InjuredReserve Posted Tuesday at 05:21 PM Share Posted Tuesday at 05:21 PM 2 hours ago, EaglesPeteC said: I don’t understand the question and I won’t respond to it In my top 10 responses of the year 2 Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
InjuredReserve Posted Tuesday at 05:23 PM Share Posted Tuesday at 05:23 PM 31 minutes ago, SirA1 said: 2024 BDL FA is complete! Thank you all for your service. Great work on FA! Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
vikes635 Posted Wednesday at 09:16 AM Share Posted Wednesday at 09:16 AM On 6/20/2024 at 9:57 AM, EaglesPeteC said: Singletary and Mixon are fine but limited ceilings. Mixon out performs "Quality Starters" Pacheco and Swift without injuries happening to any of them! Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Ragnarok Posted Wednesday at 12:18 PM Share Posted Wednesday at 12:18 PM 2 hours ago, vikes635 said: Mixon out performs "Quality Starters" Pacheco and Swift without injuries happening to any of them! No, no he doesn't. Both players crush Mixon on yards per carry which is what matters most. Plus, you can't watch the games and say Mixon has been more effective than either of those guys. And all three guys have played 30 or 31 games over the last two years. 1 Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
InjuredReserve Posted Wednesday at 12:30 PM Share Posted Wednesday at 12:30 PM 10 minutes ago, Ragnarok said: No, no he doesn't. Both players crush Mixon on yards per carry which is what matters most. Plus, you can't watch the games and say Mixon has been more effective than either of those guys. And all three guys have played 30 or 31 games over the last two years. Fellas fellas.....Jaylen Warren outperforms them all with his unmatched evasiveness. Skeletor will be back with more disturbing facts. Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
EaglesPeteC Posted Wednesday at 01:20 PM Share Posted Wednesday at 01:20 PM 4 hours ago, vikes635 said: Mixon out performs "Quality Starters" Pacheco and Swift without injuries happening to any of them! 1 Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
EaglesPeteC Posted Wednesday at 01:23 PM Share Posted Wednesday at 01:23 PM INT New Orleans Franchise Cornerstone: Javon Hargrave, Jeffrey Simmons Quality Starter: Arik Armstead Incomplete Evaluation: Byron Murphy II, Brandon Dorlus Total Points: 19pts A three way tie in points at the top, I give the #1 spot to NO for having 2 cornerstones and the better 3rd DT. The fact that they have the best DT in the draft waiting in the wings is also impressive. Berlin Franchise Cornerstone- Derrick Brown, Quinnen Williams+ Competitive Starter: Da’Von Hamilton Quality Depth: Mazi Smith, Saki Ika Replacement Level: Kurt Hinish Total Points: 19pts As a duo, Williams and Brown I think are better than Hargrave and Simmons, but I like NO’s 3rd DT and potential behind them better. Akureyri Franchise Cornerstone: Dexter Lawerence+ Quality Starter: DJ Reader+, Grady Jarrett Competitive Starter: Khalen Saunders Incomplete Evaluation: Michael Hall, Leonard Taylor Total Points: 19pts A very impressive top 3 and a nice player at the 3rd spot put Akureyri in the mix with the best in the league. CWM Franchise Cornerstone: Christian Wilkins, Chris Jones+ Incomplete Evaluation: Cameron Young Replacement Level: Perrion Winfrey Total Points: 15pts This might be the best starting duo in the league but there is nothing of note behind them, keeping CWM a bit behind the top group. Lancaster Franchise Cornerstone: Kenny Clark, Justin Madubuike Quality Depth: Zaach Pickens Incomplete Evaluation: Ade Adebawore Replacement Level: TJ Slayton, Ottio Ogbonnia, Eyioma Uwazurike Total Points: 15pts Lancaster is in the same boat as CWM with a great duo but very little depth behind them. Anchorage Franchise Cornerstone: Vita Vea Quality Starter: Ed Oliver Competitive Starter: Jordan Davis, Dante Stills Replacement Level- Bobby Brown III Total Points: 15pts Oliver is finally starting to live up to his draft potential and Vea is