Which WR Would You Take? Amongst the Elite. Minus. Rice/Moss/T.O/Megatron

[mdonnelly21]

Which WR Is The Best Amongst These WR's?

[cddolphin]

Best Career or best Right Now?

That would be either Fitzgerald or Brown

[mdonnelly21]

43 minutes ago, cddolphin said:

Best Career or best Right Now?

That would be either Fitzgerald or Brown

Best average year during the peak of their prime. 

[Danger]

Career-wise

1. Larry Fitzgerald
2. Marvin Harrison
3. Antonio Brown

 

(Antonio Brown has some time to move up this list though)

[Dome]

Fitzy for me. Especially if you knew the longevity you were getting with him.

[Pugger]

I went with Julio Jones.  He has the whole package -- size and speed to make him a nightmare to cover.

[mdonnelly21]

I had a feeling Fitz would win this. 

It's interesting thought because I always felt Fitz and Andre Johnson were 1A and 1B. 

AJ never gets even close the recognition that Fitz gets. 

And IMO it's because of his 09 post season which was Rice like which AJ never had. 

[sammymvpknight]

Fitz has been good for a long time...but Brown over the past half decade has been insane. I love Fitz...but I’m going with the ridiculous peak of Brown. 

[ET80]

Cris Carter for me.

[showtime]

I went with Michael Irvin.  Probably not the best WR on the list, but he had a lot of intangibles.  Irvin was a great leader and could make big time plays on the big stage.

[Malik]

On 11/22/2017 at 6:39 PM, Pugger said:

I went with Julio Jones.  He has the whole package -- size and speed to make him a nightmare to cover.

until you need to score.

[Kiwibrown]

tory holt for me, he could shred a defense at his peak. 

[tom cody]

Cris Carter.

[LuckIsGOAT]

Cliff Branch was basically Randy Moss before Randy Moss

[BleedTheClock]

Julio was my pick. He does everything at an insanely high level. His combo of size, speed, bailout catch radius ability, and route running is unmatched. Randy Moss would be the only WR I'd take over him off the top of my head. Sure there were more productive WR's, but I feel like the margin of error you have throwing it up to Julio or a Moss was off the charts. For example, as good as Antonio Brown is, I don't think he's going to climb the ladder and rip the ball away from a DB on a poorly thrown ball. You need to be accurate to get him the ball, no matter how open he gets. Julio's ability to separate is the same, plus he has the added bonus of being 6'3-6'4 and 225+ pounds. He's going to outmuscle just about every DB at the catch point.