Your Top 5 Favorite NCAA Prospects (in order) @ Every Position?

[DefenseWinsChampionships]

QB:
1.) Matt Corral (Ole' Miss).
2.) Kenny Pickett (Pittsburgh).
3.) Carson Strong (Nevada).
4.) Desmond Ridder (Cincinnati).
5.) Sam Howell (UNC).

RB:
1.) Breece Hall (Iowa State).
2.) Isaiah Spiller (Texas A&M).
3.) Kenneth Walker III (Michigan State).
4.) Kyren Williams (Notre Dame).
5.) Sincere McCormick (UTSA).

WR:
1.) Drake London (USC).
2.) Treylon Burks (Arkansas).
3.) Garrett Wilson (Ohio State).
4.) Jahan Dotson (Penn State).
5.) Chris Olave (Ohio State).

(Unfortunately had to remove two WRs who would've been my #1 and #2 if not for ACL injuries in George Pickens (Georgia) and Jameson Williams (Alabama).

TE:

1.) Trey McBride (Colorado State).
2.) Jalen Wydermyer (Texas A&M).
3.) Charlie Kolar (Iowa State).
4.) Isaiah Likely (Coastal Carolina).
5.) Jeremy Ruckert (Ohio State).

O-Line:
1.) Tyler Linderbaum (Iowa).
2.) Evan Neal (Alabama).
3.) Ikem Ekwonu (N.C. State).
4.) Charles Cross (Mississippi State).
5.) Zion Johnson (Boston College).

(Very intrigued by Daniel Faalele of Minnesota (RT) @ 6'9/380 lbs).

Edge Rusher:
1.) Kayvon Thibodeaux (Oregon).
2.) Jermaine Johnson II (FSU).
3.) Aidan Hutchinson (Michigan).
4.) Nik Bonitto (Oklahoma).
5.) Cameron Thomas (San Diego State).

Interior D-Line:
1.) Jordan Davis (Georgia).
2.) DeMarvin Leal (Texas A&M).
3.) Phidarian Mathis (Alabama).
4.) Haskell Garrett (Ohio State).
5.) Perrion Winfrey (Oklahoma).

Linebacker:
1.) Damone Clark (LSU). 
2.) Nakobe Dean (Georgia).
3.) Devin Lloyd (Utah).
4.) Channing Tindall (Georgia).
5.) Christian Harris (Alabama).

(Chad Muma would've made my top 5 if not for the fact he played against much weaker NCAA competition @ Wyoming).

Cornerback:
1.) Derek Stingley Jr. (LSU).
2.) Ahmad Gardner (Cincinnati).
3.) Andrew Booth Jr. (Clemson).
4.) Kaiir Elam (Gators).
5.) Derion Kendrick (Georgia).

Safety:
1.) Kyle Hamilton Jr. (Notre Dame).
2.) Jaquan Brisker (Penn State).
3.) Lewis Cine (Georgia).
4.) Daxton Hill (Michigan).
5.) Kerby Joseph (Illinois).

KR/PR: Marcus Jones of Houston (CB) is the Nation's #1 KR/PR (and I couldn't not mention him because if Braxton Berrios wants $9M per year; say hello to Mr. Marcus Jones). 

Edited February 20, 2022 by DefenseWinsChampionships

[xrade]

Ok, I’ll play since I am off work today.

QB - don’t really care since we ain’t drafting one and I think they are all mediocre at best.

RB - 1.  Allgeier 2. Williams (ND). Since I don’t want to draft a RB before day 3 looking at the others may be moot.

WR - 1. Wilson 2. Dotson 3. Wan’Dale Robinson 4.  Metchie. I think all these guys would work well in LaFleurs system. Again, since I don’t think we should draft a WR in round 1, I will not entertain all the consensus top WR’s. But if we were to target one at 10, give me Wilson.