a excellent foundational piece. Jordan Davis has been a bit disappointing to start his career. If he takes a leap, this group could be closer to the top group. Raleigh Quality Starter; Jalen Carter, Alim McNeill, Kobie Turner Competitive Starter: BJ Hill Incomplete Evaluation: Moro Ojomo Total Points: 14pts Raleigh sports a trio of exciting young DT’s which in a few years could put them on the top of this list, but for now keeps them in the middle of the pack. Ivory Coast Quality Starter: DaRon Payne+, Christian Barmore+ Competitive Starter: Davonte Wyatt Incomplete Evaluation: Keondre Coburn, Jaquelin Roy Total Points: 12pts Payne and Barmore are fringe cornerstones and Wyatt is starting to develop into a really quality player as well to make for a very formidable crew. Svalbard Quality Starter: Cameron Heyward, Zach Allen Competitive Starter: Keanu Benton, Milton Williams Total Points: 12pts A really nice four man rotation but no elite players now that Heyward is hanging on to the end of his career. Cancun Franchise Cornerstone: Jonathan Allen Competitive Starter: Travis Jones Quality Depth: Justin Jones Incomplete Evaluation: Maason Smith, Zach Carter Total Points: 10pts Travis Jones is developing into a nice running mate for Allen, but some more depth is probably needed for this group. Hungary Quality Starter: David Onyemata Competitive Starter:, Calijah Kancey, Jaaran Reed Quality Depth: Javon Kinlaw Incomplete Evaluation: Justin Eboigbe Total Points: 10pts Kancey showed some flashes year one and Onyemata is a nice player but this overall group lacks the top end talent needed to complete with the groups in the top 10. Greenland Franchise Cornerstone: DeForest Buckner Competitive Starter: Gervon Dexter Incomplete Evaluation: Bryan Bresee, Ruke Ohohorhoro Replacement Level: Phadarian Mathis, Matthew Butler Total Points: 9pts Buckner is doing most of the heavy lifting in the group. Greenland needs to add more depth behind him or have those young players step up. Cuba Quality Starter: Zach Seiler Competitive Starter: Maliek Collins, DJ Jones Quality Depth: Karl Brooks Incomplete Evaluation: Dewayne Carter, McKinnley Jackson Total Points: 9pts Cuba has a nice little compliment of decent players but this isn’t really a group to fear. Las Vegas Quality Starter: Leonard Williams Quality Depth: Larry Ogunjobi Incomplete Evaluation: Braden Fiske, Jer’Zhan Newton Total Points: 5pts Vegas invested in this group in the draft, so they’ll need those players to be significant contributors as rookies to out perform this ranking. Quebec Quality Starter: Osi Odighizuwa Quality Depth: A’Shawn Robinson Replacement Level: Neil Ferrell, Jordan Riley Total Points: 5pts Quebec should target adding to this group in the tank because they seem pretty thin. Rome Competitive Starter; Shelby Harris Quality Depth: Andrew Billings, Logan Hall Incomplete Evaluation: Kris Jenkins, T’Vondre Sweat Total Points: 4pts Rome, like Vegas, invested in this group in the draft, so they’ll need those players to produce or have some decent Tank investments to get out of the basement. Up Next: LB and S (going to get two in between today and tomorrow to finish up Friday) 6 Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
SirA1 Posted Wednesday at 05:01 PM Share Posted Wednesday at 05:01 PM 3 hours ago, EaglesPeteC said: INT Svalbard Quality Starter: Cameron Heyward, Zach Allen Competitive Starter: Keanu Benton, Milton Williams Total Points: 12pts A really nice four man rotation but no elite players now that Heyward is hanging on to the end of his career. Um I have five INTs thank you. JFM hasn't been an Edge in like 3-4 years. Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Blue Posted Wednesday at 05:08 PM Share Posted Wednesday at 05:08 PM (edited) Absolutely shocking Frogs didn’t come away with Christian Wilkins or Javon Hargrave in FA with such a glaring need at DT and more cap space than God. Edited Wednesday at 05:08 PM by Blue Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
