Black Sails Mafia (S1): Day 5

[MWil23]

5 minutes ago, Daniel said:

Two non town on that lynch vote.

So two of Matts, MWil, Naz, Josh, KSJ, bcb, Blue, and Forge are non-town.

Matts and Blue are claimed masons, Forge is the doctor, MWil is Flint.  So by process of elimination, two of the others are scum, if no one is lying.  50/50 shot there.

So, let's assume you're telling the truth, that leaves:

1. KSJ

2. BCB

3. Naz

4. Josh

...as 2 of the Non Town.

Given that you were pardoned, I'm prone to think that it's LIKELY that whoever pardoned you did NOT vote for you last night, and would LIKELY be either Town or the lone INDY (likely friendly). Do we happen to know who that list was?

[TOUCAN]

1 minute ago, MWil23 said:

So, let's assume you're telling the truth, that leaves:

1. KSJ

2. BCB

3. Naz

4. Josh

...as 2 of the Non Town.

Given that you were pardoned, I'm prone to think that it's LIKELY that whoever pardoned you did NOT vote for you last night, and would LIKELY be either Town or the lone INDY (likely friendly). Do we happen to know who that list was?

You’re aware I voted for bcb, right?

[MWil23]

@Blue @Matts4313 convince me that killing Daniel wouldn't give us the most information today, short of someone else coming forward.

@kingseanjohn @bcb1213 @Forge @JoshstraDaymus @Nazgul anything you guys can give us for last night?

Matt/someone familiar with the storyline, when does Daniel's character become bad and try to lead a mutiny? Season 1?

[Nazgul]

1 minute ago, MWil23 said:

So, let's assume you're telling the truth, that leaves:

1. KSJ

2. BCB

3. Naz

4. Josh

...as 2 of the Non Town.

Given that you were pardoned, I'm prone to think that it's LIKELY that whoever pardoned you did NOT vote for you last night, and would LIKELY be either Town or the lone INDY (likely friendly). Do we happen to know who that list was?

Damn, two of KSJ, BCB & Josh are scum. Crazy.

[Daniel]

2 minutes ago, MWil23 said:

So, let's assume you're telling the truth, that leaves:

1. KSJ

2. BCB

3. Naz

4. Josh

...as 2 of the Non Town.

Given that you were pardoned, I'm prone to think that it's LIKELY that whoever pardoned you did NOT vote for you last night, and would LIKELY be either Town or the lone INDY (likely friendly). Do we happen to know who that list was?

OK, to fix my non-accurate list: MWil, KSJ, bcb, Blue, and Forge voted for me.  Two are non town.

Makes it pretty easy for me, and since I was already suspicious of him yesterday bcb.

[Nazgul]

Just now, MWil23 said:

@Blue @Matts4313 convince me that killing Daniel wouldn't give us the most information today, short of someone else coming forward.

@kingseanjohn @bcb1213 @Forge @JoshstraDaymus @Nazgul anything you guys can give us for last night?

Matt/someone familiar with the storyline, when does Daniel's character become bad and try to lead a mutiny? Season 1?

Josh appears harmless and is dim. I don't know what that means, but it's what I have.
So if we go by the line it's KSJ and BCB probably.

[TOUCAN]

Are we having fun yet?

[Daniel]

Matts too.  Sorry.

[Nazgul]

Get your **** together, Daniel.

[Daniel]

Not getting a VC for the writeup made this difficult.

But we have a claim from literally everyone other than bcb and KSJ.  So either they're both scum, or one of the claims is non-town.

[MWil23]

3 minutes ago, JoshstraDaymus said:

You’re aware I voted for bcb, right?

Between this and missing Matts, especially in light of your impossible to prove claim, I'm having a hard time believing you @Daniel

[Nazgul]

1 minute ago, Daniel said:

But we have a claim from literally everyone other than bcb and KSJ.  So either they're both scum, or one of the claims is non-town.

I haven't claimed. 

[SwAg]

I agree.  Some of you need to step up and provide a vote count, because right now, Rick is going to be MVP for providing vote counts.

[MWil23]

I'm about to kill Daniel right this second based upon his impossible to prove claim, the fact that his death gives us the most information as now (if he's telling the truth) he's useless from an ability standpoint and that we can now proceed to play accordingly, he's messed up his own claim three times, and his character is a bad guy in the show. If he flips Town, we now have 3-4 names to pursue, 2 of whom are scum, giving us great odds down the stretch in endgame. If he's scum, that's a major win.

@Blue @Forge @Matts4313 talk me out of this. You have two hours.

[MWil23]

4 minutes ago, Daniel said:

But we have a claim from literally everyone other than bcb and KSJ.  So either they're both scum, or one of the claims is non-town.

NAZ has not claimed...