Jump to content

Are you smarter than Gutekunst?? ........... 2024 shadow draft


Recommended Posts

There's no real rules in life so I'll enter mine now:

Round 1: Cooper DeJean, CB - I don't like our CB depth considering their lengthy injury histories. I didn't consider it a massive need, but I felt our only non-depth roster holes were S and LB, so I was comfortable with either CB or OL here for depth. DeJean was BPA and will be a star for another team.

Round 2.1: Keep the trade and Edgerrin Cooper - he, Suamataia and JPJ were the top of my board, so trading down to remove JPJ made it easier to go with a LB. I also would felt there were more tackles I could get later.

Round 2.2: Kingsley Suamataia, T - I wouldn't have dreamed of him falling here, so I would have ran that card up (since I still had a need at T). I love the Bullard pick in real time (since we already had Morgan) but if I took DeJean earlier then I would have trusted that Bullard or Bishop would fall to one of our thirds. Whoops. 

Round 3.1: keep Marshawn - Cool RB. 

Round 3.2: DTD - Safeties dried up some so I take the last day-one starter. 

Round 4: Keep trade, take Devontez Walker. 

Round 5.1: I like Monk, but I had Christian Mahogany ranked higher. He would have been my IOL. 

Round 5.2: Keep Oladipo. Very pleased with the three DBs I ended up with. 

Round 6: The Glover pick confuses me. I'd take Beaux Limmer as a center type. 

Round 7.1: Give me Pratt here, sure. 

Round 7.2: Frank Crum. Hell yeah.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Don't know where else to drop this, but here's a breakdown of how the first round went vs consensus:

Name NFL Team Consensus Big Board Actual Pick % Delta Rank
Caleb Williams Chicago 1 1 0% 15
Jayden Daniels Washington 5 2 -60% 29
Drake Maye New England 2 3 50% 6
Marvin Harrison Jr. Arizona 4 4 0% 15
Joe Alt LA Chargers 10 5 -50% 28
Malik Nabers NY Giants 3 6 100% 2
JC Latham Tennessee 19 7 -63% 30
Michael Penix Jr Atlanta 31 8 -74% 32
Rome Odunze Chicago 6 9 50% 6
JJ McCarthy Minnesota 8 10 25% 9
Olu Fashanu NY Jets 15 11 -27% 25
Bo Nix Denver 35 12 -66% 31
Brock Bowers Las Vegas 7 13 86% 4
Taliese Fuaga New Orleans 16 14 -13% 19
Laiatu Latu Indianapolis 14 15 7% 13
Byron Murphy II Seattle 13 16 23% 10
Dallas Turner Minnesota 9 17 89% 3
Amarius Mims Cincinnati 22 18 -18% 21
Jared Verse LA Rams 17 19 12% 12
Troy Fautanu Pittsburgh 21 20 -5% 18
Chop Robinson Miami 27 21 -22% 23
Quinyon Mitchell Philadelphia 12 22 83% 5
Brian Thomas Jr Jacksonville 20 23 15% 11
Terrion Arnold Detroit 11 24 118% 1
Jordan Morgan Green Bay 36 25 -31% 26
Graham Barton Tampa Bay 25 26 4% 14
Darius Robinson Arizona 34 27 -21% 22
Xavier Worthy Kansas City 32 28 -13% 19
Tyler Guyton Dallas 29 29 0% 15
Nate Wiggins Baltimore 23 30 30% 8
Ricky Pearsall San Francisco 48 31 -35% 27
Xavier Legette Carolina 42 32 -24% 24
Link to comment
Share on other sites

On 4/27/2024 at 1:27 PM, CWood21 said:

Round 1 - CB/S Cooper DeJean
Round 2A - LB Edgerrin Cooper
Round 2B - S Javon Bullard
Round 3A - S Jaden Hicks
Round 3B - TE Ja'Tavion Sanders
Round 4 - RB Will Shipley (original pick)

Since I apparently never finished it.

Round 1 - CB/S Cooper DeJean
Round 2A - LB Edgerrin Cooper
Round 2B - S Javon Bullard
Round 3A - S Jaden Hicks
Round 3B - TE Ja'Tavion Sanders
Round 4 - RB Will Shipley (original pick)
Round 5A - IOL Jacob Monk
Round 5B - S Kitan Oladapo
Rround 6A - OG Christian Mahogany
Round 6B - K Will Reichard
Round 7A - QB Michael Pratt
Round 7B - CB Kalen King

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

×   Pasted as rich text.   Paste as plain text instead

  Only 75 emoji are allowed.

×   Your link has been automatically embedded.   Display as a link instead

×   Your previous content has been restored.   Clear editor

×   You cannot paste images directly. Upload or insert images from URL.

×
×
  • Create New...