TE - 1. McBride. 2. Ruckert

OL - 1. Ikem 2. Lindstrom. If we need OL at 4, Ikem, otherwise Lindstrom in round 2.

DE - 1. Hutch 2. Thibs 3. Myjai Sanders

iDL - 1. Leal 2. Travis Jones.

LB - 1. Dean 2. Lloyd 3. Chenal

Cb - 1. Sauce 2. ?

S - 1. Hamilton 2. Hamilton 3. Hamilton

[KingOfNewYork]

2 hours ago, xrade said:

Ok, I’ll play since I am off work today.

QB - don’t really care since we ain’t drafting one and I think they are all mediocre at best.

RB - 1.  Allgeier 2. Williams (ND). Since I don’t want to draft a RB before day 3 looking at the others may be moot.

WR - 1. Wilson 2. Dotson 3. Wan’Dale Robinson 4.  Metchie. I think all these guys would work well in LaFleurs system. Again, since I don’t think we should draft a WR in round 1, I will not entertain all the consensus top WR’s. But if we were to target one at 10, give me Wilson.

TE - 1. McBride. 2. Ruckert

OL - 1. Ikem 2. Lindstrom. If we need OL at 4, Ikem, otherwise Lindstrom in round 2.

DE - 1. Hutch 2. Thibs 3. Myjai Sanders

iDL - 1. Leal 2. Travis Jones.

LB - 1. Dean 2. Lloyd 3. Chenal

Cb - 1. Sauce 2. ?

S - 1. Hamilton 2. Hamilton 3. Hamilton

Is this the effort I can expect from you for FFMD? Because if so you’re fired lol

[xrade]

1 hour ago, KingOfNewYork said:

Is this the effort I can expect from you for FFMD? Because if so you’re fired lol

Lol. No El Jefe. I shall do my best.

[DefenseWinsChampionships]

4 hours ago, KingOfNewYork said:

Is this the effort I can expect from you for FFMD? Because if so you’re fired lol

QB:
1.) 
2.) 
3.) 
4.) 
5.) 

RB:
1.) 
2.) 
3.)
4.) 
5.) 

WR:
1.) 
2.) 
3.) 
4.) 
5.) 

TE:
1.) 
2.) 
3.) 
4.) 
5.) 

O-Line:
1.) 
2.) 
3.) 
4.) 
5.) 

Edge Rusher:
1.) 
2.) 
3.) 
4.) 
5.) 

Interior D-Line:

1.)

2.)
3.) 
4.) 
5.)  

Linebacker:
1.) 
2.) 
3.) 
4.) 
5.) 

Cornerback:
1.) 
2.) 
3.) 
4.) 
5.) 

Safety:
1.) 
2.) 
3.) 
4.) 
5.) 

Show your prospect rankings. 

Edited February 15, 2022 by DefenseWinsChampionships

[TheGDJets]

WR:
1.) Treylon Burks
2.) Jameson Williams
3.) Garrett Wilson 
4.) Jahan Dotson
5.) George Pickens

TE:
1.) Trey McBride 
2.) Jeremy Ruckert 
3.) Jalen Wydermyer
4.) Jake Ferguson
5.) Isaiah Likely 

O-Line:
1.) Evan Neal 
2.) Ikem Ekwonu
3.) Tyler Linderbaum
4.) Kenyon Green
5.) Zion Johnson

Edge Rusher:
1.) Aidan Htchinson
2.) Kayvon Thibodeaux 
3.) Jermaine Johnson
4.) David Ojabo
5.) Kingsley Engabare

Linebacker:
1.) Nakobe Dean 
2.) Devin Lloyd
3.) Christian Harris
4.) Chad Muma
5.) Brandon Smith 

Cornerback:
1.) Ahmad Gardner
2.) Derek Stingley
3.) Andrew Booth
4.) Kaiir Elam 
5.) Alonte Taylor 

Safety:
1.) Kyle Hamilton 
2.) Jaquan Brisker
3.) Lewis Cine 
4.) Daxton HIll
5.) Kerby Joseph 

[Bobby816]

I'm only going to do positions that I think we might draft at all (i.e. I'm not ranking QBs or DTs bc I don't think we're drafting either).

