Predict The Pick v.2 - 2 - Giants

[Texas_OutLaw7]

This is the second version of this we will be doing now that must of the Free Agency Dust has settled. Like before, here are the rules:

• I will invite some posters to help sway the vote. 
• In the event of a tie, posts will help decide.
• Runoffs are solely at my discretion.
• Votes will last for roughly 24 hours (longer for weekend).
• No. Trades. You stay at this pick.

Our Draft So Far...

1. Cleveland Browns - Sam Darnold - QB - USC
2. New York Giants
3. New York Jets
4. Cleveland Browns 
5. Denver Broncos
6. Indianapolis Colts
7. Tampa Bay Buccaneers
8. Chicago Bears
9. San Francisco 49ers
10. Oakland Raiders
11. Miami Dolphins
12. Buffalo Bills
13. Washington Redskins
14. Green Bay Packers
15. Arizona Cardinals
16. Baltimore Ravens
17. LA Chargers
18. Seattle Seahawks
19. Dallas Cowboys

[Texas_OutLaw7]

Let's get some of teams fans in here to help sway the vote!

@Acgott, @mattbags2313, @YogiBiz, @GMENNATION, @Money, @bzane, @Gmen1985, @Gmen19851, @Gmen4ev, @gmen5821, @gmenback2back, @GmenSeattle, @LuckyNumber11, @Bballbkd, @ny92jefferis, @w4rrior723, @GEE MEN, @minutemancl

[Dallas94Ware]

They SHOULD pick Barkley as the best impact player in the draft. So I voted Barkley.

That said, they would be crazy to pass up a QB like Mayfield or Rosen, and just as crazy to pass on Chubb.

Honestly the Giants cant go wrong no matter what they do, unless they pick a QB that ends up being Akili Smith, Ryan Leaf, Joey Harrington, etc

[DaBoys]

I picked Barkley

[bzane]

@Texas_OutLaw7- I voted for Barkley as the Best Player Available. I have questions about all the QB's. I'll admit in my fat little heart I am hoping that the Giants trade down, and take Nelson or Chubb or somebody a little later, collecting extra picks- they have many needs- but I read the rules, No. Trades. Your sandbox, your rules. I burst into tears initially, but after I recovered I voted for Barkley.

[Glen]

Baker. Best QB prospect in the draft. 

Learn behind Eli. And continue to add pieces to the offensive line.

 

[Dallas94Ware]

7 minutes ago, Gmen4ev said:

Baker. Best QB prospect in the draft. 

Learn behind Eli. And continue to add pieces to the offensive line.

 

Baker wouldnt fit Shurmurs design, nor Dorseys MO. 

Rosen doesnt either.

If they go QB, look for the big play, big arm potential of Allen to be the pick

[w4rrior723]

I've been calling for Barkley for months and I'm not gonna change it now. I couldn't complain if it was a QB, though. Mayfield is my favorite in the draft and I think Darnold has the least risk associated with him out of the QBs so I'd be fine with him too. Barkley is my pick, though.

[Glen]

25 minutes ago, Dallas94Ware said:

Baker wouldnt fit Shurmurs design, nor Dorseys MO. 

Rosen doesnt either.

If they go QB, look for the big play, big arm potential of Allen to be the pick

Mayfield has one of the best big arms in the country..

What about him possibly doesn't fit into a system?

[flyingmonkey30]

I went Baker again. Never know when you'll be in a position to take a potential franchise QB next. In a perfect world (for them), trading back and getting Nelson would be ideal IMO

[DaBoys]

44 minutes ago, Gmen4ev said:

Mayfield has one of the best big arms in the country..

Haha you guys are hilarious. I hope with everything the Giants take Baker at 2. 

[Texas_OutLaw7]

...how am I the only one who thinks Rosen is the obvious answer?

[Dallas94Ware]

1 hour ago, Gmen4ev said:

Mayfield has one of the best big arms in the country..

What about him possibly doesn't fit into a system?

He has a great arm, but his height and need to stay mobile due to that height breaks what Shurmur has historically preferred of his offense. Quick drop, big time throw.

Also, Gettleman has a history of preferring the upside of the bigger arm, which is Allen.

I feel Mayfield will be the best of this class and an instant star, but basing it entirely on track record and scheme, Allen is the best fit for the Giants.

[Glen]

20 minutes ago, Dallas94Ware said:

He has a great arm, but his height and need to stay mobile due to that height breaks what Shurmur has historically preferred of his offense. Quick drop, big time throw.

Also, Dorsey has a history of preferring the upside of the bigger arm, which is Allen.

I feel Mayfield will be the best of this class and an instant star, but basing it entirely on track record and scheme, Allen is the best fit for the Giants.

Allen has a big arm but couldn't connect if his target was a trampoline.

I'd gladly take the guy who can connect on 85% of 50 yard bombs over the dude who could connect on 20% of 65 yarders.

Height is also a non issue. Something beat writers need to use to find issues with a prospect without actively scouting. 

[Glen]

1 hour ago, DaBoys said:

Haha you guys are hilarious. I hope with everything the Giants take Baker at 2. 

Solid rebuttal