Jump to content

My top 18 drafts.


Recommended Posts

Posted (edited)

Someone's got to take the titles, right? Now, it will take time, but I think what I'm going to do with this is to make it a 1-32 ranking of all draft classes. Bear with me.

Top-18 BEST drafts:


They seemingly NEVER have a bad haul. Hamilton at #14 and Linderbaum at #25 were home runs, not to mention the best players in the draft at their respective positions; actually in the past several drafts. Ojabo in the 2nd could pay HUGE dividends, down the road. Doesn't matter if his rookie year is a redshirt one, either. Heal him up, coach him up, then turn him loose later. I have no idea why Travis Jones lasted until the 3rd round, but what a selection at nose tackle. Every one of their SIX 4th-rounders should make the team, and contribute, in some capacity or another. I especially like the 1-2 punch at TE, with Kolar and Likely. Even Tyler Badie, in the 6th, has a chance to stick. Another outstanding job by their front office.

#02. N.Y. JETS.

Easy selection to make, and deservedly so. Four immediate, impact starters with their first four picks. I'm not sure I would have taken Gardner over Thibodeaux, but once Houston took Stingley, I can understand it. Garrett Wilson catching passes from Zach Wilson will be a long-term combo. Atlanta may very well regret selecting London over him. Jermaine Johnson was an outstanding pick, and he should almost certainly prove a steal. Breece Hall, combined with Michael Carter, gives the Jets, at least on paper, a young, highly effective combination at running back. Ruckert should be their future starting tight end, if not immediately. I would have liked to have seen more O-line help, but NO team helped themselves more in this draft.


This may go against the grain a bit, but I absolutely love what they did. It looks like they figured there was nothing really approaching a franchise QB in this class, so they concentrated on other premium positions. Mission accomplished. The selections of Cross and Lucas gives them a tremendously talented pair of pass-blocking young bookends. Whoever eventually DOES wind up being their future starting QB will appreciate it, I'm sure. Walker in the 2nd surprised me a bit, but it'll obviously be a run-first offense this year, so, cool. Boye Mafe helps their pass-rush right away. CB's Bryant and Woolen were both good value selections, and should play soon. Tyreke Smith was a solid pick. Love the selection of Bo Melton in the seventh.


They easily had one of THE best drafts. Trading up for cornerback McDuffie was a smart move, and he will bring some honey badger tendencies to KC. Nothing bad to say about that selection. George Karlaftis was a solid pick, a need pick, and a safe pick. He doesn't have the upside of the elite pass-rushers in this class, true, but he's not going to be a liability. Skyy Moore was an outstanding selection, who will help ease the loss of Tyreek Hill, no question. He will be productive right out of the gate. I'm not the biggest fan of selecting Bryan Cook at safety, because I think there were better players available at the position, but he's not terrible, either. Chenal in the 3rd and Kinnard in the 5th should both be effective future starters.


Well, they had quantity, and they got quality, but I just don't know if it was done the best way possible for the team. Walker and Wyatt totally improve the middle of their defense, but it can be argued that both were slight reaches, as well as taken at the expense of other positions. Watson was the best size/speed combo WR prospect in the draft, and he's used to playing in cold weather, so, worth the risk. The additions of Rhyan, Tom, and Walker can only help their O-line. Doubs and Toure add a couple more targets at WR. Enegbare was a bit of a value in the 5th, but I would have liked to see more pass-rushing help than him, honestly. All-in-all, not a bad group, with lots of players that should make the final roster.


This here is a classic example of why you have to take trades into account for a team's overall draft class. They originally had three 1st-round picks, right before the draft, and they did three different things with them. One was traded to Tennessee for A.J. Brown, which is an automatic win. He's just what Philly needed at WR. One was used to select DT Jordan Davis, who is a bit boom-or-bust, but his "boom" could be sensational. Worth the shot. The other will be the Saint's 1st-rounder next year, which I think has a decent chance of being a top-15 selection. Jurgens will be their future starting center, and Nakobe Dean could wind up being the steal of the draft at ILB. No defensive end help lowers this grade a notch, however.