I'd be ecstatic if we can get at least 4 of any of these guys. Optimistically I think we can get 5 though.

 

RB

1. Isaiah Spiller

2. Kenneth Walker

3. Kyren Williams

4. Breece Hall

5. Hassan Haskins

 

WR

1.  Treylon Burks

2. Drake London

3. Jameson Williams

4. Garrett Wilson

5. Chris Olave

 

TE

1. Tre McBride

2. Isaiah Likely

3. Jalen Wydermeyer

4. Jake Ferguson

5. Jeremy Ruckert

 

OT

1. Evan Neal

2. Ikem Ekwonu

3. Charles Cross

4. Daniel Faalele

5. Trevor Penning

 

IOL

1. Tyler Linderbaum

2.. Kenyon Green

3. Zion Johnson

4. Darian Kinnard

5. Jamaree Salyer

 

DE

1. Aidan Hutchinson

2. Kayvon Thibodeaux

3. David Ojabo

4. George Karlaftis

5. Jermaine Johnson

 

LB

1. Devin Lloyd

2. Christian Harris

3. Nakobe Dean

4. Damone Clarke

5. Brian Asamoah

 

S

1. Kyle Hamilton

2. Daxton Hill

3. Jaquan Brisker

4. Jalen Pitre

5. Lewis Cine

 

CB

1. Ahmad Gardner

2. Derek Stingley

3. Andrew Booth

4. Kaiir Elam

5. Roger McCreary

[DefenseWinsChampionships]

I see WRs like George Pickens and Jameson Williams are still in our top 5 WRs. 

No way. Not a chance.  

Just look at Carl Lawson. Had an ACL tear in college and then had another blown ACL in the NFL with Cincinnati and now coming off of an Achilles Tendon injury with our Jets; the kid was already ACL damaged goods before the NFL draft.  

Or better yet Odell Beckham Jr. Blown ACL with NYG and less than 2-3 years later blows another ACL on SB night. 

It's sad. I once had George Pickens and Jameson Williams as my #1 and #2 top favorite NCAA WRs. But not anymore.

There is no way in hell I'm drafting a WR with already blown ACLs during the top two rounds. Maybe 5th or 6th round but ACL kids like George Pickens, Jameson Williams and John Metchie III are completely removed off of my board. A serious knee injury? Already damaged goods before playing an NFL snap?

No way. 

Not even #24 could ever return to greatness after his ACL injury as a Jet. He was only 26-27 and enjoying his prime years before that ACL injury. He was never the same thereafter. 

Edited February 15, 2022 by DefenseWinsChampionships

[Bobby816]

4 minutes ago, DefenseWinsChampionships said:

I see WRs like George Pickens and Jameson Williams are still in our top 5 WRs. 

No way. Not a chance.  

Just look at Carl Lawson. Had an ACL tear in college and then had another blown ACL in the NFL with Cincinnati and now coming off of an Achilles Tendon injury with our Jets; the kid was already ACL damaged goods before the NFL draft.  

Or better yet Odell Beckham Jr. Blown ACL with NYG and less than 2-3 years later blows another ACL on SB night. 

It's sad. I once had George Pickens and Jameson Williams as my #1 and #2 top favorite NCAA WRs. But not anymore.

There is no way in hell I'm drafting a WR with already blown ACLs during the top two rounds. Maybe 5th or 6th round but ACL kids like George Pickens, Jameson Williams and John Metchie III are completely removed off of my board. A serious knee injury? Already damaged goods before playing an NFL snap?

No way. 

Not even #24 could ever return to greatness after his ACL injury as a Jet. He was only 26-27 and enjoying his prime years before that ACL injury. He was never the same thereafter. 

