Acgott Posted July 9 Share Posted July 9 100: Rich Seubert 99: Brad Benson 98: Eddie Price 97: Hakeem Nicks 96: Willie Williams 95: Saquon Barkley 94: Erik Howard 93: Terry Kinard 92: Darrel Dess 91: Lawrence Tynes https://www.giants.com/100/top100players Of the players I seen, I can’t have Barkley and OBJ over Nicks. That 2011 playoff run was legendary with 444 yards and 4 touchdowns. I don’t care they trump Nicks in regular season yards. Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
minutemancl Posted July 9 Share Posted July 9 5 hours ago, Acgott said: 100: Rich Seubert 99: Brad Benson 98: Eddie Price 97: Hakeem Nicks 96: Willie Williams 95: Saquon Barkley 94: Erik Howard 93: Terry Kinard 92: Darrel Dess 91: Lawrence Tynes https://www.giants.com/100/top100players Of the players I seen, I can’t have Barkley and OBJ over Nicks. That 2011 playoff run was legendary with 444 yards and 4 touchdowns. I don’t care they trump Nicks in regular season yards. OBJ should absolutely be above Nicks, but Saquon should absolutely not. Given that they are just 2 spots apart, I won't look at it too harshly. Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Acgott Posted July 9 Author Share Posted July 9 1 hour ago, minutemancl said: OBJ should absolutely be above Nicks, but Saquon should absolutely not. Given that they are just 2 spots apart, I won't look at it too harshly. OBJ has 800 more yards than Nicks, though he did it in crazily 20 less games and nearly double the touchdowns. OBJ was insane, but the Super Bowl run was special for Nicks. Giants receivers have been poor. Plaxico isn’t making the list with him being #20 all time for receiving yards. Crazy with him having a top 5 moment all time. Hilliard and Cruz are likely out as well meaning only Toomer, OBJ, and Nicks will make the top 100. https://www.pro-football-reference.com/teams/nyg/career-receiving.htm Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Acgott Posted July 11 Author Share Posted July 11 81 - Frank Cope 82 - Kareem McKenzie 83 - Kerry Collins 84 - Ahmad Bradshaw 85 - David Meggett 86 - Erich Barnes 87 - Corey Webster 88 - Howard Cross 89 - Jason Sehorn 90 - Aaron Thomas Next batch is up Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
GMENNATION Posted July 11 Share Posted July 11 On 7/9/2024 at 6:13 PM, Acgott said: OBJ has 800 more yards than Nicks, though he did it in crazily 20 less games and nearly double the touchdowns. OBJ was insane, but the Super Bowl run was special for Nicks. Giants receivers have been poor. Plaxico isn’t making the list with him being #20 all time for receiving yards. Crazy with him having a top 5 moment all time. Hilliard and Cruz are likely out as well meaning only Toomer, OBJ, and Nicks will make the top 100. https://www.pro-football-reference.com/teams/nyg/career-receiving.htm Where are you getting the information that Cruz and Plaxico aren't making the list? Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Acgott Posted July 11 Author Share Posted July 11 4 hours ago, GMENNATION said: Where are you getting the information that Cruz and Plaxico aren't making the list? It’s my prediction based on where Nicks was. Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Shockwave Posted July 12 Share Posted July 12 I watched the entire introduction video with Bob Papa, Corey Webster and Sehorn and it doesn't seem like they ever really explained what the criteria they used to make the list was. If it's not based on some sort of formula that takes into account tenure, championships, stats and it's just kind of opinion based then it'll be pretty pointless trying to predict anything. I'll predict top 5 though: LT Strahan Eli Huff Gifford Possibly Carson Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
GMENNATION Posted July 16 Share Posted July 16 On 7/11/2024 at 4:49 PM, Acgott said: It’s my prediction based on where Nicks was. Interesting. I'll guess Cruz makes it. The numbers are almost identical and I think there is more of an emotional connection to Cruz as a local kid, underdog, etc. Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Acgott Posted July 16 Author Share Posted July 16 3 hours ago, GMENNATION said: Interesting. I'll guess Cruz makes it. The numbers are almost identical and I think there is more of an emotional connection to Cruz as a local kid, underdog, etc. I think it was between him and Nicks and he won due to having a better Super Bowl run. 71 - Antonio Pierce 72 - Ron Johnson 73 - Don Chandler 74 - Jack Gregory 75 - Pepper Johnson 76 - Gary Reasons 77 - John Mendenhall 78 - Mark Haynes 79 - Jeff Hostetler 80- William Roberts Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Acgott Posted July 23 Author Share Posted July 23 Some interesting names on this list 61 - Jason Pierre-Paul 62 - Greg Larson 63 - **** Modzelewski 64 - Jim Burt 65 - Shaun O'Hara 66 - Cal Hubbard 67 - Brian Kelley 68 - Keith Hamilton 69 - Brandon Jacobs 70 - Red Badgro Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Acgott Posted July 30 Author Share Posted July 30 I don’t know how Cruz made this list and so much higher than Nicks 51 - Ottis Anderson 52 - David Diehl 53 - Dave Jennings 54 - Steve Owen 55 - Tom Landry 56 - Mark Collins 57 - Ward Cuff 58 - Ray Wietecha 59 - Victor Cruz 60 - Jumbo Elliott Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
GMENNATION Posted July 31 Share Posted July 31 23 hours ago, Acgott said: I don’t know how Cruz made this list and so much higher than Nicks 51 - Ottis Anderson 52 - David Diehl 53 - Dave Jennings 54 - Steve Owen 55 - Tom Landry 56 - Mark Collins 57 - Ward Cuff 58 - Ray Wietecha 59 - Victor Cruz 60 - Jumbo Elliott Yep- totally understood your argumentation the whole time but Cruz is more recent, had a stronger emotional tie to the area being from Paterson and fans just generally took to him way more than Nicks. It's a subjective list meant to excite fans so I think some of the direct logic is deprioritized. 3 Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Acgott Posted August 6 Author Share Posted August 6 41 - Bart Oates 42 - Pete Gogolak 43 - Bob Tucker 44 - Jack Stroud 45 - Rodney Hampton 46 - Plaxico Burress 47 - Sean Landeta 48 - Jeremy Shockey 49 - Spider Lockhart 50 - Ray Flaherty Damn, now Plaxico is way higher than Nicks Plax 4 years as a Giant- 244 rec, 3681 yds, 33 TD 2007 post season- 18 rec, 221 yds, 1 td. Hakeem Nicks first 4 years 255 rec, 3726 yds, 27 TD 2011 post season- 28 rec, 444 yds, 4 td Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
GMENNATION Posted August 7 Share Posted August 7 I will admit Plaxico is very surprising Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Acgott Posted August 20 Author Share Posted August 20 21 - Arnie Weinmeister 22 - Jim Katcavage 23 - Del Shofner 24 - Kyle Rote 25 - George Martin 26 - Leonard Marshall 27 - Homer Jones 28 - Brad Van Pelt 29 - Joe Morrison 30 - Justin Tuck 31 - Chris Snee 32 - Osi Umenyiora 33 - Fran Tarkenton 34 - Jessie Armstead 35 - Rosey Grier 36 - Benny Friedman 37 - Odell Beckham Jr. 38 - Joe Morris 39 - Alex Webster 40 - **** Lynch Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Recommended Posts
Join the conversation
You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.