Yellowstone Mafia - Town wins!

[ET80]

2 minutes ago, TL-TwoWinsAway said:

I think, based on the last few pages, we need to just make a move happen and resume. None of this stuff is going to lead anywhere positive.

I'm game. Orca or Scoundrel?

[TheKillerNacho]

6 minutes ago, ET80 said:

Humor me nonetheless.

1. he's been defensive the whole game

2. he's been defensive the whole game despite his ultimate claim being gov who can apparently overturn lynches multiple times

3. he's been playing off of tl2's tuneling of me all game

4. he was so shook by nearly being lynched that he claimed, despite being able to save himself

5. he wasa ble to prevent his own death in a way that seems to suggest he's either godfather or 1-shot deathrpoof

6. he's claimed ive been lying no less than 4 times despite the fact ive not lied once

7. his character claim seems to be pretty minor in that it could be easily a cover role

[Scoundrel]

1 minute ago, ET80 said:

I'm game. Orca or Scoundrel?

[TL-TwoWinsAway]

1 minute ago, Scoundrel said:

Yeah I really am starting to think ET is not scum

unvote  

It's not even about the game anymore. We've now discussed opinions on COVID, and we're discussing the way such games should be played, etc. To avoid this falling apart and wasting bcb's time and energy, we should probably just make the vote and move on.

swoosh wanted ET targeted anyway. If you're town, it seems like a pretty straightforward decision.

[TheKillerNacho]

7 minutes ago, The Orca said:

So here is my issue and let me know what you think. If mafia is losing someone D1 and ET was with them and hadn't opened his PM wouldn't it have been almost assure he would be pushed by mafia for the "look" like town lynch

So thee 2 likley scenarios imo are ET is not aligned with Josh or ET is aligned and did open his PM. Was he one of the ones who lynched Josh, if so I think it makes aligned with Josh less likley 

if et80 and josh were both scum together why in the world would they risk losing et80 in addition to josh? this makes no sense.

[Scoundrel]

3 minutes ago, TL-TwoWinsAway said:

It's not even about the game anymore. We've now discussed opinions on COVID, and we're discussing the way such games should be played, etc. To avoid this falling apart and wasting bcb's time and energy, we should probably just make the vote and move on.

swoosh wanted ET targeted anyway. If you're town, it seems like a pretty straightforward decision.

Yeah this just seems like scum finding a reason to get rid of town

[The Orca]

7 hours ago, bcb1213 said:

Day 3

Alright, lets vote Pickle

no et

no nacho

you're dumb

heres some random reasoning

let's go with that

but what about this

let me tell you about my workout routine

wha

back to arguing

Eventually the group decided in a close decision that Pickle is the one who needed to go.  They surrounded Rick but then he simply stood up and said

"I will not allow for this to happen"

Rick's  security detail whisked him out of the room before anything else could occur

PICKLE RICK IS STILL ALIVE

 

It is now night three.  Night will end at 440

Pickle says I WILL NOT LET THIS HAPPEN

46 minutes ago, The Orca said:

So if we assume 12-4 Ratio

And people are telling the truth

We have 4 Ranch Hands

And then 6 main town characters

That leaves only 2 non ranch hands 

Who else has flipped town, Matts was Jake a Wrangler 

Now we are down to 1 non main character/Ranch hand role left 

This doesnt seem likley

 

We look closely at Pickles lynch and we see Pickle is the one who stopped it in the writeup, which is consistent with a pardon. I would assume if its a godfather or deathproof he would be beat to death or something and not be killed or written more clearly that he can't be killed yet (obviously varies host to host)

So pickle would be the last off main guy

So everyone else is scum...possible

Again does not seem likley. Most likley is a Ranch hand is a cover role...find the imposter imo

 

On 8/4/2021 at 2:50 PM, bcb1213 said:

 

Welcome to the Dutton Ranch, there are some no gooders around.  Get ready to defend the land!

 

Sign ups

1. Scoundrel 

2. Nacho 

3. Orca 

4. Pickle 

5. TL 

6. Swoosh   John Dutton-The Patriarch- Yellowstone Aligned

7. Tk3  

8 Josh   Dan Jenkins - California Cronie - Takeover Aligned 

9. Dome 

10. Matts   Jake  Wrangler  Yellowstone Aligned

11. Bucsfan  Jimmy - Ranch Hand - Yellowstone aligned 

12 hokiehigh 

13 Raves 

14. Et 

15. Jason   Beth Dutton- Pain the *** sister-  Yellowstone Aligned

16. Squire 

Day zero - let the fun begin

Day one The ranch has a good day 

Night one - Bucs get taken out

Day two-  Matts gets wrangled out of the game

Night two-  Jason gets black out dr...errr dead

Day three-  Pardon me?  Pickle is still alive!

