Who would go 1.1 in a 2014 redraft?

[Forge]

I'm just going to give Nola some love at this point - he has turned into a top 20 pitcher in this league already. I'm probably not taking him over Turner and Conforto, but I'd slot him in at number #3. 

[Eagles27]

I'd go Turner or Nola at the moment. 

If Conforto does this again next year, I'd probably lean in his direction.

[ramssuperbowl99]

10 hours ago, redsoxsuck05 said:

I'm too lazy to see where this stands among other drafts, but a lot of these guys are still promising prospects.  Also Trea Turner is ridiculously good

@bkobow05, @devils1854 and I listed out 3 other drafts that are worlds better.

[Lions017]

Turner then Nola. I think that Nola is going to be a legit ace over the next few years. He's already almost there. 

[NewAge]

Ok who here writes for BA?

 

 

 

 

[steelcurtain29]

What argument is there that could convince anyone that Turner isn't the consensus #1 pick? 

[NewAge]

5 minutes ago, steelcurtain29 said:

What argument is there that could convince anyone that Turner isn't the consensus #1 pick? 

Michael Conforto's 149 wRC+? 

[steelcurtain29]

7 hours ago, NewAge said:

Michael Conforto's 149 wRC+? 

Turner did have a 140+ wRC+ last year, although his overall sample size is smaller. Turner also has a better career average. Conforto has serious power, where Turner lacks. Otherwise, Turner is better defensively, much more versatile and a severe threat on the bases. 

 

Outside of RAW power, Turner is the better player.

[NewAge]

1 hour ago, steelcurtain29 said:

Turner did have a 140+ wRC+ last year, although his overall sample size is smaller. Turner also has a better career average. Conforto has serious power, where Turner lacks. Otherwise, Turner is better defensively, much more versatile and a severe threat on the bases. 

 

Outside of RAW power, Turner is the better player.

Conforto also walks like 150% more than Turner does. As it stands now, Conforto is a 6 hit, 6 eye, 6 run, 6-7 power CF. 

Turner's big year last year was inflated a bit by a .388 BABIP. I think he can maintain a high BABIP but not that high. His exit velocity is also down a bit this year.