I think they did a commendable job, considering their circumstances. They weren't going to be able to afford keeping A.J. Brown, so they traded him to Philly, and saved 100 million dollars. Modern N.F.L. economics. They drafted Treylon Burks, who is the closest thing TO Brown in this class, and they were actually lucky he was still there, considering the early run on WR's. McCreary in the 2nd was a smart pick. Maybe not a #1 corner, but could be a VERY good #2. Petit-Frere in the 3rd has immediate swing-tackle potential. And, of course, there's Malik Willis, who fell into a near-ideal situation/team for him. Haskins will be Henry's backup, and Okonkwo will challenge to start at TE. Kyle Phillips could be the next Hunter Renfrow.

#08. DENVER.

In keeping with the taking trades into account theme, there was NO more important pre-draft trade than the one for Russell Wilson by the Broncos, in the entire N.F.L. Sure, he's past his ultimate prime, but he's still the best QB they've had since, well, John Elway. More importantly, he gives them an actual chance to succeed in the toughest division in all of football right now. Cost them their 1st and 2nd, but if you get 3-5 years of quality play, WELL worth it. Bonitto at #64 was a quality pick. Dulcich in the 3rd was sneaky-good, and will help replace the loss of Noah Fant. Damari Mathis in the 4th is an outstanding athlete at cornerback. The rest of their draft gives them at LEAST competition at various other positions.


Hard to think of a better player-to-team selection, not only in this draft, but in recent YEARS, than Hutchinson to his near-hometown Lions. Close as you can probably get to the real ideal. I am still confident that Walker and Thibodeaux have comfortably higher ceilings, but this guy will play his heart out, and be effective. Trading up for Jameson Williams scares me, not only because of the coming off of the ACL injury, but I am never a fan of inter-divisional trades. At least the price was cheap to make the move. He could be very special. I think the selection of Josh Paschal will wind up being a productive one. Kerby Joseph could eventually become a quality safety. Any way you cut it, they definitely are a better team after the draft.


They got talent, they addressed obvious team needs, but this one still kind of falls flat for me a bit. I am skeptical about Drake London being worth the #8 overall pick, as well him even being the best receiver IN the draft. He's actually kind of like a smaller, slower Kyle Pitts, and I'm just not the biggest fan. Jordan Davis in the 1st, and a WR and Pass-rusher in the 2nd might have been better bang. They hit their pass-rusher and ILB needs in the 2nd, with Ebiketie and Andersen, so I can't say much bad about that, really. Both are talented, athletic young players. Desmond Ridder went to a perfect scene, and I personally can't wait to find out if he has what it takes to be an eventual franchise quarterback in the N.F.L. Great pick.


Yes, they only had 6 total selections, which isn't a lot. THAT being said, I challenge ANYONE to find me a team that did more with less in this draft. The selection of Ekwonu at #6 was probably the best pick they could have hoped for. Best all-around O-lineman in the draft, almost certainly their biggest need, and he's even from Charlotte! Bit of a steal, too. I had him as a top-5 talent all day in this draft. The trade-up for Corral was a gutsy move, and only time will tell if it was a savvy one. You make moves like that for quarterbacks, and Darnold isn't making the Pro Bowl anytime soon. Brandon Smith needs time, but has the total athletic profile at LB. Barno is a freak. Mays could start at guard, soon. Kalon Barnes has RARE speed.

#12. N.Y. GIANTS.

Figuratively-speaking, this is a tale of TWO drafts, by the same team. First, the GOOD: They absolutely CRUSHED the 1st round. Better than anybody. Thibs and Neal were the best two picks they could have possibly dreamed of. They each had been mentioned as possible #1 overall picks, and to friggin' get BOTH, at #5 and #7, respectively, at major need positions?!? Simply incredible. Foundation pieces. Now, the BAD: The REST of their draft appears to suck harder than a super-massive black hole at the center of a galaxy, and it's just sad. The only other player I'll comment about is Wan'Dale Robinson, just to say there were maybe 20-25 players that would have helped the team more. This could have been SO much better.


This is a pretty tough one to evaluate, initially. On the one hand, they absolutely did add some fresh new talent, mostly at need positions. They did their job there. On the other hand, it can CLEARLY be argued that they reached, in varying degrees, on most of their picks. Have to wait and see on this one, pretty much. Dotson in the 1st WILL be a weapon, make NO mistake. Never a true #1, though. Mathis in the 2nd was a terrible value pick. Robinson in the 3rd should at least give them a fairly competent power back for the next few years. Butler in the 4th will be a backup safety, and special-teams stud. Sam Howell in the 5th, however, is the key to this draft. Future starting QB, or a forgettable draft pick. No middle ground, I bet.

