FootballsFuture 2022 Best QB's of the NFL: #1

[BayRaider]

Who is the best QB in your opinion, right now? We'll do this up until 25, or maybe 32. 

Some people get best confused. It's not just who had the best 2021 season. It's not career accolades. And it has nothing to do with age. It's who you think is the best in the league. Right now. Heading into 2022. 

For me I think Rodgers has to be #1. He's playing some of the best football this sport has ever seen, and just nearly flawless. Back to back MVP's with no signs of slowing down. However, some may not think he can keep this pace up, and might have Mahomes or Allen over him, or someone else entirely, which is totally fair. 

[bigbadbuff]

Mahomes.

Rodgers is the regular season king that for some reason is consistently less than himself in the post season. I can’t put that over Mahomes, even though he is the back to back mvp.

[MrOaktown_56]

Honest to god I may just be a prisoner of the moment, but I might put Allen at 1 after that playoff game.

[Uncle Buck]

1.  Mahomes
2.  Allen
3.  Burrow
4.  Rodgers
5.  Herbert
6.  Watson
7.  Wilson

[Soko]

Mahomes, for me.

[FrantikRam]

12 hours ago, Uncle Buck said:

1.  Mahomes
2.  Allen
3.  Burrow
4.  Rodgers
5.  Herbert
6.  Watson
7.  Wilson

 

Damn Watson doesnt play but still over Stafford. Wilson over Stafford? What does this man have to do??

[BayRaider]

1 hour ago, FrantikRam said:

 

Damn Watson doesnt play but still over Stafford. Wilson over Stafford? What does this man have to do??

You honestly think Stafford is better than Wilson? Yikes. 

[FrantikRam]

1 minute ago, BayRaider said:

You honestly think Stafford is better than Wilson? Yikes. 

 

Definitely.

Stafford finished with a better passer rating than Brady, Herbert, Mahomes and Allen. Slightly worse than Wilson. Beat Wilson twice even if he got hurt in the first game, Geno came in and produced more offense than Wilson had up to that point.

Won the Super Bowl and had a great game missing his second WR and down to his fourth TE.

Looking at just last year, I don't see the argument for Watson, Wilson or Herbert. Stafford had a better season than Mahomes and Allen as well.

Aside from bias against Stafford and/or the Rams, there's no argument for Wilson, Watson or Herbert over him.

[BayRaider]

Just now, FrantikRam said:

 

Definitely.

Stafford finished with a better passer rating than Brady, Herbert, Mahomes and Allen. Slightly worse than Wilson. Beat Wilson twice even if he got hurt in the first game, Geno came in and produced more offense than Wilson had up to that point.

Won the Super Bowl and had a great game missing his second WR and down to his fourth TE.

Looking at just last year, I don't see the argument for Watson, Wilson or Herbert. Stafford had a better season than Mahomes and Allen as well.

Aside from bias against Stafford and/or the Rams, there's no argument for Wilson, Watson or Herbert over him.

Your using purely stats and a Super Bowl win as an argument, which is way too black and white. This is about who’s BEST. Not about accomplishments or accolades. This is who you would take, all things equal, in one season. I’d take Wilson all dayyyyy over Stafford. They still win that Super Bowl with Wilson, and with an even more dominant season with Wilson at the helm. 

Stafford will 99% likely not finish ahead of Wilson in these rankings. Ram fans will cry “Ram hate” when it literally has nothing to do with that. 

[Soko]

I think Stafford has overtaken Brady as GOAT tbh if u think otherwise it’s Rams hate

[Jakuvious]

1 hour ago, FrantikRam said:

 

Definitely.

Stafford finished with a better passer rating than Brady, Herbert, Mahomes and Allen. Slightly worse than Wilson. Beat Wilson twice even if he got hurt in the first game, Geno came in and produced more offense than Wilson had up to that point.

Won the Super Bowl and had a great game missing his second WR and down to his fourth TE.

Looking at just last year, I don't see the argument for Watson, Wilson or Herbert. Stafford had a better season than Mahomes and Allen as well.

Aside from bias against Stafford and/or the Rams, there's no argument for Wilson, Watson or Herbert over him.

There's your problem. There's no reason to look at just last year. It literally says in OP it's not just who had the best 2021 season.

[FrantikRam]

9 hours ago, Jakuvious said:

There's your problem. There's no reason to look at just last year. It literally says in OP it's not just who had the best 2021 season.

 

 

That's fair, but then gets confusing. Like Joe Burrow only had one good year, and ultimately factoring in the playoffs, it was worse than Staffords.

[FrantikRam]

10 hours ago, Yin-Yang said:

I think Stafford has overtaken Brady as GOAT tbh if u think otherwise it’s Rams hate

 

To be fair the guy who started this does just legit hate the Rams. We can't figure out why.

[Uncle Buck]

For the record, I do think Stafford is a very good quarterback and he is very close to Wilson in my rankings.

[Soggust]

Not sure I see the argument for Mahomes over Rodgers besides being more awesome in general.

Objectively, something like IMO ->

The Elitist Snobs
1. Rodgers
(Brady)
2. Mahomes

MVP or Bust
3. Allen
4. Herbert
5. Burrow

Better than People Want to Admit
6. Prescott
7. Stafford
8. Wilson
(Watson)
9. Cousins

Prove It 
10. Jackson
11. Murray 
12. Carr
13. Tannehill

Could Do Better, But How?
14. Hurts
15. Jones
16. Wentz
17. Ryan
18. Garoppolo

Herlp! Panik!
19. Winston
20. Bridgewater
21. Goff
22. Tagovailoa
23. Mayfield
24. Lawrence

The Nameless
25+ The Rest

Edited February 22, 2022 by Soggust