Prequel to World War III Mafia: Night 5 (Send Yerr PMs!)

[Hockey5djh]

16 minutes ago, Pickle Rick said:

Once that you cam out with it after orca, can you explain how you got the info? 

All of this makes me think hockey is fbi

You're correct, unfortunately Orca posted it first even though the question was directed at me. I guess I have to rely on faith when I tell you I knew the info prior to Orca posting the actual role and I would hope my posting about it leading up to that point would indicate that I'm not lying.

[Pickle Rick]

1 minute ago, Hockey5djh said:

You're correct, unfortunately Orca posted it first even though the question was directed at me. I guess I have to rely on faith when I tell you I knew the info prior to Orca posting the actual role and I would hope my posting about it leading up to that point would indicate that I'm not lying.

kind of, but you and @The Orca are completely wrong in your thought processes.

orca is gung ho that ted is scum bc of his role.

you have the same info apparently and are gung ho that ted is town.

you both should be in the middle, he can just as easily be town as he can be scum based on his role

[Hockey5djh]

15 minutes ago, Pickle Rick said:

🤔🤔

If the person knows then it would have to be squire or et (maybe dome). 

Above

I do, partly bc it may help zero in on who to lynch. 

Squire, et, forge, gopher is what we need to narrow down.

I've already made my thoughts clear on the first 3. 

Gopher is in the middle for me right now. 

I don't think that info has any bearing on the lynch either way.

[Hockey5djh]

4 minutes ago, Pickle Rick said:

kind of, but you and @The Orca are completely wrong in your thought processes.

orca is gung ho that ted is scum bc of his role.

you have the same info apparently and are gung ho that ted is town.

you both should be in the middle, he can just as easily be town as he can be scum based on his role

What can I say, your brother is dumb.

[Pickle Rick]

1 minute ago, Hockey5djh said:

I don't think that info has any bearing on the lynch either way.

it does, bc as i said he only could have enhanced 3 people (dome, et, or squire), unless i have missed something.  if he is town i want to know which one bc 2 of those should be highly considered for the lynch 

Just now, Hockey5djh said:

What can I say, your brother is dumb.

you are just as dumb for thinking his role automatically clears him, bc it does not.  unless you have more that makes things clearer 

[Hockey5djh]

Ted's role is Bastard Role Enhancer. Orca was adamant that he was mafia because of the term bastard. That said "Bastard" is a role modifier that basically says your power won't work like you think it will and has nothing to do with alignment. The reason why I don't think ted is mafia is because of the role itself. 1) A role enhancer in the mafia is severely unlikely based on the power of the role itself and 2) the fact that the role was bastardized was meant to add some element of confusion to the power, it doesn't seem likely that they would give the mafia the ability to "power up a role" and then on top of that "bastardize" that unlikely power up.

[Hockey5djh]

Just now, Pickle Rick said:

you are just as dumb for thinking his role automatically clears him, bc it does not.  unless you have more that makes things clearer 

I didn't clear him but I did discourage his lynch.

[Hockey5djh]

1 minute ago, Pickle Rick said:

it does, bc as i said he only could have enhanced 3 people (dome, et, or squire), unless i have missed something.  if he is town i want to know which one bc 2 of those should be highly considered for the lynch 

I don't follow this logic. If someone who has a town role and doesn't know who anyone is uses an enhancement power on someone else, why would this enhancement have any bearing on if they were mafia or not. Unless you're suggesting that we should lynch that person to eliminate the "threat" of the bastard modifier, which would be a little paranoid.

[Forge]

2 hours ago, Hockey5djh said:

Sorry...

Unofficial VC

 

Ted - 3 – Touch, Orca, ET,

 

Counselor - 3 - squire, gopher, Rack

 

Orca 2 -  , Hockey

 

ET -  Pickle

 

Hockey -  1 -  Counselor

 

 

2 hours ago, Hockey5djh said:

I'm moving my vote to Gopher pending his response

Votes on Counselor, Orca, and Ted are scum votes.

 

2 hours ago, theuntouchable said:

Unvote 

 

2 hours ago, Counselor said:

Gopher 

 

15 minutes ago, ET80 said:

Forge until something starts making sense.

Unofficial VC 

Ted - 1 –  Orca

Counselor - 3 - squire, gopher, Rack

ET -  Pickle

Gopher - Counselor, Hockey

Forge - ET

Needs to vote - Forge, Touch, Ted 

Cant vote - Dome

[Hockey5djh]

Just now, Hockey5djh said:

I don't follow this logic. If someone who has a town role and doesn't know who anyone is uses an enhancement power on someone else, why would this enhancement have any bearing on if they were mafia or not. Unless you're suggesting that we should lynch that person to eliminate the "threat" of the bastard modifier, which would be a little paranoid.

At the same time if you believe he is mafia then in theory you would lynch him than forge in that order, not the person he enhanced.

[Pickle Rick]

Player List:
1. @theuntouchable - no role (lmao)

4. @rackcs - vig

7.  @The Orca - some sort of role invest

8.  @Dome - pgo

9.  @TedLavie - bastard enhancer

10.  @Hockey5djh -

12.  @Pickle Rick - 

13.  @ET80 -

14.  @Forge - claimed end night early (mafia)

15.  @squire12 - 

16.  @gopherwrestler - claimed protect

18.  @Counselor - claimed protect

 

so this is where we are at

we have 2 town members killed last night by the players above, we have someone arresting dome

so who could have had those move....

touch - read town

hockey - I can buy that you are fbi and arrested dome (so you are scum)

pickle (nope but ill include myself bc I don't want to miss anything)

et - drump supporter (probably indy)

squire - mafia 

counselor/gopher - town unless one is lying 

forge (probably killed 1) mafia

 

 

[Hockey5djh]

@rackcs, @squire12, @gopherwrestler can you please move your vote from counselor. Nobody has counterclaimed his protector role and it would be highly inconvenient to lynch the protector with an investigator out in the open.

[Hockey5djh]

1 minute ago, Pickle Rick said:

16.  @gopherwrestler - claimed protect

Gopher didn't claim protect, he claimed that he knew of another protector.

I'm still waiting on clarification of what he knows.

[Pickle Rick]

1 minute ago, Hockey5djh said:

I don't follow this logic. If someone who has a town role and doesn't know who anyone is uses an enhancement power on someone else, why would this enhancement have any bearing on if they were mafia or not. Unless you're suggesting that we should lynch that person to eliminate the "threat" of the bastard modifier, which would be a little paranoid.

if I believe he is town than I want to know who he enhanced bc they better be town or @TedLavie screwed up

then we can lynch the other one if things fit

[Pickle Rick]

1 minute ago, Hockey5djh said:

@rackcs, @squire12, @gopherwrestler can you please move your vote from counselor. Nobody has counterclaimed his protector role and it would be highly inconvenient to lynch the protector with an investigator out in the open.

@gopherwrestler did, multiple times