EaglesPeteC Posted Wednesday at 05:14 PM Share Posted Wednesday at 05:14 PM 14 minutes ago, SirA1 said: Um I have five INTs thank you. JFM hasn't been an Edge in like 3-4 years. That's a good catch. He was listed as a EDGE but I knew you weren't using him at EDGE and then I forgot to add him to your DT list. I'd rate him a competitive starter giving you 2 more points and hopping you over IC for #8 1 Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
EaglesPeteC Posted Wednesday at 05:19 PM Share Posted Wednesday at 05:19 PM LB Greenland Franchise Cornerstone: Roquan Smith+ Quality Starter: TJ Edwards Competitive Starter: Devin Lloyd+, Jack Campbell+ Incomplete Evaluation: Drew Sanders Total Points: 18pts The best group by far in BDL. An elite cornerstone and 3 very good players behind him New Orleans Quality Starter: Matt Milano+, CJ Mosley+ Competitive Starter: Josey Jewell Quality Depth: Anthony Walker Jr Incomplete Evaluation: Demarvion Overshown, Daiyan Henley, Trevin Wallace, Marist Liufau Total Points: 13pts New Orleans reaching into their pockets for Milano and Mosley gives them a strong duo with a couple nice couple pieces behind them. Hungary Franchise Cornerstone: Logan Wilson Competitive Starter: Shaq Thompson, Ivan Pace, Nathan Landman Total Points: 13pts A cornerstone with 3 nice depth pieces behind them puts Hungary in the 3rd spot. Lancaster Franchise Cornerstone: Fred Warner+ Competitive Starter: Willie Gay Jr Quality Depth: Malcolm Rodriquez Incomplete Evaluation: Junior Colston Replacement Level: Mark Robinson, Channing Tindall Total Points: 11pts Lancaster is lead by the league’s best LB and enough startable players to compliment him. Cuba Quality Starter: Bobby Okereke Competitive Starter: Jahlani Tavai, Andrew Van Ginkel+ Quality Depth: Dorian Williams, Henry To’oto’o Incomplete Evaluation: Jeremiah Trottier Jr Total Points: 11pts Nice depth all around but no elite players puts Cuba on the fringe of the top 5. Anchorage Quality Starter: Jeremiah Owusa Koramoah Competitive Starter: Devin White, David Long Quality Depth: Micah McFadden, Owen Pappoe Total Points: 10pts Another group with a really healthy floor but lacking elite talent. Raleigh Quality Starter: Quincy Williams+ Competitive Starter: Quay Walker Quality Depth: Tyrel Dodson, Jack Sanborn Replacement Level: Christian Elliss Total Points: 9pts Quincy Williams headlines this group that could use one more piece to really be competitive with the top teams. Svalbard Quality Starter: Kaden Elliss Competitive Starter: Blake Cashman Quality Depth: Zach Baun, Isaiah Simmons, Mack Wilson Total Points: 9pts A nice group that will be complimentary piece to a defense, but no real impact players here. Akureyri Quality Starter: Patrick Queen Competitive Starter: Damone Clark, Azeez Al Shaair Incomplete Evaluation: Cedric Gray, Ty’Ron Hopper Total Points: 8pts Queen highlights this group and Clark and Al Shaair complete a nice starting trio. Some experience depth would be nice. Berlin Competitive Starter: Jordyn Brooks+, Kyzir White, Terrell Bernard Quality Depth: Chad Muma Incomplete Evaluation: Tyrice Knight Total Points: 8pts A formidable trio of competitive starters but nothing overly special about this group. Rome Quality Starter: Nick Bolton Competitive Starter: Eric Kendricks+ Incomplete Evaluation: Trenton Simpson Total Points: 7pts Bolton and Kendricks is a strong duo but no experienced depth behind them. Cancun Quality Starter: Ernest Jones Competitive Starter: Pete Werner Quality Depth: KJ Britt Incomplete Evaluation: Noah Sewell, Mohamoud Diabate Replacement Level: Isisah McDuffie, SirVocea Dennis, Brandon Smith Total Points: 7pts Jones and Werner are a perfectly cromulent duo. The other players are certainly……there. Quebec Quality Starter: Lavonte David Quality Depth: Nakobe Dean, Jack Gibbens, Divine Diablo Replacement Level: Troy Andersen Total Points: 7pts David is the grandpa in the room for the rest of the depth players. Quebec getting ahead of a few teams here and pure volume alone. Ivory Coast Quality Starter: Bobby