Night 3-  Swoosh faces father time

Rules Read These

 

You may character claim at any time. However you may not role claim until day 3. Exceptions shall be made starting day two. If you are to receive an exception you will be notified prior to day 2 beginning. This is a new rule so I will allow possible slip ups. Flagrant breaking of this rule will result in a modkill

--Unless it says otherwise in your Role PM, you may NOT talk about the game outside of the Game Thread.

--Voting during the Day Phase will end once we get to a majority decision or the time limit is reached. Day one is 48 hours.  All other days is 24 

--In order to vote for someone to get eliminated during the day, you must bold their name. You can lock a vote if you want but you can also move them.  I don't do locked votes as mod 

--The night phase will last exactly 8 hours unless BCB receives every PM. That means if you have a Night Ability, you have 8 hours to send in your PMs unless otherwise noted. Should you not want to use your night ability, send a pm saying so.. Bcb is a terrible mod so he will not disrupt his sleeping to do a writeup at 3 AM. Deal with it. 

--If you miss a night PM, and are the last person to send in a pm the following night, you will lose your power for that night phase as we will end the phase there!

--No editing or deleting your posts with votes in it in the game thread. Double, triple, quadruple, quintuple, etc. posting is fine. 

--I reserve the right to mod kill and forcefully end a lynch. 

--NO DEAD POSTING! Once you're dead, you're out of the Game Thread. Simple. You will be allowed one good game, **** you guys, etc post. I also don’t mind idle chat during night phases or a joke post. However must you post when you're dead please keep it non game related 

--NO POSTING SCREENSHOTS.  You can copy paste anything you like from your PM. Note this may have perilous consequences, just not from me. 

--Do not post information regarding your PM from the Night prior to the Write-up being posted 

--If your PM says not to say something, don’t. There will be no second chances and you will be modkilled. 

---If there is conflicting ability uses on one another. The first pm's ability will win out, dont like it, send in your pm's faster

--Most importantly…HAVE FUN!

 

Day 3 says Pardon me?

I've also posted about it earlier as well a few times. Based on everything Pickle is most likley a pardon...might or might not be town. Could be an indy. Id wager town at the moment depending on other claims/flips

But thanks for playing "things @TheKillerNacho said I have done or not done just to be wrong game on what he says"

[squire12]

4 minutes ago, TheKillerNacho said:

if et80 and josh were both scum together why in the world would they risk losing et80 in addition to josh? this makes no sense.

Go check the end of n1and see who was around that could have tried to save Josh. It is a list worth considering

[The Orca]

5 minutes ago, TheKillerNacho said:

if et80 and josh were both scum together why in the world would they risk losing et80 in addition to josh? this makes no sense.

[Scoundrel]

Just now, squire12 said:

Go check the end of n1and see who was around that could have tried to save Josh. It is a list worth considering

#teamsavejosh

[TL-TwoWinsAway]

3 minutes ago, Scoundrel said:

Yeah this just seems like scum finding a reason to get rid of town

What's your reasoning if I'm actually town?

[TheKillerNacho]

Just now, The Orca said:

Pickle says I WILL NOT LET THIS HAPPEN

 

Day 3 says Pardon me?

I've also posted about it earlier as well a few times. Based on everything Pickle is most likley a pardon...might or might not be town. Could be an indy. Id wager town at the moment depending on other claims/flips

But thanks for playing "things @TheKillerNacho said I have done or not done just to be wrong game on what he says"

you assume wrong.

most of the time the host tries to make it as vague as possible, but there are things that would make me doubt it is a pardon. A security detail for instance is not something consistent with a pardon - seems personal.

[squire12]

2 minutes ago, Scoundrel said:

Yeah this just seems like scum finding a reason to get rid of town

Or it is town trying to find a way to eliminate a player that not helping to a full potential.  Why keep the deadweight around?  You know scum wouldn't hit him if he is town.  It's why voting inactives d1 is the smart play for town.  Always will be.

[Dome]

49 minutes ago, The Orca said:

Disagree, you can't have a Dutton or Rip be a cover role. Too easy for mafia to win. And no way do they have a Godfather/deathproof plus that 

Its like in a game where you have a couple crewmen that are vanilla and you tell Mafia thats their cover role, but here you also get a specific name not generic so its tougher to decide in that scenario 

So ur saying I’m clear 

[TheKillerNacho]

2 minutes ago, squire12 said:

Go check the end of n1and see who was around that could have tried to save Josh. It is a list worth considering

just tell me i have no desire to go back to reread rn