover

LB K. Greene, D. Thomas, D. Brooks, R. Lewis, Z. Thomas, C. Brown, R. Mckinnon

CB T. Law, D. Sanders, C. Woodson, S. Springs, R. Buchananon, J. Hitchcock

FS S. Knight, S. Atwater

SS L. Milloy, R. Griffith

 

  • Like 1
Link to comment
Share on other sites

2007 

QB: Brady 

QB Manning 

WR Moss

WR Harrison 

WR Owens 

TE Gonzalez 

TE Gates 

RB Tomlinson 

RB Peterson 

OL Mankins 

OL Faneca 

OL Thomas 

OL Huchinson

OL Saturday 

 

DE Peppers

DE Strahan 

DE Tuck

DT Seymour 

DT Wilfork

DT Willians 

LB Urlacher 

LB Ware

LB Lewis 

S Reed

S Sanders /Polamalu (take your pick)

CB Bailey

CB Woodson 

CB Revis (yeah he was a rookie but he was calling and if he’s your number 3, your field is locked down) 

K Vinatieri 

 

 

  • Like 2
Link to comment
Share on other sites

On 5/9/2020 at 3:28 AM, lancerman said:

2007 

QB: Brady 

QB Manning 

WR Moss

WR Harrison 

WR Owens 

TE Gonzalez 

TE Gates 

RB Tomlinson 

RB Peterson 

OL Mankins 

OL Faneca 

OL Thomas 

OL Huchinson

OL Saturday 

 

DE Peppers

DE Strahan 

DE Tuck

DT Seymour 

DT Wilfork

DT Willians 

LB Urlacher 

LB Ware

LB Lewis 

S Reed

S Sanders /Polamalu (take your pick)

CB Bailey

CB Woodson 

CB Revis (yeah he was a rookie but he was calling and if he’s your number 3, your field is locked down) 

K Vinatieri 

Yeah it’s probably this one. I think there were other teams in play for me until I factored in a player that you didn’t even mention.

I mean all these teams are great so it’s not like any one player makes or breaks a squad necessarily, but 2007 also had Devin Hester who had probably the greatest special teams season of all time.

So I mean, just imagine having any of these already overpowered offenses and defenses and adding HIM to the equation back there... that team literally could not be stopped.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

×   Pasted as rich text.   Paste as plain text instead

  Only 75 emoji are allowed.

×   Your link has been automatically embedded.   Display as a link instead

×   Your previous content has been restored.   Clear editor

×   You cannot paste images directly. Upload or insert images from URL.

×
×
  • Create New...