Wagner, Jordan Hicks Quality Depth: Marpe Matu Incomplete Evaluation: Edgerrin Cooper Total Points: 5pts A couple former stud LB’s past their prime paired with a couple young players with much to prove. CWM Competitive Starter: Germaine Pratt, Christian Harris Quality Depth; Jamin Davis Replacement Level: Brian Asamoah Total Points: 5pts Pratt and Harris are good players that have had strong moments in the NFL but need a little more consistency. Davis has been a pretty big disappointment so far. Las Vegas Competitive Starter: Robert Spillane Quality Depth: Leo Chanel, Cody Barton Incomplete Evaluation: Peyton Wilson Total Points: 4pts This group needs to add some talent in the tank to avoid being the target of game plans all season. Next up: CB (with getting 2 in today. I'll do CB's tomorrow and then S with the overall D and team rankings Friday) 6 Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
InjuredReserve Posted Wednesday at 05:37 PM Share Posted Wednesday at 05:37 PM I think the confusion on my ranking may be that "Peyton Wilson" does not exist. "Payton Wilson" is a guaranteed Franchise Cornerstone and I assume my ranking will be updated shortly to reflect that. Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
bcb1213 Posted Wednesday at 08:14 PM Share Posted Wednesday at 08:14 PM Everyone knocking Pete for spelling warms my heart Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Blue Posted Wednesday at 11:12 PM Share Posted Wednesday at 11:12 PM Impressive that SirVocea Dennis has climbed up to Replacement level based on 100 rookie year snaps behind Quality Starters Lavonte David and Devin White. Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
EaglesPeteC Posted Thursday at 01:30 PM Share Posted Thursday at 01:30 PM CB Anchorage Franchise Cornerstone: Sauce Gardner+, Patrick Surtain II+ Quality Starter: Derek Stingley Jr Competitive Starter: Paulson Adebo Incomplete Evaluation: Christian Gonzalez Total Points: 21pts Shut up Scoundrel Rome Franchise Cornerstone: Marlon Humphrey Quality Starter: DJ Reed, DaRon Bland+ Competitive Starter: Jamel Dean, Ja’Quan McMillian Incomplete Evaluation: Max Melton Replacement Level: Jayln Armour-Davis Total Points: 20pts A very deep and diverse group that should help Rome control some of the best WR corps in the league. Akureyri Franchise Cornerstone: Jaire Alexander, Trent McDuffie Competitive Starter: Kyler Gordon Quality Depth; Nate Hobbs, Clark Phillips, Jaylon Jones, Garrett Williams Incomplete Evaluation: Dax Hill Total Points: 20pts Akureyri made the big move to acquire Jaire to go along with Trent McDuffie. They also have lots of nice young depth with upward mobility. Svalbard Franchise Cornerstone: Jaylon Johnson Quality Starter: Charvarius Ward+, Brian Branch Quality Depth: Isaiah Oliver Incomplete Evaluation: Ennis Rakestraw, Khris Abrams Draine, Nemamiah Pritchett Replacement Level: Shaun Wade Total Points: 17pts Svalbard traded for Jaylon Johnson at the deadline last year to give this team a really strong starting 3. They are relying on a lot of youth after that, so they should really hope for health. Ivory Coast Franchise Cornerstone: Trevon Diggs Quality Starter: AJ Terrell+, Greg Newsome Incomplete Evaluation: Kamari Lassiter Replacement Level: Sam Womack Total Points: 16pts IC has a very similar story as Svalbard with Diggs returning from injury. A very strong top 3 with depth questions after that. Cuba Franchise Cornerstone: Denzel Ward Quality Starter: Martin Emerson Competitive Starter: Alontae Taylor Quality Depth: Kader Kohu, Joshua Williams, Levi Wallace Incomplete Evaluation: Keele Ringo, Renardo Green, Jarrian Jones Total Points: 16pts Ward leads a pretty deep group, but I am a bigger fan of IC’s top end talent which keeps Cuba behind them. Ringo is a nice wild card to this group to make it even potentially better. Raleigh Quality Starter: Kendall Fuller, Taron Johnson Competitive Starter: Sean Murphy Bunting, Marcus Jones Quality Depth: Isaiah Rodgers, Bryce Hall, Rock Ya Sin Incomplete