Rank Each QB in their Respective Divisions

[WizeGuy]

Shoot!

[NudeTayne]

AFC North

1. Baker Mayfield

2. Joe Burrow

3a. Ben Roethlisberger

3b. Tyler Huntley

4. (5) Mason Rudolph

[ET80]

Hmmm...

1. Ryan Tannehill (never thought I'd say that...)

2. Trevor Lawrence (I mean... yeah? Probably?)

3. Carson Wentz (If he can stay healthy and into a groove with Reich's offense, he could be a steal).

4. Tyrod Taylor/Davis Mills (oof, good luck selling jerseys this season, Cal).

[August4th]

I'm going with tiers

AFC north

tier 1: Lamar

tier 2: Baker, Ben and Joe

AFC East

tier 1: Allen

tier 2: Tua, Cam

???: Wilson/Mac

AFC south(assuming Watson doesn't play)

Tier 1: Tanny

Tier 2: Wentz

Tier 3: Tyrod

???: TLaw

AFC West

Tier 1: Mahomes

Tier 2: Herbert

Tier 3: Carr

tier 4: Lock/Teddy

NFC North

Tier 1: Rodgers

tier 2: Cousins

Tier 3: Goff/Dalton

???: Fields

NFC East

Tier 1: Dak

Tier 2: Fitzpartick, Jones and Hurts

NFC South

Tier 1: Brady

Tier 2: Ryan

Tier 3: Winston

Tier 4: Darnold

NFC West

Tier 1: Wilson

Tier 2: Stafford

Tier 3: Murray

Tier 4: Jimmy G

???: Lance

 

[pwny]

Probably: 
1. Ryan Tannehill
2. Trevor Lawrence
3. Carson Wentz
4. Gardner Minshew
5. Tyrod Taylor
6. CJ Beathard
7. Jacob Eason
8. Logan Woodside
9. DeShone Kizer
10. Davis Mills

[scar988]

AFC East

1. Josh Allen

2. Cam Newton

3. Tu'a Tagavailoa

4. Jacoby Brissett

5. Max Jones

6. Mitch Trubisky

7. Zach Wilson

8. James Morgan

 

AFC North

1. Lamar Jackson

2. Ben Roethlisberger

3. Joe Burrow

4. Baker Mayfield

5. Case Keenum

6. Brandon Allen

7. Mason Rudolph

8. Trace McSorley

 

AFC West

1. Patrick Mahomes

2. Justin Herbert

3. Derek Carr

4. Marcus Mariota

5. Teddy Bridgewater

6. Drew Lock

7. Chad Henne

8. Chase Daniel

 

AFC South

1. DeShaun Watson

2. Trevor Lawrence

3. Ryan Tannehill

4. Carson Wentz

5. Tyrod Taylor

6. Gardner Minshew

7. Jacob Eason

8. Logan Woodside

 

NFC East

1. Dak Prescott

2. Jalen Hurts

3. Ryan Fitzpatrick

4. Daniel Jones

5. Mike Glennon

6. Joe Flacco

7. Taylor Heinecke

8. Cooper Rush

 

NFC North

1. Aaron Rodgers

2. Jared Goff

3. Kirk Cousins

4. Justin Fields

5. Andy Dalton

6. Jordan Love

7. Nick Foles

8. Kellen Mond

 

NFC West

1. Russell Wilson

2. Matt Stafford

3. Kyler Murray

4. Trey Lance

5. Jimmy Garoppolo

6. Geno Smith

7. Colt McCoy

8. John Wolford

 

NFC South

1. Tom Brady

2. Matt Ryan

3. Jameis Winston

4. A.J. McCarron

5. Sam Darnold

6. Blaine Gabbert

7. Kyle Trask

8. Taysom Hill

[BayRaider]

1. Patrick Mahomes

gap

2. Derek Carr

3. Justin Herbert

gap

4. Drew Lock

5. Teddy Bridgewater

6. Marcus Mariota

gap

7. Chase Daniel

8. Nate Peterman

I don’t think Peterman is Bills Peterman anymore, plus I think Henne is straight garbage. Chiefs need to keep Mahomes healthy. Then again, Reid does have a tendency to make a broom look like a competent QB. 

Edited May 25, 2021 by BayRaider

[Turnobili]

Peterman

Mahomes

Carr
Herbert

Bridgewater
Mariota

Lock

Edited May 25, 2021 by Turnobili

[Turnobili]

 

[Ray Reed]

Lamar
Baker
Roethlisberger
Burrow

[MWil23]

25 minutes ago, Ray Reed said:

Lamar
Baker
Roethlisberger
Burrow

I'd personally flip Ben and Burrow, but I could absolutely see the argument for Ben over him for now. TBH, I wouldn't be surprised to see Burrow take a step back this year coming off of that injury.

[Ray Reed]

1 minute ago, MWil23 said:

I'd personally flip Ben and Burrow, but I could absolutely see the argument for Ben over him for now. TBH, I wouldn't be surprised to see Burrow take a step back this year coming off of that injury.

Yeah I went back and forth on that one tbh

I've just seen the fat man pull too many rabbits out of hats the last 15 years to put him last on this. Wouldn't surprise me if he has a bunch of crazy "one final ride" plays/moments in him this year.

[MWil23]

1 minute ago, Ray Reed said:

Yeah I went back and forth on that one tbh

I've just seen the fat man pull too many rabbits out of hats the last 15 years to put him last on this. Wouldn't surprise me if he has a bunch of crazy "one final ride" plays/moments in him this year.

Even though Ben's arm is largely gone, I still think A LOT of their issues last year were scheme. They had zero running game, mostly because of their awful OL, and as a result, they had 0 in the play-action department or RPO game. If they're even able to solve this issue, and that defense is back healthy, the AFC North may very well absolutely cannibalize each other, and Ben could have some sort of resurgence this year.

Obviously we both hope that I'm wrong, but I could see it.