Jameson Williams will still be a 1st rounder. Watch. 

[DefenseWinsChampionships]

4 minutes ago, Bobby816 said:

Jameson Williams will still be a 1st rounder. Watch. 

You're probably right but he'll probably never run the same again and/or will blow out his ACL within the next 3 years. 

There is no way I'm touching any kid before the 5th round with an HS/NCAA torn ACL (already) before the NFL. Not a chance. 

Edited February 15, 2022 by DefenseWinsChampionships

[Bobby816]

1 minute ago, DefenseWinsChampionships said:

And he'll probably never run the same again and/or will blow out his ACL within the next 3 years. 

There is no way I'm touching any kid before the 5th round with an HS/NCAA torn ACL already before the NFL. Not a chance. 

Torn ACLs aren't hard to come back from anymore. And when I say anymore. It's been like this for like 10 years. Achilles... and I can be on the same page as you kind of. That's a lot harder to come back from. But an ACL recovery isn't that bad. Jameson Williams won't be able to do pre workout stuff but make no question when he's recovered he will be that 4.3 WR. Whoever gets him is getting a steal. Because pre injury he was in the mix for us at 10. Now I think he's more likely in that 20-30 range. On average players make a 100% recovery from an ACL in around 8 months. He tore it in January... so he will be healthy for the start of the regular season or close to it. 

[DefenseWinsChampionships]

25 minutes ago, Bobby816 said:

Torn ACLs aren't hard to come back from anymore. And when I say anymore. It's been like this for like 10 years. Achilles... and I can be on the same page as you kind of. That's a lot harder to come back from. But an ACL recovery isn't that bad. Jameson Williams won't be able to do pre workout stuff but make no question when he's recovered he will be that 4.3 WR. Whoever gets him is getting a steal. Because pre injury he was in the mix for us at 10. Now I think he's more likely in that 20-30 range. On average players make a 100% recovery from an ACL in around 8 months. He tore it in January... so he will be healthy for the start of the regular season or close to it. 

I was personally pissed at giving Carl Lawson big time FA $ due to already suffering two ACL injuries.  And then before playing 1 single snap as a Jet he ruptured his Achilles tendon.  I just knew he wasn't going to last.

Look at Odell Beckham Jr. Another blown ACL. 

How many players @ WR have torn their ACL and A.) Became a better player than they were pre injury and B.) Didn't have a 2nd ACL injury later on?

100% recovery in 8 months? I'm not buying that because the ACL is never (ever) supposed to tear to begin with and once it does? It'll never be the same; especially on turf.  

[Bobby816]

1 hour ago, DefenseWinsChampionships said:

I was personally pissed at giving Carl Lawson big time FA $ due to already suffering two ACL injuries.  And then before playing 1 single snap as a Jet he ruptured his Achilles tendon.  I just knew he wasn't going to last.

Look at Odell Beckham Jr. Another blown ACL. 

How many players @ WR have torn their ACL and A.) Became a better player than they were pre injury and B.) Didn't have a 2nd ACL injury later on?

100% recovery in 8 months? I'm not buying that because the ACL is never (ever) supposed to tear to begin with and once it does? It'll never be the same; especially on turf.  

I’m not going to list you the countless players that have played great post ACL injuries. The list is darn near endless. Go Google it.

[DefenseWinsChampionships]

2 minutes ago, Bobby816 said:

I’m not going to list you the countless players that have played great post ACL injuries. The list is darn near endless. Go Google it.

Can you at least give me your top 5 @ WR? 

[JetsandI]

1 hour ago, DefenseWinsChampionships said:

Can you at least give me your top 5 @ WR? 

Not going to waste our time to do that but one of your targets (Allen Robinson) did come back from torn ACL.

Heck, NFL's most pain in the butt offensive players in the universe did.    Rob Gronkowski and Adrian Peterson (2k rushing yards !!!!!!!!!!!!!!!)

 

Good enough.