Evaluation: Darius Rush, Juju Brents, Nate Wiggins, Andu Phillips Total Points: 15pts Raleigh’s ranking is a product of throwing a lot of darts at this position and having a lot of startable bodies. If I am being honest, I’d probably take a few of the crews behind mine over this, but I think I’ve done enough to turn by biggest weakness on defense into a solid group for BDL. Quebec Franchise Cornerstone: L’Jarius Sneed Quality Starter: Asante Samuel Jr Quality Depth: Benjamin St. Juste, Mekhi Blackmon, Dee Alford Incomplete Evaluation: Elijah Jones, Decamarion Richardson, Kamal Hadden Total Points: 14pts Quebec with a strong top 2 but questions after that. They could probably use the tank to fill out the room a bit more. Hungary Quality Starter: Carlton Davis Competitive Starter: Emmanuel Mosley, Roger McCreary Quality Depth: Jeff Okudah, Kei’Trell Clark, Chamarri Conner, Terrel Smith, Tre Brown Incomplete Evaluation: Riley Moss, Cooper DeJean, Quinyon Mitchell Replacement Level: Marcus Peters Total Points: 13pts Davis seemed to take a step back last season but McCreary took a step up. Mosley’s season was lost to injury last year, so it’ll be interesting to see how he bounces back. Greenland Quality Starter; Marshon Lattimore+, Tariq Woolen Competitive Starter: Joey Porter Jr+ Quality Depth: Emmanuel Forbes Total Points: 13pts Greenland has a strong top 3, so a few quality additions in the tank would probably have this group shoot up the list. Lancaster Franchise Cornerstone: Jalen Ramsey Competitive Starter; Brandon Stephens, Tyrique Stevenson Quality Depth: Akayleb Evans, Coby Bryant Incomplete Evaluation: Kool Aid McKinstry, Kyu Blu Kelly, Corey Trice Jr Total Points: 13pts Ramsey is still clutching on to cornerstone status but will that continue this year? Stevenson had great ball production as a rookie and Stephens is an underrated player. I have some questions about their depth beyond that, but I’d be excited to see what Kool-Aid adds to this room. New Orleans Competitive Starter: Rasul Douglas, Decommadore Lenoir, Cam Taylor Britt Quality Depth: Kristian Fulton, Eric Stokes, Decobie Durant, Derion Kendrick, Jakorian Bennett Replacement Level: Adoree Jackson, Stephon Gilmore Total Points: 11pts New Orleans has a lot of bodies here but nothing that would strike fear in me as an opponent. If Jackson and Gilmore sign, they’ll have an even deeper group that should be more than sufficient for the season Las Vegas Competitive Starter: Chidobe Awuzie, Michael Carter II+, Dane Jackson, Jaycee Horn Quality Depth; Michael Jackson Incomplete Evaluation: TJ Tampa Replacement Level: Noah Igbinoghene Total Points: 10pts Vegas has 4 nice players at the top of this group, but nothing that I’d be overly excited about maybe outside of Horn, who has not been healthy enough to be more than a projection. Berlin Quality Starter: Devon Witherspoon Competitive Starter: Deonte Banks, DJ Turner Quality Depth: Christian Benford Incomplete Evaluation: Terrion Arnold Total Points: 9pts Dibs on Rags being the one that complains the most about his ranking! Witherspoon looks like he is on his way to cornerstone status, but it's fair to hold him in Quality Starter for now. Banks and Turner both showed real potential in year 1, so I could see them jumping a tier as well. Arnold as a rookie also gives a ton to be excited about. This group could easily make this ranking look silly by midseason. CWM Quality Starter: Darius Slay, Tyson Campbell Incomplete Evaluation: Tre Tomlinson, Cam Smith, Mike Sainristil Total Points: 8pts A pretty strong top 2, but they need some tank additions to really be formidable this season. Cancun Quality Starter: Darious Williams Quality Depth: Jack Jones, Jaylen Watson, Eli Ricks, Carrington Valentine Incomplete Evaluation: Cam Hart, Khyree Jackson Replacement Level: Zyon McCollum Total Points: 8pts They certainly have players here. 6 Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Recommended Posts
Join the conversation
You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.