#14. DALLAS.

If I could sum up their annual body-gathering in one short term, it would be like THIS: Uninspiring, but serviceable. They for sure needed O-line help, so they took a chance on a potentially physically dominating one, in Smith. He may take time, but he could be a MONSTER guard. Williams in the 2nd was a well-documented character risk, but they got a football player. If he develops his game, he could be a double-digit sack threat. Tolbert was a nice WR pickup in the 3rd. Good talent and value. Ferguson in the 4th was "Mehhh", but he'll wind up on the roster. Backup tight end, all day. See what I did there? Their later picks were decent enough, too, seems like. Waletzko and Ridgeway should both make the team. Boring?


Best thing I can say about the picks for my Bills is that we didn't need MUCH, and I think we got what we NEEDED. I'll take the small trade-up for Elam in the 1st, no problem. We probably preferred McDuffie, but Kansas City made our choice for us. Cook in the 2nd gives us a really interesting duo with Singletary. Different games and styles, and both should be effective. The Bernard pick in the 3rd ruined my decade. Maybe not literally. SUPER-reach in my book. I would have selected SO many players instead. I see him as a career backup/special-teamer. Shakir was amazing value in the 5th. Future starting slot WR. Matt Araiza could possibly wind up being our 2nd-most important pick in the draft, after Kaiir Elam. SUPER BOWL!


In direct, polar-opposite contrast to Carolina's draft, I find it hard to identify a team that did LESS with MORE. Just WAY too much risk and reaches for me. They needed help everywhere, sure, but what a dart-throw of a draft. Stingley over Thibodeaux or Gardner, or ANY O-lineman? Trading down to select Kenyon Green, when you could have stayed put, and drafted Hamilton? Pitre was a good pick, Metchie was NOT. In fact, it can be argued that Metchie was one of the worst picks, PERIOD, far as reaches and risks go. Aside from Stingley, maybe. Harris in the 3rd and Pierce in the 4th were at least decent. The rest of their draft is irrelevant. They got starters, but there's NO way this could've have been too much lamer.


NEVER have I seen a more extreme risk than the trade for Deshaun Watson. Not only super-expensive in terms of draft picks surrendered, the ABSURD amount of guaranteed money, the CLEAR legal and character issues, but do you really even see him wanting to be in CLEVELAND, other than the money?!? It's just a bad-looking fit, chemistry-wise. Ask Baker Mayfield about THAT. Simply not a good look. This could wind up being just disastrous for the team, short AND long-term. Grab the popcorn. On the plus side, the rest of their draft was actually pretty good. Emerson, Wright, and Bell were all solid 3rd-round picks, and Winfrey in the 4th is a total steal-of-the-draft candidate. Cade York will be their new placekicker.


Their draft really wasn't all that bad, but I would have liked to see them concentrate on other areas besides linebacker. Travon Walker, last I heard, is being geared up to play that position, but I see him more as a 4-3 end, honestly. Maybe it'll be a hybrid scheme, and at least he's versatile. Him and Josh Allen could certainly bring some heat off the edges. Trading up for Devin Lloyd was an unexpected but worthy move, I'd figure. PROBABLY the best all-around linebacker in the draft, and I'm sure he'll play the inside, as will Chad Muma, their 3rd-round pick at the position. Their other 3rd-rounder, Fortner, the center from Kentucky, was a reach, IMHO. None of their other picks appear to matter much. Kind of a strange team.

Edited by Suffering_Bills
  • Like 6
Link to comment
Share on other sites

11 hours ago, Suffering_Bills said:

Building towards the total 32 team reviews, guys. Feedback?

I don't watch college so have zero knowledge about 99% of the players drafted. But I'm fascinated by the hard work and research people put into it, cheers. 

  • Like 1
Link to comment
Share on other sites

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.

Reply to this topic...

×   Pasted as rich text.   Paste as plain text instead

  Only 75 emoji are allowed.

×   Your link has been automatically embedded.   Display as a link instead

×   Your previous content has been restored.   Clear editor

×   You cannot paste images directly. Upload or insert images from URL.


  • Create New...